Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Exhaust manifold studs?
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
catsltd
Pulling tranny.decided to change out heat exchangers while at it.
Fou;ld lots of black soot,so leaking pretty bad.

The problem is when I was pulling off the passenger side 3 of the studs came out.

What should I do.??.
Click to view attachment
catsltd
Should I order new Bolts.???
Old nuts are siezed solid.
Thanks for any Help.
dlee6204
If the threads in the head are not damaged then simply replace the studs with new. If the threads have been stripped, then install a step stud (m10 on one end and m8 on the other) but it will require you to drill and tap the head to m10 which can be done without pulling the engine.
injunmort
from the looks of things, your threads are fine. you can get new studs at flaps, dorfman for ford explorer 4.6l. 2mm longer but makes no difference. antisieze the hell out of them. replace. i like the dorfmans because they have a square end which makes it easy to thread back into head tightly and comes with shouldered nuts that are better than the original hardware.
catsltd
QUOTE(injunmort @ Jun 5 2016, 07:16 PM) *

from the looks of things, your threads are fine. you can get new studs at flaps, dorfman for ford explorer 4.6l. 2mm longer but makes no difference. antisieze the hell out of them. replace. i like the dorfmans because they have a square end which makes it easy to thread back into head tightly and comes with shouldered nuts that are better than the original hardware.

Thanks for your help.The threads in the head look new.
I am wondering if I should locktight the end going into the head.????
Appreciate the help from everyone.
Cheers.
rhodyguy
You dodged 3 bullets. Congratulations.
r_towle
Lock tight won't hold up in the heads, and you don't want it to.
Either get the nuts off those and reuse them, or buy new ones
catsltd
QUOTE(rhodyguy @ Jun 5 2016, 08:58 PM) *

You dodged 3 bullets. Congratulations.

I kind of thought that also,they sure were tight.

You can see the nuts on the stud were not very tight on the heat exchanger,so I had a massive exhaust leak,black carbon all over the heat exchanger,already fixed drivers side so I am glad I decided to check passenger side also.

I was sure I was going to strip one.LOL.

Im going to order new studs and hardware,seems like the smart thing to do,along with new copper exhaust gaskets.

So far the clutch replacement is going pretty good,but Im sure that will change soon enuff.
Cheers.,
catsltd
Help.
The exhaust leaks were massive,mainly because the nuts could not be tightened down.
Anyway:questions.
I ordered new copper nuts from Pelican along with new studs,but upon reading I keep hearing about the copper nuts stripping the studs.

Should I use some other type of Nut????.

The second question.
How do I remove the old copper ring from the head,so far no luck,and when installing new copper o ring,do I attach it to the heat exchanger or head,and what can I use to hold it in place with.

Really appreciate some help here,as potencial for breaking studs seems pretty dier.

Thanks Grant.Click to view attachment
BeatNavy
I'm not aware of copper nut issues - I've always been told to use those. I would definitely consider using the copper anti-seize paste as well.

In terms of the copper gasket (ring as you call it): a small dental pick carefully applied should be able to get that out of there. The approach I had the best success with in terms of putting the gasket on was to use that copper spray gasket and use that almost as a glue -- it keeps the gasket in place on the head as you put the HE in position. I've heard others say using superglue is fine as well, as the heat from the engine will simply burn it off. Putting it on the HE while you lift it up into place is way too hit and miss for me. I tried that before and found I had one HE that sealed well and another that did not.

Are you going to anneal the gasket? Have you considered filing down the HE's to make sure they're uniform?
TheCabinetmaker
Large coarse file. 16" or better. File both tubes at once to keep them flat. File until clean metal shows completely. Remove the copper gaskets with a screwdriver. Gently hammer a flat screwdriver between the straight side of the gasket and the head. Then a good twist will deform the gasket enough to grab it with needle nose pliers.
IPB Image

IPB Image
dlee6204
I use these...

http://vwparts.aircooled.net/ACN-Flanged-R...-p/acn-nuts.htm


I use a dental prick and screwdrivers to remove the copper gaskets. Also make sure to anneal your new copper exhaust gaskets. It softens the copper and helps seals. I use a dab of super glue to hold them in the head.

Here's some more good information.
http://www.ratwell.com/technical/Exhaust.html
catsltd
QUOTE(BeatNavy @ Jun 9 2016, 12:22 PM) *

I'm not aware of copper nut issues - I've always been told to use those. I would definitely consider using the copper anti-seize paste as well.

In terms of the copper gasket (ring as you call it): a small dental pick carefully applied should be able to get that out of there. The approach I had the best success with in terms of putting the gasket on was to use that copper spray gasket and use that almost as a glue -- it keeps the gasket in place on the head as you put the HE in position. I've heard others say using superglue is fine as well, as the heat from the engine will simply burn it off. Putting it on the HE while you lift it up into place is way too hit and miss for me. I tried that before and found I had one HE that sealed well and another that did not.

