Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Would a cooler like this work in the front
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
JmuRiz
I was wondering if an oil cooler like this one would work as a front oil cooler of a 2.7 6 conversion.

What are your thoughts? BTW it's a Behr from an old Mercedes.
SLITS
Why not? It's a single pass, fin & tube cooler. The type can still be purchased today.
carr914
pretty sure that is what rfuerst911 used
Elliot Cannon
Contact bdstone. He knows a little about oil coolers. biggrin.gif
Scott S
What is that cooler out of?
beerchug.gif
Dave_Darling
Anything will work, frankly. Even bare metal tubes--just ask 911SC owners about that. The question is will it work well enough?

A plate-style cooler will be more efficient and reject more heat per area. Not sure about flow restriction.

Is it what you need? Could be, but that depends on a whole lot of variables. Like the air temps you expect to see, how much cooling the engine needs, the exact ducting of cool air to it and warmed air away from it, and so on.

--DD
JmuRiz
QUOTE(Scott S @ Sep 25 2012, 09:30 AM) *

What is that cooler out of?
beerchug.gif

The one I have is out of a euro-spec Mercedes M110 engine (2.8l DOHC inline 6 with 185HP) but that engine is pending sale along with my car.

I was just outside and thought the dimensions were close to the 914/6 GT coolers and since it helped with a 2.8l inline six.....

I'd have to find another one, but I'm sure they are out there.

Thanks to all you guys for your help. I'll probably run either braided lines or those cool GT-style hardlines to the front (the ones PMB are doing). I've been told a front cooler is best, so what the heck.

If anyone has a line on a good RX7-cooler or of a place to get one, I'd be willing to think about that too.
Scott S
I had the RX-7 cooler - they were so cheap from our local pic a part (like 10.00). However, after researching within this group, it seemed like it would take quite a bit of cutting and rewelding to get the cooler to work (removing the built in t-stat). The cost to have this work done and then have the cooler cleaned was getting close to the cost of other options.
I gave away the ones I had several years ago because of this.
JmuRiz
Bummer, but good information to know. I'll see what ideas people have as well as the local Porsche racers near me (not that my car will be more than a street car).
SirAndy
QUOTE(JmuRiz @ Sep 25 2012, 07:57 AM) *
What are your thoughts? BTW it's a Behr from an old Mercedes.

I used to run the same type (old Mercedes oil coolers) on many of my bugs back in the day.
Mounted under the front bumper ...

popcorn[1].gif
SLITS
QUOTE(Scott S @ Sep 25 2012, 10:57 AM) *

I had the RX-7 cooler - they were so cheap from our local pic a part (like 10.00). However, after researching within this group, it seemed like it would take quite a bit of cutting and rewelding to get the cooler to work (removing the built in t-stat). The cost to have this work done and then have the cooler cleaned was getting close to the cost of other options.
I gave away the ones I had several years ago because of this.


I hate this .... the only reason to remove the thermostat from the RX7 cooler is that it takes a little longer for the engine to come up to temperature because of the added 1-2 quarts of oil in the lines.

The stock RX7 thermostat would prevent the oil from flowing thru the cooler until it came up to temperature.

If there is that much wear in the engine created by having to warm up a couple more quarts, then there is something wrong in the metallurgy or design.

Besides, you could remove the thermostat and probably use an expandable freeze plug to achieve the same thing as cutting, replacing the mid plate and re-heliarcing the tank back on an RX7 cooler. ( I haven't tried this as yet, but I'm getting there).

Just my thoughts. I've been running a plate cooler for about 10K miles with no thermostat and my engine is far from wearing out.

Rant over .....
Scott S
Crap. I wish I would have known this Ron. I gave away three of those coolers. After reading various threads, I didn't think they were just plug and play. That stinks.

And you never see RX-7's in our local wrecking yards anymore either.....

headbang.gif
wndsrfr
QUOTE(JmuRiz @ Sep 25 2012, 09:50 AM) *

QUOTE(Scott S @ Sep 25 2012, 09:30 AM) *

What is that cooler out of?
beerchug.gif

The one I have is out of a euro-spec Mercedes M110 engine (2.8l DOHC inline 6 with 185HP) but that engine is pending sale along with my car.

I was just outside and thought the dimensions were close to the 914/6 GT coolers and since it helped with a 2.8l inline six.....

I'd have to find another one, but I'm sure they are out there.

Thanks to all you guys for your help. I'll probably run either braided lines or those cool GT-style hardlines to the front (the ones PMB are doing). I've been told a front cooler is best, so what the heck.

If anyone has a line on a good RX7-cooler or of a place to get one, I'd be willing to think about that too.


I have two RX7 coolers for, say $ 30 each. I used one for a while with the thermostat plugged off since I have a mocal in line tstat. They are a great fit for a front mount setup. However, do a search on Rx7 coolers here and you'll find the thread on how to remove the strips from inside the tubes & re-weld the tank on the end......without doing that the cooler is very restrictive when the oil is cold & causes an oil pressure drop when the tstat switches. Let me know if you want one.
SLITS
QUOTE(wndsrfr @ Sep 25 2012, 03:15 PM) *

However, do a search on Rx7 coolers here and you'll find the thread on how to remove the strips from inside the tubes & re-weld the tank on the end......without doing that the cooler is very restrictive when the oil is cold & causes an oil pressure drop when the tstat switches. Let me know if you want one.


Not to start an argument, but:

Since the cooler is on the scavenge side of a six pump and no pressure is measured there, I fail to see how it would effect the oil pressure in the engine. The oil returning to the filter and tank is what is cooled.

