Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What is carburetor percolation...
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
nsr-jamie
Hi, over here in Japan where it is much hotter and humid than the rest of most parts of the world. My car is a 1972 914-4 model that has been tuned up a bit with 103mm p/c, high can and big valve heads (48x38) and twin 40mm drla Dellorto carbs....in the summer time the car seems to run badly and when I stop the car for even a short time to run into the 7-11 and try to restart the 914 it sometimes is quite difficult to get it running again. I talked with my mechanic friend at my local air cooled VW shop here and he told me I was experiencing carburetor percolation which seems to be common on these cars or air cooled engines that are running carbs like mine. I did a bit of research and found nothing here on this site but a little bit on google....not really sure what carburetor percolation is but kind of sounds like the carbs are over heating from the engine heat. Are others experiencing this problem too and if so what are you doing to try to fix it. My shop mentioned special gaskets or spacers to go in between the carbs and manifolds to cure this problem...it seems to occur more here on this side of the planet cause of the humid and hotter weather compared to say back home in the US or Europe. I checked on the CB Performance site and could not find spacers.....any body have any input to add? Thanks and cheers

Jamie in Japan
McMark
When the engine is running you have air flow and fuel flow to keep things relatively cool. But when you shut off the engine all that heat builds up in the carbs and causes the fuel in the bowls to boil and spill into the carb throat. When you go to restart you have a flooded engine.

Your shop sounds like they know what they're talking about. There are phenolic spacers that will reduce heat flow from the heads into the carbs. This is where a lot of the heat comes from. The stock FI-style intake manifold gaskets are phenolic and you can find the intake-carb phenolic spacers on eBay in the US searching 'phenolic idf'. The DRLA has the same bolt pattern.
sean_v8_914
the plastic spacers help. Porsche used a return line off teh fuel pressure regulator, after the carbs. most carb conversions use a pressure regulator before teh carbs. it only allows about 3 psi to the carb. the carbs are a dead end-final destination for teh fuel. Porsche used a regulator after the carbs. any fuel over teh required 3 psi was let out to a fuel return line to keep fuel cool.

the simple solution seems to be teh plastic spacer but this will change your linkage geometry since teh carbs will be up higher and wider apart.
r_towle
spacers are the key.

rich
GeorgeRud
You can also put a switch in the dash that let's you shut off the fuel pump. Then, simply cut off the fuel flow to the carbs a bit before shutting down. The lowered fuel level in the carbs will also help cut down the percolation.
mrbubblehead
hi jamie, i had a similar problem. on super hot days i could actually hear the fuel boiling in my float bowls after shut down. so i use the phenolic spacers between the manifold and carb. as well as the stock phenolic spacer between manifold and the head. i work in the desert, and once my carbs heat soaked, they didnt want to idle real well. once i isolated the carbs my heat soak problems went away.

IPB Image
nsr-jamie
Hello everyone and thank you for the excellent replies. Spacers sound like the way to go and now that my engine is now out of the car I have decided to try to rebuild the carbs myself...I saw the spacers on Ebay (thanks McMark) and I think I might be able to make them myself on the CNC mill at work in my free time. It seems like the material I need is called phenolic and I did a quick search and "BakeLite" was also mentioned. We actually have some bakelite at work that has been sitting for years that I could use and try to attempt to make a set of these spacers. It might be kind of fun to try and make them and see how they turn out.

Is this going to affect my linkage, the thickness of the material is 8mm....I guess I will need new stud bolts for the manifolds.

This could be fun to try to make something like this....just wondering if I can machine or mill bakelite (phenolic), I guess I need to do more searching again on the web. I will let you guys know soon.
'73-914kid
Jamie, what linkage are you running? I installed the phenolic spacers after installing Chris Foley's cable linkage without any real issue, or need to res-synch. For almost any other linkage though, I think it would throw the geometries out a little.

BTW, I've haven't had any good luck milling bakelight. It chips away rather than milling cleanly. But I'm sure with the right tool could mill it cleanly, but from my experience, it's a crap shoot.

