Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

914World.com _ 914World Garage _ SOT: 930 Tach disassembly FT! is rattling in there?

Posted by: 914forme Nov 12 2017, 07:58 PM

So I have a 930 Tach, and every time you rolled it around it would rattle. I figured that someone dropped a bulb in it, but before I did something with itI needed to find out why it rattled so.

So let the autopsy begin. screwy.gif

930 Tach - so what makes these so damn expensive confused24.gif That little 1 bar boost gauge hosed in the face. confused24.gif

Attached Image

Tools of the trade - custom made for this job.

Attached Image

Opens gauge bezels like a can opener.

Attached Image

Just work your way around, at least 3/4 of the way.

All opened up piratenanner.gif

Attached Image

Attached Image

Flip it over remove three screws and one nut.

Attached Image

And removed from the can

Attached Image

More Detail just for you Tim beer.gif

Attached Image

Attached Image

Attached Image

Attached Image

Attached Image

Interior of the can

Attached Image

And now what was rattling around inside the tach.





poke.gif




Attached Image

I was right piratenanner.gif

happy11.gif Can't wait to see what happens to this now shades.gif

Posted by: timothy_nd28 Nov 12 2017, 08:29 PM

It's amazing how VDO stuck with their same board design of over 20 years. Instead of spending a few bucks by doing a simple revision of the circuit board so it profiles around the boost gauge, they just used what they had and crammed it all together. headbang.gif

Notice how they had to tilt the main board so it fits around the boost motor.

Posted by: mepstein Nov 12 2017, 08:36 PM

So how hard is it to substitute in a 914 gas gauge for the boost gauge.

Posted by: timothy_nd28 Nov 12 2017, 09:01 PM

Mechanically, I would just reuse the boost motor as the fuel gauge motor. You may need to change the resistor, but it's minor work. Re-stenciling the face plate would be the bigger issue.

The needle for the boost gauge isn't in its proper resting point, is your boost gauge broken? There should be a hair spring attached to the needle shaft so the needle returns back to zero.

Posted by: Spoke Nov 12 2017, 09:40 PM

QUOTE(914forme @ Nov 12 2017, 08:58 PM) *

...930 Tach - so what makes these so damn expensive confused24.gif


It's not just the 930 tach. Any Porsche part that starts with 930 is expensive.

I recently saw a valuation of the 1986 930 which puts the value of the car between $75k and $115k.

Posted by: 914forme Nov 13 2017, 11:19 AM

Well, here is the real skinny on this.

The boost gauge portion is not broke, it goes full right with out a resistance source. That is a big plus. So it is working as intended.

930 parts carry a cult status with them. I completely understand why, but just saying for what it is it is not that big of a deal. confused24.gif Certainly not worth the $$$.$$ being offered on Ebay for ar15.gif

Yes you can add a fuel gauge movement to the tach with the help of some friends. You can do it with a stock face plate and some carful drilling. and then a couple of tick marks, a vinyl stencil would most likely do the trick. and then a bit of 1 shot and a nice brush. Or 1 shot and an airbrush. Add a small spot for the low fuel warning light to go, and well you got a working gauge. And a very nice trick combo gauge.

Mark what are you running that you need more gauges?
Speedo
Tach - add 1
and a Quad or Triple gauge.
With the Quad you can have 5 (other) gauges, that is a lot of gauges.

My 914-6
Oil temp / Pressure, and fuel.
Guess I could add cylinder head temp or two for both banks and move the fuel over to the Tach. Quad is easily made via a 924 combo gauge.

My EG build
Oil Presuure
Oil Temp
Water Temp
Fuel
? - but if I use the 930 tach, then I would keep it a 930 tach and add positive pressure to the intake side. happy11.gif

Posted by: theer Nov 13 2017, 11:36 AM

Ooooo Stephen, that would look very nice in my Getty dash for Grey Matter.

Just sayin'
Tom

Posted by: mepstein Nov 13 2017, 11:54 AM

QUOTE(914forme @ Nov 13 2017, 12:19 PM) *

Well, here is the real skinny on this.

The boost gauge portion is not broke, it goes full right with out a resistance source. That is a big plus. So it is working as intended.

930 parts carry a cult status with them. I completely understand why, but just saying for what it is it is not that big of a deal. confused24.gif Certainly not worth the $$$.$$ being offered on Ebay for ar15.gif

Yes you can add a fuel gauge movement to the tach with the help of some friends. You can do it with a stock face plate and some carful drilling. and then a couple of tick marks, a vinyl stencil would most likely do the trick. and then a bit of 1 shot and a nice brush. Or 1 shot and an airbrush. Add a small spot for the low fuel warning light to go, and well you got a working gauge. And a very nice trick combo gauge.

Mark what are you running that you need more gauges?
Speedo
Tach - add 1
and a Quad or Triple gauge.
With the Quad you can have 5 (other) gauges, that is a lot of gauges.

My 914-6
Oil temp / Pressure, and fuel.
Guess I could add cylinder head temp or two for both banks and move the fuel over to the Tach. Quad is easily made via a 924 combo gauge.

My EG build
Oil Presuure
Oil Temp
Water Temp
Fuel
? - but if I use the 930 tach, then I would keep it a 930 tach and add positive pressure to the intake side. happy11.gif


I was just thinking of adding the gas gauge as an alternative to using a triple gauge. Something different.

But if people are getting a grand for these gauges, I should probably hold off for now.

