hi I was wondering if you had a choice between the subaru engine and the 911 engine which one would you choose? and why?
Tricky one.....
or
Depends on which subaru engine and which 911 engine
WRX STi versus a 2.7 liter stud puller 911? easy... Subaru engine...
1.6 liter Subaru versus 996 twin turbo? easy.. Porsche engine...
For a closer match, the 2.5 naturally aspirated Subaru engine and 2.7 liter 911 6 are a closer match in performance. As to which is better it depends on your preference. I prefer the Subaru because its a more modern engine, is cheaper, and weighs considerably less. However it is water cooled, and doesn't have the sounds of a 6, nor does it strictly belong in the 'family.'
-Tony
I'd guess that "most" of the Suby conversion people (I'd say 99%) picked the subaru motor based on it being more cost effective....the subaru motor is cheap and less expensive to install.....
if money was no object, 911 3.6 motor hands down would be the number one choice I'd say...well at least for me it would be.
I'd do a 911 engine if it wasn't for cost. I can buy a some thousand mile WRX engine any day of the week for under $1000. If I had a 911 engine - it would cost me $8k minimum to rebuild it. I could have 8 subaru motors for that.
The Subie motor is also lighter. It would be interesting to know if it's still lighter after it's full of water and radiators and shit.
Oh yeah - and it still costs about 8k to rebuild a 2.0 120-150hp 911 motor. You could probably rebuild the 1.6 subie motor for 1k and outrun the 6, especially if you put a blower on it.
My WRX motor sounds like a 914-4 engine.
The 911 engine sounds much better, though there can be too much of a good thing. The fan is very close to the firewall, and makes quite a racket. However, doing a valve adjustment on a 911 engine in a 914 is even more of a PITA than doing one on a /4, whereas the Soob will rarely need that particular bit of attention. The Soob engine would be cheaper to do, though a 3.0 (or even a 2.7) would be hard to turn down.
Money says Soob, heart says 911.
QUOTE (lapuwali @ Dec 5 2005, 12:31 PM) |
****** However, doing a valve adjustment on a 911 engine in a 914 is even more of a PITA than doing one on a /4, *********** |
I like the 4 banger Subie motor enuff that it would be a slam dunk for the replacement of a blowed up T-4. I'm considering building one for a driver....at some distant point in the future.
As for the replacement of a 6....
Maybe an sti motor "rather" than a 911 6 conversion.... the rest are dog meat. If you wanna prove me wrong, come play. Some STI guys (the whole car) give me a hard time at AX, but my 914 is prettier
QUOTE (Mueller @ Dec 5 2005, 12:11 PM) |
911 3.6 motor hands down would be the number one choice I'd say... |
I'd say to pick up a used 911SC or Carrera 3.2 motor out of a wreck. Be a lot cheaper than a rebuilt one. There is nothing like the wail of an air-cooled motor and 6 thoats worth of webers right behind your ears! Makes old women blush, young women giggle and mothers grab hold of their daughters!
Oh yeah, get the sport exhaust and bring some ear plugs!
Yes JP, yours is prettier on the outside and in the engine compartment
What engine do you have in your car now?
Attached image(s)
Hay, that's an old pic. It sure was pretty back in 2001, eh?
Still that same old 2.7L with more cam & compression than it came to me with. I can't seem to break it...yes, I'm knocking wood.
that one is pretty but so would this one, close to my palnned power plant!
Attached image(s)
there is a question that needs to be asked first: what do you want to do with your car? PCA will not be thrilled w/ your Suby choice. what class would you be in with SCCA?
I love my V8 914 but mt 2.0 will bring me more smiles per mile on teh track. I would have to pick teh Porsche 6
I travel 3-4 days a week and I have a second driver coming up the line, my crew is now becoming a driver.
NASA GTS , power to weight classes only with german mark cars
DE's.
I can't afford to lose a porsche motor at the track and expect to return in any kind of short order, 2.0liter long block suby, $600-1000... I can afford to keep one prep'ed and in the garage.
Track junkie yes, racing is a little out of reach....
SCCA road racing would prolly put put you in "other".....bend over & kiss your ass goodby.
SCCA AX...WAG E Mod
PCA AX...if they let ya run......OTP
Our ORPCA DE....come play against the Pcars.