Out of curiosity, would Delrin work as well as phenolic material? Talk about a material easy to come by, and easy to mill....
john rogers
Do you have all the sheet metal AND the rubber seals that fit between the tin and body parts? If not then the heat will surely come up, worse when stopped. You can also add some aluminum heat shields over top the exhaust to help with radiated heat deflection. We used to use these on the 4 cylinder race car to help keep heat away from the carbs. With the spacers, be sure to tighten the nuts very evenly and not to over tighten or air leaks will result.
charliew
The spacers I have seen have a mesh looking reinforcement running through them. We use a spacer on suby motors that also looks like it has a mesh in it. The stuff I have seen looks just like the stuff electronics hobbiest use to mount electronics on.
DBCooper
I don't think you want Bakelite, it cracks really easily so I doubt you'd be able to torque the carbs down and keep it intact. Phenolic has a bit of give. It's just what was used back in the day, but if you're making them I imagine you could use any of a dozen other modern non-metalic materials that would do the same job.
nsr-jamie
Seems like lots of guys in Japan are using bakelight with their air cooled cars...today after work I cut 4 pieces of them on the band saw and drilled out the stud bolt holes on the mill today so they are perfectly pitched. I am going to make some kind of jig for them either tomorrow or the day after when work is done and hope to maching a few pairs of them. The material is very soft and I tested with a carbide endmill and it turned out much cleaner than I expected. I'll try to get some pictures this weekend and let others know how they work out. This is kind of fun...
URY914
Jamie,

I see a group buy in your future. biggrin.gif

Pictures would be great.

I have this same problem after a few autocross runs. I need to do something.
Woody
QUOTE(URY914 @ Nov 7 2012, 07:29 AM) *

Jamie,

I see a group buy in your future. biggrin.gif

Pictures would be great.

I have this same problem after a few autocross runs. I need to do something.

agree.gif
DBCooper
QUOTE(nsr-jamie @ Nov 7 2012, 04:29 AM) *

Seems like lots of guys in Japan are using bakelight with their air cooled cars...today after work I cut 4 pieces of them on the band saw and drilled out the stud bolt holes on the mill today so they are perfectly pitched. I am going to make some kind of jig for them either tomorrow or the day after when work is done and hope to maching a few pairs of them. The material is very soft and I tested with a carbide endmill and it turned out much cleaner than I expected. I'll try to get some pictures this weekend and let others know how they work out. This is kind of fun...


Maybe there's a difference in terminology then, because Bakelite was a brand name and one of the very early plastics, from the first part of the last century. It was black and very hard and brittle, not soft, typically used for molded electrical connectors and components. I wasn't even aware it was still being made. Whatever you call it, if what you have is soft, you can machine and it will insulate then it will work.
nathansnathan
QUOTE(DBCooper @ Nov 7 2012, 05:28 PM) *

QUOTE(nsr-jamie @ Nov 7 2012, 04:29 AM) *

Seems like lots of guys in Japan are using bakelight with their air cooled cars...today after work I cut 4 pieces of them on the band saw and drilled out the stud bolt holes on the mill today so they are perfectly pitched. I am going to make some kind of jig for them either tomorrow or the day after when work is done and hope to maching a few pairs of them. The material is very soft and I tested with a carbide endmill and it turned out much cleaner than I expected. I'll try to get some pictures this weekend and let others know how they work out. This is kind of fun...


Maybe there's a difference in terminology then, because Bakelite was a brand name and one of the very early plastics, from the first part of the last century. It was black and very hard and brittle, not soft, typically used for molded electrical connectors and components. I wasn't even aware it was still being made. Whatever you call it, if what you have is soft, you can machine and it will insulate then it will work.


I too had thought bakelite was not made anymore, but bakelite and phenolic are just about the same thing according to wikipedia, bakelite being the trademark for the first completely synthetic plastic, a thermoset made from a reaction between phenol and fermaldehyde. I used to work for a lady that designed retro jewelry, and there is a whole crowd of old ladies that are into the bakelite bracelets and such, they would rub them and smell to check the authenticity - will have to try that on some spacers next time smile.gif
larryM
go check the PMO site for info

- in addition to insulating spacers for webers, there was an anti-percolation mod done in the carbs

yes, i know you are not talking weber - but carbs are carbs - you can learn from that

as i recall it was caused by EPA changes in the volatility (reid vapor pressure) of our enviro-approved gas

- special tool as i recollect, and i think i still have the thing

i did all that yrs ago on my sixer

.
rhodyguy
are the spacers between the idfs and intakes cut down intake to head spacers? i've never seen that application before. where did you purchase them?

k
nsr-jamie
QUOTE('73-914kid @ Nov 7 2012, 01:05 AM) *

Jamie, what linkage are you running? I installed the phenolic spacers after installing Chris Foley's cable linkage without any real issue, or need to res-synch. For almost any other linkage though, I think it would throw the geometries out a little.

