Just bought a wiper motor off a 2003 Boxster to see how interchangeable they are with ours. Modern speed wipers is on my list of things to make the 914 wife-worthy.
Pictures and thoughts once the part arrives later this week.
*Looked a Boxster seat belts as well.
SirAndy
Jul 17 2012, 02:22 PM
CG-914
Jul 17 2012, 02:38 PM
good idea if its going to work! I know the 996 motor for the sunroof fits in an 73 911
I just wonder at the steering wheel the wiper switch!!!
I defiantly would not want the boxster switch to replace a good looking 914 one!
aharder
Jul 17 2012, 02:51 PM
The wiper motor is on my list of to-do's I've got plenty on time because the priority rating is sitting @ 99.
mrbubblehead
Jul 17 2012, 04:41 PM
Mike Bellis
Jul 17 2012, 09:41 PM
Thinking about using the VW Passat one on mine. Steering column swap too, along with turn signal stuff...
McMark
Jul 17 2012, 10:32 PM
I just bought the bare motor and I'm hoping it will connect to the 914 linkage and be a simple swap, yet still improve upon the stock motor.
scott_in_nh
Jul 19 2012, 02:04 PM
a couple of good coats of Rain-X + some speed and who needs wipers?
A delay would be nice, but that is a whole lot of work for very little effect imo
SirAndy
Jul 19 2012, 02:14 PM
QUOTE(scott_in_nh @ Jul 19 2012, 01:04 PM)
A delay would be nice, but that is a whole lot of work for very little effect imo
Just use the stock intermittent relay for the stock wipers ...
jimsfolly
Jul 19 2012, 02:15 PM
I added a delay box from JCW for about $25, gives a 2-20 variable delay... can't live without an intermittent wiper in the Pacific Northwet.
Not sure just swapping the motor will do anything without a the switch to go with it... waiting to someone to step up and update to a modern control stalk set...both lights and wipers
76-914
Jul 19 2012, 02:48 PM
QUOTE(McMark @ Jul 17 2012, 09:32 PM)
I just bought the bare motor and I'm hoping it will connect to the 914 linkage and be a simple swap, yet still improve upon the stock motor.
To quote Col. Klink, "Vely interestink."
wingnut86
Jul 19 2012, 07:15 PM
Mike,
What years of Passat? Or are you just going to fabricate anything that pops up during the swap?
tanks...
ruby914
Jul 19 2012, 08:00 PM
QUOTE(jimsfolly @ Jul 19 2012, 01:15 PM)
I added a delay box from JCW for about $25, gives a 2-20 variable delay... can't live without an intermittent wiper in the Pacific Northwet.
Not sure just swapping the motor will do anything without a the switch to go with it... waiting to someone to step up and update to a modern control stalk set...both lights and wipers
I was thinking the same. I used all the suby wiring I could. With the WRX intermittent switch to the 914 motor all is good.
IronHillRestorations
Jul 20 2012, 07:30 AM
FWIW, there's a plug in VW intermittent wiper relay that's plug and play for the early Boxsters, the VW part number is 357 955 531 or 1HM 955 531B. It might take one of our electrical engineers to make it work, but I'm betting it wouldn't be too hard.
jimsfolly
Jul 20 2012, 10:47 AM
QUOTE(ruby914 @ Jul 19 2012, 07:00 PM)
QUOTE(jimsfolly @ Jul 19 2012, 01:15 PM)
I added a delay box from JCW for about $25, gives a 2-20 variable delay... can't live without an intermittent wiper in the Pacific Northwet.
Not sure just swapping the motor will do anything without a the switch to go with it... waiting to someone to step up and update to a modern control stalk set...both lights and wipers
I was thinking the same. I used all the suby wiring I could. With the WRX intermittent switch to the 914 motor all is good.
did you use the wiper/light switch assembly as is? haven't messed with mine since I did the washer switch upgrade... is it much of a hack to get the assembly to replace the stock setup?
really want a modern stalk wiper/light switch setup since my new dash design doesn't support the factory panel mounted switches...
McMark
Jul 20 2012, 04:58 PM
Tracking says it was delivered. I get to play on Sunday.
effutuo101
Jul 20 2012, 05:02 PM
Half way through a 2004 VW steering swap. It is a lot of work if you want to maintain the adjustability.
ruby914
Jul 20 2012, 05:25 PM
QUOTE(jimsfolly @ Jul 20 2012, 09:47 AM)
QUOTE(ruby914 @ Jul 19 2012, 07:00 PM)
QUOTE(jimsfolly @ Jul 19 2012, 01:15 PM)
I added a delay box from JCW for about $25, gives a 2-20 variable delay... can't live without an intermittent wiper in the Pacific Northwet.