At many PCA region's DEs you will not be welcome by the stuck up SOBs
But for a street car, who cares? You could even plumb in heat that heats and have a nice modern reliable engine.
$.02 cents I dropped 10k into parts for my 3.0 and had a buddy build it for free. I then had to sell the mortor to move. After looking at all of the recipts for that monster, vs the 3k it looks like it is going to take for my autox/street car. my $ are going to a suby and I will take the $ i saved and build my wife a bad ass Ghia
QUOTE (J P Stein @ Dec 5 2005, 08:06 PM) |
At many PCA region's DEs you will not be welcome by the stuck up SOBs But for a street car, who cares? You could even plumb in heat that heats and have a nice modern reliable engine. |
I spent the last few months really grappling with this question. Ultimately, it was a couple of things that made my decision for me. I was strongly influenced by my desire to be able to participate in PCA events. Being in the Porsche business, there was a pretty strong need to be able to go to those events and represent our shop. And then the purist in me took over from there. I decided that I wanted to make my 914 what it should have been from the factory. I realize that I am not going to have as modern or as powerful an engine as the guys doing 3.0, 3.2 or 3.6l conversions. But I am going to go with a 2.4l I just like that engine, and it seems period correct to me.
And this all comes from a die hard Subaru guy. I have a very built 2.5RS as my daily driver. And I have done WRX engine swaps on early Subarus, in addition to a number of different bastard builds of various head and block combinations, both turbo and non-turbo. With half a dozen longblocks in the garage, including an early JDM STi engine, it would be really easy to just drop a Subaru engine into my car. But I am going to have to go the more expensive and purist route and do a 914-6 build...
QUOTE (brant @ Dec 6 2005, 07:37 AM) |
locally... I don't think its a matter of being stuck up. Its just that most events sell out and, its used as a way to limit applicants somewhat. $.02 |
QUOTE (fiid @ Dec 6 2005, 11:10 AM) | ||
I respectfully disagree. I've had plenty of discussions with plenty stuckup PCA people that just don't like conversions because they aren't pure Porsche. I always get attitude about the Subaru conversion,very few of these guys are willing to understand the reasoning behind it, or to appreciate some of the tech that went into getting it running. I think most of these guys are still trying to get over the fact that 914s are allowed in the Porsche club because they think it's NARP. I've never gotten the impression that they are turning away "all porsche" vehicles because the events are full, I think that's just an excuse. The other excuse I've heard is: Mr Bloggs in his (probably gorgeous) 914 1.7 doesn't want to get beaten at (insert event here) by a small block chevy powered 917 replica. Personally - I'd f*****g love to get whaled on by said 917. I love watching Radicals and other totally tricked out kit ripping around the track and I don't give a rats ass if it's faster than me. I'm in it to take part and to enjoy the spirit of motorsport. To me that's about innovation and taking part, and not staring down your nose. |
I suspect there's a lot of regional differences too - yeah. I only have experience with GGR-PCA, and to be clear - I have only gotten attitude from a very small minority of people.
Everyone else in the group seems to be really awesome.
Fortunately we also have a number of alternative clubs as well.
How do you think a 280HP turbo 4 banger would stack up against the 280HP 6 with 50K in it??