Are you going to anneal the gasket? Have you considered filing down the HE's to make sure they're uniform?

I have a large file,and have already filed the heat exchanger( 1 of them) flat.

I just read about heating the copper gaskets,so I will do that as well,but did not do it on the drivers side,and it leaks so not impressed.

I am doing the clutch so I will pull both heat exchangers and replace copper o rings after I have anneal them.3 new studs,all new copper nuts(Thanks),and will file flat.
Dont want to do this again,as I am sure Ill break a stud.

Thanks for your help.
Grant
McMark
Some tips on exhaust.

* You don't need to file both pipes at once. They flex a lot. Just make sure each one is filed flat on its own.

* Use a tiny amount of copper antisieze to stick the copper rings into the head during installation. Keeping those bugger in place is a pain sometimes.

* When installing the pipes, it's not uncommon for the pipe edge to catch on the head slightly. Use a flashlight to spend a lot of time looking around the pipe. You should be able to see a small amount of copper around the pipe when it's installed. You can carefully pry the pipe into place with a screwdriver if it's stubborn.

* Stainless steel headers are the most difficult to line up.

* Don't tighten any of the nuts all the way first. You will get the pipe cocked a bit and it won't seal. Run all four nuts on part way, and then just go around and around tightening a little bit at a time. The best is to use a torque wrench set to a very low number. That way if one nut starts getting tight before the others you can skip it until the other nuts match torque.

* Use a 1/4" drive ratchet. You don't need any more leverage than that and it makes it much harder to over tighten the nuts. You don't need to tighten these hard to make them seal.

* You'll need to go back and retighten the nuts after a little run time.

That's it off the top of my head.
rhodyguy
Jake's method of painting the nut threads with milk of magnesia to prevent seizing works great.
BeatNavy
QUOTE(McMark @ Jun 9 2016, 01:00 PM) *

Some tips on exhaust.

* You don't need to file both pipes at once. They flex a lot. Just make sure each one is filed flat on its own.

* Use a tiny amount of copper antisieze to stick the copper rings into the head during installation. Keeping those bugger in place is a pain sometimes.

* When installing the pipes, it's not uncommon for the pipe edge to catch on the head slightly. Use a flashlight to spend a lot of time looking around the pipe. You should be able to see a small amount of copper around the pipe when it's installed. You can carefully pry the pipe into place with a screwdriver if it's stubborn.

* Stainless steel headers are the most difficult to line up.

* Don't tighten any of the nuts all the way first. You will get the pipe cocked a bit and it won't seal. Run all four nuts on part way, and then just go around and around tightening a little bit at a time. The best is to use a torque wrench set to a very low number. That way if one nut starts getting tight before the others you can skip it until the other nuts match torque.

* Use a 1/4" drive ratchet. You don't need any more leverage than that and it makes it much harder to over tighten the nuts. You don't need to tighten these hard to make them seal.

* You'll need to go back and retighten the nuts after a little run time.

That's it off the top of my head.

Follow Mark's advice. That's what I did the first time, and it made an otherwise unpleasant (and somewhat risky) effort easier and more successful. One other tip that Mark or someone else suggested: yes, use the 1/4" ratchet and a flexible extension can be helpful too.
MarkV
I had really bad luck with the copper nuts that are self locking. I think I bought them at Pelican. They seem to weld themselves in place and when you go to loosen them the stud comes out. I found some regular old flanged nuts somewhere and used milk of magnesia on the studs and the nuts. Use some grease to hold the seal to the head.
worn
QUOTE(catsltd @ Jun 9 2016, 08:49 AM) *

QUOTE(BeatNavy @ Jun 9 2016, 12:22 PM) *

I'm not aware of copper nut issues - I've always been told to use those. I would definitely consider using the copper anti-seize paste as well.

In terms of the copper gasket (ring as you call it): a small dental pick carefully applied should be able to get that out of there. The approach I had the best success with in terms of putting the gasket on was to use that copper spray gasket and use that almost as a glue -- it keeps the gasket in place on the head as you put the HE in position. I've heard others say using superglue is fine as well, as the heat from the engine will simply burn it off. Putting it on the HE while you lift it up into place is way too hit and miss for me. I tried that before and found I had one HE that sealed well and another that did not.

Are you going to anneal the gasket? Have you considered filing down the HE's to make sure they're uniform?

I have a large file,and have already filed the heat exchanger( 1 of them) flat.

I just read about heating the copper gaskets,so I will do that as well,but did not do it on the drivers side,and it leaks so not impressed.

I am doing the clutch so I will pull both heat exchangers and replace copper o rings after I have anneal them.3 new studs,all new copper nuts(Thanks),and will file flat.
Dont want to do this again,as I am sure Ill break a stud.