BTW, I've haven't had any good luck milling bakelight. It chips away rather than milling cleanly. But I'm sure with the right tool could mill it cleanly, but from my experience, it's a crap shoot.

Out of curiosity, would Delrin work as well as phenolic material? Talk about a material easy to come by, and easy to mill....



I am running what I believe is the CB performance hex link kit. I bought the whole kit with the 40mm DRLA dells from Dave Shepard at Mid Engine Mania (now GPR) around 15 years ago or so new. I have also been thinking about upgrading to the Tangerine linkage too someday.

I am not sure of the actual name of the material but everybody is calling it bakelite at my work...I did some research and heard it was not even made anymore but I also heard Mitsubishi Heavy Industries makes it....from the pictures it looks just like the stuff sold on Ebay as Phenolic so it may be that. It gives off lots of powder when you machine it and a bad order...I wore a mask for this...I have a feeling this is not a material you want to machine much
nsr-jamie
Ok, here are some pictures as promised. I finished one set this week.

Picture one shows the material I am using which may be bakelight...I actually got it for free from our spot welder operator as he no longer needed it. Thats how I got it with the holes in it already.

Click to view attachment


Another one but close up. Is this really bakelite or is it Phenolic? I believe they are the same material.

Click to view attachment



nsr-jamie
Here is the material after I roughly cut it out on the band saw. Than I made a small jig from some scrap metal to mill out the holes for the stud bolts so they are perfectly pitched to keep it positioned well.

Click to view attachment

This is another jig I made for ones the holes are drilled and it fits into to give it the 2D profile. I did this on the CNC mill after work. Than I bolt it to the jig and mill away in the shape.

Click to view attachment
nsr-jamie
a picture of before and after, sorry picture turned out a bit fuzzy.

Click to view attachment

The final product all done and ready to go in the car. They turned out better than I thought. It was actually kind of fun making them.

Click to view attachment

nathansnathan
Like I said they are the same, like kleenex and tissue, pretty much.

You may want to use a gasket on top of them too, on the manifold side. The stock fi spacers have a paper gasket adhered to each side, and the CB intakes, the facing where it mates is so far short of flat they have their own thicker gaskets. Just the paper ones don't work, and though the phenolic gives some degree of crush, I have found it better to use both. -not doing this, they will leak slightly.

I've often thought that what people describe as the dellorto howl was just a bad seal there, as it's the only time I've heard it, running paper gaskets. I think the special gaskets without the cutout or the silicone- in-the-recesses trick might be just misled.
DBCooper
QUOTE(nsr-jamie @ Nov 9 2012, 08:38 AM) *


Another one but close up. Is this really bakelite or is it Phenolic? I believe they are the same material.



You're right, they're the same (http://www.professionalplastics.com/BAKELITE). You couldn't machine the original bakelite, it was always molded, but now it's now made with different reinforcing materials, paper, canvas and linen, that make it machinable.

Right about the Dellorto whistle, too. CB Performance sells a spacer/gasket that covers that gap and eliminates the chirps.

.
nsr-jamie
QUOTE(DBCooper @ Nov 10 2012, 01:51 AM) *

QUOTE(nsr-jamie @ Nov 9 2012, 08:38 AM) *


Another one but close up. Is this really bakelite or is it Phenolic? I believe they are the same material.



You're right, they're the same (http://www.professionalplastics.com/BAKELITE). You couldn't machine the original bakelite, it was always molded, but now it's now made with different reinforcing materials, paper, canvas and linen, that make it machinable.

Right about the Dellorto whistle, too. CB Performance sells a spacer/gasket that covers that gap and eliminates the chips.

.


Do you happen to know the part number for this CB performance part? I have been looking over their site and have not found anything....perhaps I am looking in the wrong area.