QUOTE (fiid @ Dec 6 2005, 11:38 AM) |
How do you think a 280HP turbo 4 banger would stack up against the 280HP 6 with 50K in it?? |
I really thankful for all of your guys responces. I myself want my car just to be fast, reliable, and most of all fun. I find that I don't have the money to pay for a 6 cylinder porsche engine with 90k miles on it for 3,500 right now. I've been building my car for about 3 years now with our budget. I'm restored just about everything from transmission to rebuilding a master cylinder. I got a bad rebuilt motor in irwindale,ca on which I get very low compression, 80 lbs per cylinder which is about half of what it should be.I don't find myself going to races anytime soon maybe in a few years, but I just want a pretty good motor that I know will be somewhat fast and reliable. also do you think I should just redo the heads on my 4 cylinder or just save and get the subaru conversion? THanks for all of your help
I really wanted to put a Porsche engine in my 914 but to achieve the performance that I was looking for would have been too much money. Instead I went with an engine that will make 400-450 RWHP / 350-400 lb-ft torque in N/A form, have a 9000 rpm redline, weigh 315 lbs and has dimensions of 26.5" L x 21.5" W x 20.5" H. Initial purchase price of the engine is $3500US with a rebuild costing around $2000US each if I do it. Now if you could find me a Porsche engine that comes close to these numbers let me know and I'll hunt one down for my project. Otherwise it's onwards and upwards with my 3 rotor conversion. The cool thing is it'll still sound like an exotic and should be fairly unique in the world. Here's a picture of the triple throttle body assembly I got for it the other day:
Attached image(s)
QUOTE (lfdrumz0929 @ Dec 6 2005, 11:00 AM) |
I really thankful for all of your guys responces. I myself want my car just to be fast, reliable, and most of all fun. I find that I don't have the money to pay for a 6 cylinder porsche engine with 90k miles on it for 3,500 right now. I've been building my car for about 3 years now with our budget. I'm restored just about everything from transmission to rebuilding a master cylinder. I got a bad rebuilt motor in irwindale,ca on which I get very low compression, 80 lbs per cylinder which is about half of what it should be.I don't find myself going to races anytime soon maybe in a few years, but I just want a pretty good motor that I know will be somewhat fast and reliable. also do you think I should just redo the heads on my 4 cylinder or just save and get the subaru conversion? THanks for all of your help |
While on the topic of Subaru engines, has anyone converted to a Subaru engine and installed air conditioning? Love driving the 914 but in the summer I don't like arriving at my destination in a sweat.
Last summer a lunchtime errand run to Home Depot, Best Buy, and Staples in 85F sunny weather put me back at work drenched.
Spoke
I don't think anyone's done it yet, but that doesn't mean it's not possible or even reasonably easy to do once you have it running.
There are 2 main challenges to putting A/C in a stock 914:
1) it's hard to fit all the air plumbing and the heat exchanger to the inside of the car.
2) it's tricky to get the unit bolted up to the engine becuase of the air ducting for engine cooling.
2 is made easier by the subaru engine since they all come from the factory with AC pumps.
The 2.5l conversions that are running the radiator in the trunk depend on flipping the intake manifold around, which requires moving the alternator. As far as I know - ther alternator in these setups goes where the air conditioning pump goes on a stock subie engine - which might make it harder - plus there's just less room around due to the radiator being there.
So: challenges, but not impossible.
QUOTE (fiid @ Dec 5 2005, 11:26 AM) |
I'd do a 911 engine if it wasn't for cost. I can buy a some thousand mile WRX engine any day of the week for under $1000. If I had a 911 engine - it would cost me $8k minimum to rebuild it. I could have 8 subaru motors for that. The Subie motor is also lighter. It would be interesting to know if it's still lighter after it's full of water and radiators and shit. |
QUOTE (Spoke @ Dec 7 2005, 05:33 PM) |
While on the topic of Subaru engines, has anyone converted to a Subaru engine and installed air conditioning? Love driving the 914 but in the summer I don't like arriving at my destination in a sweat. Last summer a lunchtime errand run to Home Depot, Best Buy, and Staples in 85F sunny weather put me back at work drenched. Spoke |
Youz guys crack me up.
Ya'll run on & on about how much the 911 motor costs so much, expensive to rebuild, how you can get more-better-cheeper with a __________(fill in the blank).
So, let's see em' on the road or track.....anywhere but in your dreams.
Yet, for all the poor mouthing, guys are sticking the beauty
from the 9elbmen in behind their shoulders all the time.....how stupid are we idots? Even more plan on it ....from what I read here. WTF?
There is nothing wrong, to my way of thinking, with stuffing what ever the hell you want back there. Infering or implying that your set-up is gonna be better, faster,cheeper, yada is
absurd....till you can prove it's than a decent 6. The nifty pictures of parts catagory is already by Quarl.....and nice pile it is, so I ain't impressed by wannabes.
QUOTE |
So, let's see em' on the road or track.....anywhere but in your dreams. |
QUOTE |
so I ain't impressed by wannabes. |
JP.
Honestly. One of the reasons Im building my car the way it will be will be to compete with the 6 people that claim there is nothing close.
Ie You and Trekkor.
Unfortunately, I dont make, or have enough money to put into my car what you have in your suspension and tires and chassis.
So, it will continue to take a while.
And there are a few v8 track cars out there.
Harry (guy with the purple car) tracks his car, but its in for a rebuild right now.
