QUOTE(Travis Neff @ Dec 24 2009, 02:23 AM)
...Some say they flex a bunch and the weight savings that far low in the chassis doesn't bring a lot of return.
I wouldn't say they flex 'a bunch.' But they aren't as stiff as the steel ones. Tradeoffs. If you've got a track car that runs slicks and placing lots of stress it will contribute to a certain vagueness where you're looking for repeatable precision.
For a street car or street-tire AX car it's less clear. Losing weight down low doesn't buy you as much as weight up high, but weight is weight, and you still have to accelerate it and brake it.
Porsche originally went to the aluminum crossmember in part because saving every gram was important when they made the Carrera RS - but also because they were cheaper to make a single casting than a steel weldment. They used the aluminum crossmember in the lightweight RS's - and then went back to the steel ones for the RSRs.
So it depends on what you're looking for. If you're looking to replace a bent or rusted steel piece and found an aluminum part cheap - go for it. If you're looking at weight reduction as a benefit, it couldn't hurt. If you're thinking it'll be the be the ultimate upgrade - maybe not.
If you go that way and don't like it, there is no lack of steel ones to replace it with...