I was thinking about going with two sets of paper gaskets and sandwhich my new bakelight spacers in between.
DBCooper
Hmmm.... not at CB any more but found them on John's site, aircooled.net: Dellorto Anti-Whistle Gaskets

Yes, use regular thick paper carb base gaskets, and note his tip to use chapstick on them to use them more than once. And actually if you put the carbs and manifolds together on the bench you can see the space that creates the whistle. If you want to spend the time you can fill it in with epoxy and file it flat.

By the way I also saw your isolators on their carb page, about halfway down here: http://vwparts.aircooled.net/Dellorto-DRLA...-Jets-s/933.htm Also shows some of the GOOD fuel pressure regulators for carbs.
nsr-jamie
Thanks for the links, checked them out and they were helpful. I also finished rebuilding my carbs today and they are almost ready to go.....new gaskets on the way. My spacers fit perfectly. I am going to cut some new stud bolts for them and do some small touches on the following weekend as I only have time to work on the car on Sunday. I can't wait to get my car on the road and drive it finally.
URY914
Any chance you sending me some of the scrap material or making a another set of spacers? biggrin.gif

OR do you know where someone could buy about a 12" x 12" piece of it? What kind of supply house would handle it?

Thanks. Great thread. This is one of the few things that I could use on my car.

nsr-jamie
QUOTE(URY914 @ Nov 12 2012, 03:05 AM) *

Any chance you sending me some of the scrap material or making a another set of spacers? biggrin.gif

OR do you know where someone could buy about a 12" x 12" piece of it? What kind of supply house would handle it?

Thanks. Great thread. This is one of the few things that I could use on my car.

It was a lot of work cause I manually machined each piece...it would have been faster to do it on the CNC machining center and have a program made up. But work wouldn't let me use the CNC's as they are always working and never stop....

The material I came accross from a friend who had it lying around but there is probably enough to do maybe 2 pieces if lucky. I don't know where to get anymore...but I did notice on the link that DB Cooper posted may have them for sale.

http://www.professionalplastics.com/BAKELITE

I designed mine to fit my 40mm DRLA dellortos. I think they turned out very nicely and I am proud of them. There is somebody selling them on ebay for cheaper than I could make them for
URY914
Thanks Jamie. I looked at the link and they only sell sheets that are too big. I'll tey to find a supplier locally.
wndsrfr
QUOTE(URY914 @ Nov 12 2012, 03:37 AM) *

Thanks Jamie. I looked at the link and they only sell sheets that are too big. I'll tey to find a supplier locally.

Try Mcmaster-Carr....they have everything often cut to smaller sizes and it'll ship to your door like overnight even with standard ground service......
DBCooper
Or ask that industrial plastics supplier for a 12x12 sample piece.
nathansnathan
The Phenolic FI spacers are in the 1.8/ 2.0 elring gasket sets. It's a fun project to make your own, but I can't see going to great lengths to make these.

About the Dellorto whistle, I was saying I think it is a myth, as my Dells only make that noise when they aren't sealing right. CB doesn't make them anymore, like was said. I speculate that those gaskets were a cover up - the literature wasn't going to say, "now buy our gaskets which compensate for how badly machined our manifolds are", so they made up a story about the gaps that had to be filled by a proprietary gasket, when it is just the thickness of the gasket that makes the difference. -just speculating here as I have not tried the special gaskets. My Dells son't whistle, though, without them.

It could be there is some confusion between "Dellorto whistle" and "Dellorto Howl". Mine do howl impressively. smile.gif

McMark
But you can buy them pre-fabbed on eBay... confused24.gif

I get why Jamie wouldn't go that route, but the US folk can order finished pieces for less than the time & material would cost.
ConeDodger
QUOTE(nathansnathan @ Nov 12 2012, 06:51 AM) *

The Phenolic FI spacers are in the 1.8/ 2.0 elring gasket sets. It's a fun project to make your own, but I can't see going to great lengths to make these.

About the Dellorto whistle, I was saying I think it is a myth, as my Dells only make that noise when they aren't sealing right. CB doesn't make them anymore, like was said. I speculate that those gaskets were a cover up - the literature wasn't going to say, "now buy our gaskets which compensate for how badly machined our manifolds are", so they made up a story about the gaps that had to be filled by a proprietary gasket, when it is just the thickness of the gasket that makes the difference. -just speculating here as I have not tried the special gaskets. My Dells son't whistle, though, without them.