Then theres the Ultimate v8 car (silver one, always pictures of it)
They do pretty well in my understanding.
Main reason that they dont go on the track is that PCA does not allow them to run, and SCCA bumps moderate v8 guys into very high classes. So unless the car is setup and capable of TTOD, then they are screwed.
Im a wanabe.. I think JP is not impressed with me
QUOTE (Andyrew @ Dec 8 2005, 05:58 PM) |
JP. Honestly. One of the reasons Im building my car the way it will be will be to compete with the 6 people that claim there is nothing close. Ie You and Trekkor. Unfortunately, I dont make, or have enough money to put into my car what you have in your suspension and tires and chassis. So, it will continue to take a while. And there are a few v8 track cars out there. Harry (guy with the purple car) tracks his car, but its in for a rebuild right now. Then theres the Ultimate v8 car (silver one, always pictures of it) They do pretty well in my understanding. Main reason that they dont go on the track is that PCA does not allow them to run, and SCCA bumps moderate v8 guys into very high classes. So unless the car is setup and capable of TTOD, then they are screwed. Im a wanabe.. I think JP is not impressed with me |
QUOTE (Andyrew @ Dec 8 2005, 04:58 PM) |
JP. Honestly. One of the reasons Im building my car the way it will be will be to compete with the 6 people that claim there is nothing close. Ie You and Trekkor. Unfortunately, I dont make, or have enough money to put into my car what you have in your suspension and tires and chassis. So, it will continue to take a while. And there are a few v8 track cars out there. Harry (guy with the purple car) tracks his car, but its in for a rebuild right now. Then theres the Ultimate v8 car (silver one, always pictures of it) They do pretty well in my understanding. Main reason that they dont go on the track is that PCA does not allow them to run, and SCCA bumps moderate v8 guys into very high classes. So unless the car is setup and capable of TTOD, then they are screwed. Im a wanabe.. I think JP is not impressed with me |
Does it matter if the car actually runs? A Porsche six conversion has become a pretty much bolt on project, not so with other engines. Unless you have a thing about being a pioneer, the degree of fabrication and modification is going to be less with a tried and true conversion. Not to dismiss the probability of actually driving the car within your lifetime
If you stick with a Porsche engine you should be able to keep a higher resale value, if that's important. If you put something besides an air (oil)cooled engine in the car it will probably bring less than whatever you paid for the car originally, and certainly not as much as you've dumped into it (if that's a consideration), building your water cooled conversion. Only the nicest V8 cars bring decent money, whereas good conversions hold up pretty well.
The nice thing about a 914 (despite lack of a/c) is the useability. You can put a ton of stuff in the car (two sets of clubs in the back and a playmate cooler up front). I'm no fan of any conversion that eats up front trunk space, regardless of what you are cooling.
I say go with a Carrera 3.2 motronic engine. You don't want a 3.6, there's too much auxillary bs to deal with (did ya know they don't have an oil cooler on the engine like all prior 911 engines?), that you won't run into with a earlier flat six.
This is just what you asked for though, an opinion. I'm not saying I'm right or wrong, this is just my opinion. It is based on some experience, but I've certainly been wrong before, and you've pretty much gotten what you've paid for
QUOTE (9146986 @ Dec 9 2005, 07:10 AM) |
I say go with a Carrera 3.2 motronic engine. You don't want a 3.6, there's too much auxillary bs to deal with (did ya know they don't have an oil cooler on the engine like all prior 911 engines?), that you won't run into with a earlier flat six. |
sorry to put this question in here but this subaru swap sounds interesting....
how much "customizing " do you have to do to the 914 to squeeze one in?
mike
QUOTE |
how much "customizing " do you have to do to the 914 to squeeze one in? |
so are you using the subaru trans ?
QUOTE (J P Stein @ Dec 8 2005, 04:16 PM) |
Youz guys crack me up. Ya'll run on & on about how much the 911 motor costs so much, expensive to rebuild, how you can get more-better-cheeper with a __________(fill in the blank). So, let's see em' on the road or track.....anywhere but in your dreams. Yet, for all the poor mouthing, guys are sticking the beauty from the 9elbmen in behind their shoulders all the time.....how stupid are we idots? Even more plan on it ....from what I read here. WTF? |
QUOTE |
so are you using the subaru trans ? |
Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)