Dan - Have you tried these before?
http://www.vwispwest.com/product.php?isppr...;part=GA-CAP914I suggest them since you went with the non-OE polished Fuchs on your resto.
SoCalAndy has them on his Yellow 72 COM from Nov/Oct 09 with no sizing problems, but John/avidfan has had to clearance them on the outside. Otherwise they look pretty close to stock/OE but won't dent up like the lighter/thinner OE ones.
I got a set on evil-bay of OEM ones but pricey ($75 each NIB/NOS), but I think that AA carries either OE ones, NOS or maybe SS repros (ask George which).