Posted by: 914forme Nov 13 2017, 11:56 AM

QUOTE(theer @ Nov 13 2017, 12:36 PM) *

Ooooo Stephen, that would look very nice in my Getty dash for Grey Matter.

Just sayin'
Tom


I could do that, with some motivation, that is what made me get it out and see what was going on. with the rattle.

I'll PM you.

Posted by: 914forme Nov 13 2017, 05:58 PM

So now since Mark posed the question.

Yes you can put a stock fuel gauge into a 914 Tach, but a few items will have to change.

So I did a bit of quick disassembly tonight. And found this to be true.

Movements will work, the fuel gauge would read full on the left and empty on the right. You would have to add a tube for the low fuel warning light. There is enough room to do it.

Depending on the tach, the high beam indicator might need to be moved. On the back a hole would need to be filled. Face would need to be modified for the gauge movement and a proper brace made. Wiring for the power and ground would need to be spliced. Face would need to have the marks redone so the fuel gauge and the tach, moved ho beam indicator and others would look proper and factorish. And last but not least all re-assembled.

So here is what we are trying to stuff into a 914 Tach.

Attached Image

The backsides of the 930 Boost gauge and the 914 fuel gauge, Like Tim said very similar.

Attached Image

And now for the old man photoshop methods laugh.gif

Attached Image

I might need to start making the kit to do this.

Note this Tach face has the combined turn singles, and the high beam indicator out of the way. Prefer these as hopefully I am still smart enough to know which direction I have left my turn signal on. howard.gif

Posted by: mepstein Nov 13 2017, 06:21 PM

Stephen - is there any way to flip the gas gauge 180 degrees.

Posted by: Larry Hubby Nov 13 2017, 07:37 PM

You might try using a 911 fuel gauge, which reads the other way, the same as the 930 boost gauge. They're easy to come by and cheap since every 911 had one. The marks aren't a match to the linearity of the 914 gauge, but you're going to have to Photoshop them anyway, and the gauge does also have a warning light.

Posted by: iamchappy Nov 13 2017, 07:38 PM

Best solution would be to leave the gauge as is and install a turbocharged 930 into the teener.... thats what i would do......

Posted by: mepstein Nov 13 2017, 07:42 PM

QUOTE(iamchappy @ Nov 13 2017, 08:38 PM) *

Best solution would be to leave the gauge as is and install a turbocharged 930 into the teener.... thats what i would do......

smilie_pokal.gif

Posted by: 914forme Nov 13 2017, 07:46 PM

Mark, are you talking reverse rotation on the gauge? Or have the needle facing down to the bottom? Like it does in a stock gauge. The 2nd option would be no, as it would compete for real estate with the tach movements. And updating the tach movements to a smaller unit, causes some other issues that might not be favorable. The two needles could cross, and get locked like an old typewriter.

The other item, I have been thinking about reverse rotation and have not found my complete answer. Of course I might just have to test it out. It is a DC motor of sorts, so maybe just reversing the polarity would do it. laugh.gif But I doubt it will be that easy, otherwise every one would be doing it.


Posted by: timothy_nd28 Nov 13 2017, 08:10 PM

I love the type writer analogy! biggrin.gif Perhaps you could stagger the needles? Have the fuel gauge needle hugging the face plate, while the updated tach needle hanging out further, closer to the glass lens?

Posted by: timothy_nd28 Nov 13 2017, 08:14 PM

QUOTE(914forme @ Nov 13 2017, 06:46 PM) *

The other item, I have been thinking about reverse rotation and have not found my complete answer. Of course I might just have to test it out. It is a DC motor of sorts, so maybe just reversing the polarity would do it. laugh.gif But I doubt it will be that easy, otherwise every one would be doing it.


Not a easy task with this style motor. They have a hair spring attached to the shaft, you would need to flip the spring. Then, the gauge motors' case is grounded, you would need to remove the motor from its case and move some wires around. These wires are super thin, wouldn't be easy. I like Larry's idea with using a cheap 911 gauge motor.

Posted by: 914forme Nov 18 2017, 10:52 AM

Just ordered the film thank you Bob for the suggestion. Will give it a try and se how it does. Bob and I have exchanged several e-mails and we will give his method a try. As Bob says "Been dicking with this stuff since 1974" I'll pray.gif sage wisdom. http://www.914world.com/bbs2/index.php?showtopic=319837

First Project per Mark's request a 911 fuel gauge in a 914 Tach, nice and flat, and should put it to a good test.

Attached Image

I can add more hash marks or ticks in-between the numbers to make it closer to the Porsche / VDO tach of the time period. Not bad for a few minutes and not using a scanned face. That will be next, when day light is not burning.

Ran a test print, I'll add it to a piece of AL and cut it out and see if all the stuff is in the right spots adjust and finish the design up. then off to get them cut, with a bunch of other items. shades.gif

So yes Tim you will be getting a shipment soon.

Posted by: timothy_nd28 Nov 18 2017, 04:15 PM

Sounds good! Could you also do a face overlay with a voltmeter vs the fuel gauge?
I looked into the silk screening process and it did make my head spin, this is why I stuck with gauge lighting. biggrin.gif

Posted by: 914forme Nov 19 2017, 05:39 PM

Yes that is not an issue, I can pretty much do what every you want to put in there. As long as it comes in a 90 degree sweep, even 120 would fit, 180 degree sweeps just won't cut it.


Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)