QUOTE(malcolm2 @ Mar 21 2016, 10:33 AM)
Folks won't consider it the "right" way. But if it is like you say.... SOLID under the remaining cover, I might consider just treating under the cover and leave the larger hole. The factory hole was very small and pretty much good for nuthin'. dirt and water got up in there and just RUSTED. At least with a large hole you won't have that issue.
If you do cover the new large hole, leave yourself a small hole to poke and clean out the mud, like the factory did.
Good luck.
If you ever use the hole for a jack, you need to have that area with new metal. That is the part that lifts the car up, as it is in tension. I rarely use it, but sometimes it helps get the jack stand into the place you would otherwise be using for the jack! Instead of using the paddles they sell, I bought a trailer hitch ball and squared the shaft to fit. That way there is no torsional force, just straight up from a point on the ball.
Note from pictures that not everything everywhere needs new metal. Just sometimes. You might be one of the lucky ones.