It could be there is some confusion between "Dellorto whistle" and "Dellorto Howl". Mine do howl impressively. smile.gif


Nope. It's real. You have to epoxy up that positioning slot at the base since the gaskets are NLA. My 2270 had Dell's and she tweeted up a storm. I got 'the last set of gaskets' at CB Performance according to the person I ordered from.
McMark
Rob's right. Dellorto whistle is a real thing. If you haven't experienced it, great! But some do and when it happens, you know.
SirAndy
What about the bottom piece that goes between the heads and the manifold? I think that's even more important than the pieces between the manifolds and carbs.

On my carbed 2056, i ran the stock FI phenolic spacers between the heads and manifolds and just a paper gasket between the manifolds and carbs and i never had an issue with fuel boiling ...

popcorn[1].gif

QUOTE(nsr-jamie @ Nov 9 2012, 07:38 AM) *

IPB Image
mrbubblehead
QUOTE(McMark @ Nov 12 2012, 08:40 AM) *

But you can buy them pre-fabbed on eBay... confused24.gif

I get why Jamie wouldn't go that route, but the US folk can order finished pieces for less than the time & material would cost.


agree.gif thats what i did....
URY914
I'll look for them on ebay
URY914
Found them.....


http://www.ebay.com/itm/Weber-44-IDA-44-ID...cbc&vxp=mtr
mrbubblehead
QUOTE(URY914 @ Nov 12 2012, 02:39 PM) *


thats them.... if you go to their website the sell two different thicknesses.
URY914
Also in 1/2" thick.


http://www.ebay.com/itm/Weber-44-IDA-44-ID...63c&vxp=mtr
mrbubblehead
QUOTE(URY914 @ Nov 12 2012, 02:42 PM) *
beerchug.gif
DBCooper
The only reason we use the phenolic spacers is because we all have a few sets under a bench somewhere. They work but aren't the only way. Slightly different but a heck of a lot cheaper on aircooled.net: http://vwparts.aircooled.net/Weber-IDF-IDA...-11-1562-12.htm

Even cheaper at Pierce Manifolds, called "isolator" gaskets, to eliminate heat transfer and vibration (which can aerate fuel): http://www.piercemanifolds.com/category_s/296.htm

These are a different style, 1/8" instead of phenolic, but they do exactly the same thing.


.
nathansnathan
QUOTE(ConeDodger @ Nov 12 2012, 07:49 AM) *

QUOTE(nathansnathan @ Nov 12 2012, 06:51 AM) *

The Phenolic FI spacers are in the 1.8/ 2.0 elring gasket sets. It's a fun project to make your own, but I can't see going to great lengths to make these.

About the Dellorto whistle, I was saying I think it is a myth, as my Dells only make that noise when they aren't sealing right. CB doesn't make them anymore, like was said. I speculate that those gaskets were a cover up - the literature wasn't going to say, "now buy our gaskets which compensate for how badly machined our manifolds are", so they made up a story about the gaps that had to be filled by a proprietary gasket, when it is just the thickness of the gasket that makes the difference. -just speculating here as I have not tried the special gaskets. My Dells son't whistle, though, without them.

It could be there is some confusion between "Dellorto whistle" and "Dellorto Howl". Mine do howl impressively. smile.gif


Nope. It's real. You have to epoxy up that positioning slot at the base since the gaskets are NLA. My 2270 had Dell's and she tweeted up a storm. I got 'the last set of gaskets' at CB Performance according to the person I ordered from.


Maybe I'm doing something wrong that I can't get them to whistle? smile.gif Mine are the european ones, drla 40's, running tiny 32 mains, the long manifolds, cb air filter/ linkage on an 1800 with a webcam 86 cam - has some overlap and some lift over stock cam. I've got a stock muffler, all this in a bus mind you. smile.gif

Here are the gaskets at aircooled.net.

http://vwparts.aircooled.net/Dellorto-DRLA...stle-gasket.htm
nsr-jamie
Complete!! Total cost = zero, machining time on the mill after work about 4 hours for the set plus a bit more to make the jig for them. It feels good making parts for your own car instead of having to pay out money for them. piratenanner.gif

Click to view attachment
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.