A six pump is a flooded suction pump with 8 quarts of oil in the tank feeding the engine oil pump.
wndsrfr
QUOTE
Not to start an argument, but:

Since the cooler is on the scavenge side of a six pump and no pressure is measured there, I fail to see how it would effect the oil pressure in the engine. The oil returning to the filter and tank is what is cooled.

A six pump is a flooded suction pump with 8 quarts of oil in the tank feeding the engine oil pump.


Ahhh.....yes, right on. I was relating my experience with my Type4 & didn't remember that it's a 6 being worked on. In which case, since the scavenged oil is quickly warmed, the only pressure spike in the system will be on startup with high pressure on the elements of the system upstream of the cooler. Where in the system is the filter located on a sixer? Wix has a racing filter good for like 100psi which is what I'm using....
SLITS
With a stock six tank, the oil filter is on the tank. It filters the oil prior to free dump in the tank.

With an aftermarket tank, it can be on the tank or remote in a line.

Pressure of the system would be such to push the oil thru the filter as it is the only restriction other than elbows, lines and cooler capacity,

I use a standard Bosch filter for the early sixes.
rgalla9146
QUOTE(SLITS @ Sep 25 2012, 10:59 AM) *

QUOTE(Scott S @ Sep 25 2012, 10:57 AM) *

I had the RX-7 cooler - they were so cheap from our local pic a part (like 10.00). However, after researching within this group, it seemed like it would take quite a bit of cutting and rewelding to get the cooler to work (removing the built in t-stat). The cost to have this work done and then have the cooler cleaned was getting close to the cost of other options.
I gave away the ones I had several years ago because of this.


I hate this .... the only reason to remove the thermostat from the RX7 cooler is that it takes a little longer for the engine to come up to temperature because of the added 1-2 quarts of oil in the lines.

The stock RX7 thermostat would prevent the oil from flowing thru the cooler until it came up to temperature.

If there is that much wear in the engine created by having to warm up a couple more quarts, then there is something wrong in the metallurgy or design.

Besides, you could remove the thermostat and probably use an expandable
freeze plug to achieve the same thing as cutting, replacing the mid plate and re-heliarcing the tank back on an RX7 cooler. ( I haven't tried this as yet, but I'm getting there).

Just my thoughts. I've been running a plate cooler for about 10K miles with no thermostat and my engine is far from wearing out.

Rant over .....

I agree with slits,
why remove a built in t-stat ? By keeping it you avoid four additional connections and the cost of an additional part. It allows reduced flow until operating temp is reached.
Also, it is designed to prevent explosion caused by excess oil pressure when cold.
The adaptation can be as simple as drilling to enlarge and tapping existing bungs and welding on an additional tapped bung for better position.
Rant over x 2....

Scott S
Wndsrfr -
Do you have a good RX-7 cooler for sale? If so, I am absolutely interested.

(sorry for the hi jack...)

...oh - and once again - THANKS RON!
wndsrfr
QUOTE(Scott S @ Sep 26 2012, 07:16 AM) *

Wndsrfr -
Do you have a good RX-7 cooler for sale? If so, I am absolutely interested.


Yep, I've got one more available.......PM me.....
ConeDodger
BDStone - Bruce Stone did a talk on oil coolers at WCR2010 Teeners at Tahoe. He specifically mentioned the Mercedes Benz Behrs... In a good way IIRC. evilgrin.gif

Clean it and use it!
majkos
Hey Scott, I have one too.
just brought it home from RRC.
larryM

the front cooler is a LONG WAY from the sixer engine - it may NEVER get warm oil to open that RX7 thermo - since no flow exists to warm it up until the thermo is open

take it out


QUOTE(SLITS @ Sep 25 2012, 11:59 AM) *


I hate this .... the only reason to remove the thermostat from the RX7 cooler is that it takes a little longer for the engine to come up to temperature because of the added 1-2 quarts of oil in the lines.

The stock RX7 thermostat would prevent the oil from flowing thru the cooler until it came up to temperature.
Rant over .....

SLITS
Flow to the cooler will occur as it is plumbed into the scavenge line of the six.

At the cooler, cold oil will just make a U-turn and head back to the oil tank.

At the cooler with hot oil, the cooler thermostat will plug the bypass and direct oil thru the cooler body.

Also, on a six, the onboard cooler is by-passed with the on-board thermostat. No oil is cooled until the thermostat opens.
JmuRiz
I saw this picture in the sandbox, looks like someone did some custom work on an LE front valance to install a cooler like the one I posted at the start of this thread.

Doesn't look as low as the RSR cooler, but may be a solution for front oil cooling w/o cutting up the front trunk.
What are your thoughts?

IPB Image
SLITS
QUOTE(JmuRiz @ Jul 22 2013, 07:41 AM) *

I saw this picture in the sandbox, looks like someone did some custom work on an LE front valance to install a cooler like the one I posted at the start of this thread.

Doesn't look as low as the RSR cooler, but may be a solution for front oil cooling w/o cutting up the front trunk.
What are your thoughts?

IPB Image


As long as the nay-sayers don't jump you with lines about hitting curbs or objects in the road, it would work fine.

In the late '70s I worked on a 914/6 race team. The stock front valence was pulled down and out, stretched, braced and the oil cooler was installed behind it ... no cutting of the car. It was only a problem when the driver hit a cone at Holtville and broke the AN fitting ... 13 quarts of Castrol R on the track.
JmuRiz
I figure if it's good enough for a 911 2.7RS & RSR...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.