Today I decide to tackle the problem. I checked the float level, make sure all the jets are clean, verify the jets have the correct numbers, etc... Nothing appears wrong. So I decide to start over and baseline all the adjustments. I had already pulled the left air cleaner assembly, so I go ahead and pull the right one.
WTF!!!
ARRUUGGHH!!!

I installed the f***ing Aux venturis upside down on the left carb when I rejetted it.



So I pull it apart, and change the Aux venturis. I get it as warm as possible and adjust it. It idles much better (well, as good as can be expected with S cams and worn throttle shafts). It even sits there and blows neat little smoke rings while warming up.
I get the linkage adjusted and take it out for a drive... WOO HOO!!! It pulls almost as good as it did with the MFI.
So maybe now I can get better than 10 mpg on my trip to work.
As I said, I am officially stupid!!!!