Not sure just swapping the motor will do anything without a the switch to go with it... waiting to someone to step up and update to a modern control stalk set...both lights and wipers
I was thinking the same. I used all the suby wiring I could. With the WRX intermittent switch to the 914 motor all is good.
did you use the wiper/light switch assembly as is? haven't messed with mine since I did the washer switch upgrade... is it much of a hack to get the assembly to replace the stock setup?
really want a modern stalk wiper/light switch setup since my new dash design doesn't support the factory panel mounted switches...
I put in the complete steering column, gauge cluster, light and wiper controls from the WRX. Yes, it is a lot of work. I am not unhappy with the speed of mine but swapping motor you may get some more speed? That would not hurt.
jimsfolly
Jul 20 2012, 06:41 PM
QUOTE(ruby914 @ Jul 20 2012, 04:25 PM)
QUOTE(jimsfolly @ Jul 20 2012, 09:47 AM)
QUOTE(ruby914 @ Jul 19 2012, 07:00 PM)
QUOTE(jimsfolly @ Jul 19 2012, 01:15 PM)
I added a delay box from JCW for about $25, gives a 2-20 variable delay... can't live without an intermittent wiper in the Pacific Northwet.
Not sure just swapping the motor will do anything without a the switch to go with it... waiting to someone to step up and update to a modern control stalk set...both lights and wipers
I was thinking the same. I used all the suby wiring I could. With the WRX intermittent switch to the 914 motor all is good.
did you use the wiper/light switch assembly as is? haven't messed with mine since I did the washer switch upgrade... is it much of a hack to get the assembly to replace the stock setup?
really want a modern stalk wiper/light switch setup since my new dash design doesn't support the factory panel mounted switches...
I put in the complete steering column, gauge cluster, light and wiper controls from the WRX. Yes, it is a lot of work. I am not unhappy with the speed of mine but swapping motor you may get some more speed? That would not hurt.
How did you adapt to the intermediate shaft? Does the Subaru use 36 spline 16mm? I've been looking at use an 'EZ Fit'variable length shaft to allow offsetting the column left to line up with my NSX seats.
The 240Z guys use mid-90's Honda motors and IIRC, they are almost plug-and-play. Something about the electrical connections has to be adapted... They were the same era, maybe the same supplier?
- The wiper linkage arm on the Boxster is longer (the gold piece below, pic from boxster). This means the 914 pieces may move faster then the Boxster. But that's a good thing. I can slow down a motor, but I can't speed it up.
- The bolts and drive shaft on the 914 motor are longer to allow the motor to clear the bracket in two place. Click to view attachment
First the 914 bracket will bump into the Boxster motor. This can be clearanced easily with a grinder. Click to view attachment
The second is the linkage drive arm will bump into the rubber mount. There is a little bit the can be removed from the arm and a little bit that can be removed from the rubber mount. This should clear. Worse case scenario, I can cut and weld the drive arm to have it run higher up. I don't want to do this because that will also make some undesirable forces that could lead to unexpected failure later on in life. Click to view attachment
- Wiring The red wire is the fast speed and the green wire is the slow speed (motor body is ground). The three unwired connections are the motor park connections. They look like simple pass through connections (which is what I thought they were), but I took off the cover and discovered connections inside that correspond with the connections outside. The center pin (#2) is the common rail. The inside pin (#3) is disconnected at the park location, but connected the rest of the rotation. The outside pin (#1) is connected at park and disconnected the rest of the rotation. Click to view attachment
McMark
Jul 22 2012, 11:10 AM
Here's a couple shots with the cover off. I noticed an important piece of info I missed the first time. Connection #1 is also grounded to the motor body full time. The implication is that those 'park' connections shouldn't be run as 12v switched. The need to be a ground connection off of a relay. Which makes sense.
One note that may not be obvious because of the grease. The metallic portion set into the white plastic is one solid piece of metal.
Mike Bellis
Jul 22 2012, 11:38 AM
Great photos! I can really see all the dirt and grime.
If you can do the motor swap, and figure out how to incorporate that intermittent wiper relay, this could the ultimate 914 wiper upgrade. Great work Mark!!
McMark
Jul 22 2012, 02:02 PM
Here's an image from Kansas_914's build showing the wiring.
To translate:
Boxster Motor ----> 914 wiring red ----> black/purple green ----> black/blue 1 ----> empty/no wire 2 ----> green/white 3 ----> red/black
This wiring isn't confirmed - just based on research. Use at your own risk.
smj
Jul 22 2012, 04:13 PM
QUOTE(McMark @ Jul 22 2012, 08:42 AM)
- The bolts and drive shaft on the 914 motor are longer to allow the motor to clear the bracket in two place.
