Printable Version of Topic
Click here to view this topic in its original format
914World.com _ 914World Garage _ URO trim evaluation
Posted by: peteyd Jul 19 2018, 12:57 PM
Hello all,
I volunteered to evaluate 5 pieces from URO. They are all trim pieces.
First of all, I am not going to resell these on my website. I have no vested interest in the company. I personally have used all of the regular suppliers and I hold no allegiance to anyone.
Competition creates quality. At Restoration Design we deal with it just as much as anyone else. It can be frustrating, but in the end it only make us work harder to have better quality parts.
These are the pieces that I reviewed. I used original Porsche rubber to test the fit.
914 531 865 10 (This fits the left side targa top; has a very slight curve to it.)
914 531 866 10 (This fits the right side targa top; has a very slight curve to it.)
I test fit these on a /6 that we are assembling here, so its my desire to have quality pieces put on it.
The curve matched the original well. Also the screw holes are all in the correct location.
The only issue I have with this piece was that I had to file the edge of the trim to slide the rubber seal in. This did not affect the appearance from the outside.
914 531 827 10 (This fits the left B-pillar; has a pronounced curve to it.)
914 531 828 10 (This fits the right B-pillar; has a pronounced curve to it.)
These pieces match up to originals well. The curve is correct and the holes are in the proper location. The factory had crimped the edges in several spots to hold the rubber in. These repros don't have the crimp, and in my opinion rightly so, because the end user needs to do the crimp once the rubber is installed.
I also had to file the edges to slide the rubber in. 
914 559 103 10 (Rear outer roll bar mounding)
This piece is also very nice in appearance. The one knock would be the curvature is slightly off from the original. It was not hard to flex it to the right curve while installing it though.
In conclusion, these are very nice parts, and they will definitely be staying on this car. I believe that I provided enough photos for anyone else to form their own opinion as well, but if you desire any other photos let me know.
Pete
Posted by: 914Sixer Jul 19 2018, 01:51 PM
Good, fair review. More new parts to choose from.
Posted by: tygaboy Jul 19 2018, 01:54 PM
Pete - Nice review. Thanks for all the support you provide our community!
Posted by: mb911 Jul 19 2018, 02:09 PM
Very nice.. I like that uro is stepping up the quality on so many parts.
Are they also making rear roll bar trim that is super expensive for what it is?
Posted by: peteyd Jul 19 2018, 02:27 PM
Very nice.. I like that uro is stepping up the quality on so many parts.
Are they also making rear roll bar trim that is super expensive for what it is?
I have no idea what they have coming up. Maybe Drew, the UROpartsman can chime in to what is coming to the market in the near future.
Pete
Posted by: UROpartsman Jul 19 2018, 06:29 PM
Great job on the review Pete, thank you!
The original trim has the same 90-degree edge, we're guessing the assembly line probably had a match-fit nylon funnel or some kind of tool to help slide the rubber into the track without having to chamfer the end of the trim.
Absolutely right, the originals were staked on the assembly line after the rubber was installed. We have genuine NOS pieces for reference, and they are not crimped.
Indeed we are making the "rear sail trim" / "buttress trim", and hope to have it available this fall! These pieces have several compound curves and are extremely difficult to make, so it's taking a lot of development time and effort. We're making good progress though. And there's more good news; we should also have the trim for the A-pillars available around the same time.
Posted by: sb914 Jul 19 2018, 08:35 PM
Great job on the review Pete, thank you!
The original trim has the same 90-degree edge, we're guessing the assembly line probably had a match-fit nylon funnel or some kind of tool to help slide the rubber into the track without having to chamfer the end of the trim.
Absolutely right, the originals were staked on the assembly line after the rubber was installed. We have genuine NOS pieces for reference, and they are not crimped.
Indeed we are, and hope to have them available this fall! These pieces have several compound curves and are extremely difficult to make, so it's taking a lot of development time and effort. We're making good progress though.
And there's more good news; we should also have the trim for the A-pillars available around the same time.
Posted by: Rob-O Jul 20 2018, 12:02 AM
Great job on the review Pete, thank you!
The original trim has the same 90-degree edge, we're guessing the assembly line probably had a match-fit nylon funnel or some kind of tool to help slide the rubber into the track without having to chamfer the end of the trim.
Absolutely right, the originals were staked on the assembly line after the rubber was installed. We have genuine NOS pieces for reference, and they are not crimped.
Indeed we are, and hope to have them available this fall! These pieces have several compound curves and are extremely difficult to make, so it's taking a lot of development time and effort. We're making good progress though.
And there's more good news; we should also have the trim for the A-pillars available around the same time.
That’s great news. I just purchased the rear targa trim straight from Porsche. $220 something for each, left and right. Right fit marginally well, left not at all. The curve was all wrong. Even if you could bend it (wasn’t going to take that chance with a brand new piece of aluminum I wouldn’t be able to return if I bent the snot out of it trying to get it to fit. Sierra Madre sent me another left side and it too didn’t fit. If it’s not hijacking a thread I’ll post my pics and comments on where and why the factory part didn’t fit.
I’m trying to go back to the original look. My trim is either blacked out or painted the same color as the car.
Posted by: injunmort Jul 20 2018, 06:41 AM
maybe off topic a little, but I have used uro parts on my bmw's for over 10 years and have been very satisfied with the parts. I have found that proper installation goes along way towards partslife, no matter who made it. I would not hesitate to use uro parts on my 914's. fwiw.
Posted by: bdstone914 Jul 20 2018, 08:38 AM
Good review. The complete test will include how the top fits to the windows and how the trim meets the top to seal. I may have missed it but whose seal did you use? That could also affect the final fit.
Bruce
Posted by: UROpartsman Jul 20 2018, 09:49 AM
It's always a challenge when deciding to make something the same as OE, or change the design a bit attempting to improve it. If you change it, you'll likely enrage the purists. If you make it the same as OE, there might be some grumbling, but it will be directed at the original designer instead. It's a tough call, made on a case-by-case basis.
Posted by: raynekat Jul 20 2018, 11:10 AM
I'll definitely want some of the A pillar trim when it's complete.
Also, where do you buy the outer roll bar molding: 914.559.103.10 ???
Posted by: UROpartsman Jul 20 2018, 11:32 AM
dr914@autoatlanta can confirm, but this is probably it: http://www.autoatlanta.com/Porsche-Used-Upper-Rear-Rollbar-Chrome-Parts-PN-R91455910310.html
Sierra Madre just added it as well: http://www.sierramadrecollection.com/Targa-Top-Center-Molding-914-70-76-p27001.html
Posted by: Larmo63 Jul 20 2018, 10:44 PM
I had a very good outcome on a URO part that they made good on. Good communication and really great follow-up.
Posted by: defianty Jul 21 2018, 01:03 AM
Is there anywhere in the UK or Europe I can order URO parts from?
Posted by: mepstein Jul 21 2018, 07:17 AM
Is there anywhere in the UK or Europe I can order URO parts from?
SSF caries these parts and all the other URO parts. SSF is a very large Porsche parts distributor that many shop like ours order from. So check with a shop near you if they order from SSF. It might be a lot less for shipping if they have a Europe warehouse.
Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)