First the 914 bracket will bump into the Boxster motor. This can be clearanced easily with a grinder.
The second is the linkage drive arm will bump into the rubber mount. There is a little bit the can be removed from the arm and a little bit that can be removed from the rubber mount. This should clear. Worse case scenario, I can cut and weld the drive arm to have it run higher up. I don't want to do this because that will also make some undesirable forces that could lead to unexpected failure later on in life.
Probably a stupid question, but you've got to go with your strengths in life: Why can't you use spacers and longer bolts for mounting, and a widget to extend the drive shaft?
McMark
Jul 22 2012, 04:17 PM
More work, no benefit. It would work. But in particular, the drive shaft widget would need a special cone shape on the top and the bottom to seat right. Lots of machining time to get that right. I would work, and it would be more elegant. But for a piece that hides up in a hole you'll never see, it'd be wasted effort.
smj
Jul 22 2012, 06:07 PM
Fair enough. And thanks for sharing! This looks pretty cool...
sixnotfour
Jul 22 2012, 06:26 PM
How about a 911 motor 3spds
shuie
Jul 22 2012, 09:41 PM
Intermittent wipers would be cool. Is it any lighter?
McMark
Jul 22 2012, 09:53 PM
Much lighter. Funny, I almost weighed them. Tomorrow.
Intermittent wipers is easy with a relay. It'll definitely be part of my installation.
76-914
Jul 23 2012, 02:50 PM
Great info After your finished you should move this over to the classy's.
Cupomeat
Jul 23 2012, 03:00 PM
For those looking for intermitancy on thier wipers, a parallel thread provides all the answers;
If you use the 964 wiper motor as it is designed, the motor is on the left, and it will fit in the car if you alter the bottom mounting bracket. I flipped the wiper arm rack to make more clearance vertically for the AC, so I had to redo the mounting location for the motor.
It works great, I had it out in the rain last weekend.
Well, 3.5 years after mocking this up, I actually did the install. My original assessment was right on. I notched the mount just slightly to make clearance for the motor body and removed the rubber mounting nut. I'll weld a new nut on the other side (that'll make it even harder to install). Now everything bolts up fine and the motor moves the assembly, just like it should.
I'm gonna go install it in a car now and see how it looks in real operation.
Note to self: take before and after videos.
McMark
Nov 28 2016, 01:22 PM
Well, that was an easy install. No surprises at all. My wiring in post #27 (above) is correct. Boxster motor is a little faster, which is more noticeable on the fast speed. And that's good because the 'fast' speed on a stock setup always seemed a bit slow.
The bottom line, in my opinion, this isn't so much an upgrade. It's more just a replacement part that's in better condition than the old original parts. Also worth noting, the video/test uses two different wiper linkages. The linkage can introduce a lot of drag if there's corrosion or old gummy grease inside. The next step here is to overhaul the linkage for a complete wiper refresh.
76-914
Nov 28 2016, 05:53 PM
Smooth as butter. Great job Mark.
porschetub
Nov 29 2016, 11:06 PM
Thanks a lot Mark for taking the time to document this,Iam sure I have seen a similar motor on a VW Golf,would do the boxster motor one but parts are a bit thin on the ground in my country for these.
ConeDodger
Nov 30 2016, 01:57 AM
Oh boy... put it on the list.
Chris H.
Nov 30 2016, 08:02 AM
Awesome. Mine move about 90% slower than those. They need a full cleaning/refurb so might as well do this too. Thanks for the tutorial.
porschetub
Nov 30 2016, 11:56 PM
QUOTE(Chris H. @ Dec 1 2016, 03:02 AM)
Awesome. Mine move about 90% slower than those. They need a full cleaning/refurb so might as well do this too. Thanks for the tutorial.
Exactly,mine works ok but are still rather slow,no getting over that and I cant be bothered making a slow wiper motor a little faster by cleaning it,can't believe my luck trawled our countries biggest auction site and scored a boxster wiper assembly for a very fair price... Mark coming thru again with great info ,I real asset to this forum,top marks he he.
porschetub
Dec 7 2016, 01:19 PM
I haven't picked mine up from the postal depot as yet,seller wouldn't separate the motor from the drive but only charged for motor and free shipping,got me thinking if I could use most or all of the drive,would certainly be better than 40yr old parts.
skaravelle
Apr 16 2017, 01:53 PM
QUOTE(porschetub @ Nov 30 2016, 06:06 AM)
Thanks a lot Mark for taking the time to document this,Iam sure I have seen a similar motor on a VW Golf,would do the boxster motor one but parts are a bit thin on the ground in my country for these.
Just did this swap on my -70, used a VW-"mostvehicles"-type motor, looks just the same as the Boxter-motor in this post. New motor, bought it online here in Norway for about 60$
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.