Thanks for your help.
Grant

A lot of folks do not know that to soften copper or silver you heat to dull red and immediately quench in cool water. Opposite of steel. If you cool slowly you are following the process for hardening!
rhodyguy
Marking the top of the pipes with a black sharpie makes filing easier. No need to remove anymore metal than Is required.
Mark Henry
If the studs are backing out the threads are stripped even though you think they are not.

I like using the 8mm/9mm step stud if you can find it, this gives you the option of the 8mm/10mm stud in the future. Below gives you the correct number, you might be able to get them from your local P-dealer.

http://www.stoddard.com/n0146841.html

I've also had luck with timeserts, but never use a helicoil on an exhaust stud.
dlee6204
QUOTE(worn @ Jun 9 2016, 01:23 PM) *

QUOTE(catsltd @ Jun 9 2016, 08:49 AM) *

QUOTE(BeatNavy @ Jun 9 2016, 12:22 PM) *

I'm not aware of copper nut issues - I've always been told to use those. I would definitely consider using the copper anti-seize paste as well.

In terms of the copper gasket (ring as you call it): a small dental pick carefully applied should be able to get that out of there. The approach I had the best success with in terms of putting the gasket on was to use that copper spray gasket and use that almost as a glue -- it keeps the gasket in place on the head as you put the HE in position. I've heard others say using superglue is fine as well, as the heat from the engine will simply burn it off. Putting it on the HE while you lift it up into place is way too hit and miss for me. I tried that before and found I had one HE that sealed well and another that did not.

Are you going to anneal the gasket? Have you considered filing down the HE's to make sure they're uniform?

I have a large file,and have already filed the heat exchanger( 1 of them) flat.

I just read about heating the copper gaskets,so I will do that as well,but did not do it on the drivers side,and it leaks so not impressed.

I am doing the clutch so I will pull both heat exchangers and replace copper o rings after I have anneal them.3 new studs,all new copper nuts(Thanks),and will file flat.
Dont want to do this again,as I am sure Ill break a stud.

Thanks for your help.
Grant

A lot of folks do not know that to soften copper or silver you heat to dull red and immediately quench in cool water. Opposite of steel. If you cool slowly you are following the process for hardening!


Quenching copper is not necessary. It can be annealed both ways, quenching or air cooled..
TheCabinetmaker
I must disagree Mark. Filing them one at a time leaves opportunity to file them out of square, which can cause a frustrating leak.
catsltd
QUOTE(Mark Henry @ Jun 9 2016, 01:35 PM) *

If the studs are backing out the threads are stripped even though you think they are not.

I like using the 8mm/9mm step stud if you can find it, this gives you the option of the 8mm/10mm stud in the future. Below gives you the correct number, you might be able to get them from your local P-dealer.

http://www.stoddard.com/n0146841.html

I've also had luck with timeserts, but never use a helicoil on an exhaust stud.


I ordered the 8/9 studs specific to the 1.8L head.

As I was undoing the bolts the studs seized up solid,so I turned them back about 1/2 turn and put in anti seize,then after sitting for a while I screwed them the other way,after a hour or so they came out with a uniform tighness.

I am pretty sure they are not stripped,there was no metal that came out,and you can see the old studs threads look like new.

Once my new studs arrive I will figure out what shape the inserts are in.
More worries is 1 of the studs is soaked in oil???.Anyway I will take my time and follow everyone advice.
Thanks to all.
McMark
Forgot about the annealing. YES! And quenched or slow cooled doesn't matter for copper. Either way works.

QUOTE(The Cabinetmaker @ Jun 9 2016, 02:09 PM) *
I must disagree Mark. Filing them one at a time leaves opportunity to file them out of square, which can cause a frustrating leak.

Out of square to each other? No way, they're too flexible to affect each other.
Out of square to the nuts/ears? Well I suppose, but I think that's just a matter of good file technique.

But, do it however you feel works. I just know I've done them one at a time on a LOT of cars and had good luck. I'm sure it works both ways.
jmitro
QUOTE(injunmort @ Jun 5 2016, 05:16 PM) *
you can get new studs at flaps, dorfman for ford explorer 4.6l. 2mm longer but makes no difference. antisieze the hell out of them. replace. i like the dorfmans because they have a square end which makes it easy to thread back into head tightly and comes with shouldered nuts that are better than the original hardware.



bumping this thread because it was quite helpful for me. and correcting the spelling error for future reference - it's Dormans. I couldn't find any "dorfmans" studs and then realized it was spelled wrong.

rjames
May have been said in a previous post but don’t over tighten when putting it all back together. Use a torque wrench so you know for sure when to stop.
Bartlett 914
QUOTE(worn @ Jun 9 2016, 12:23 PM) *

QUOTE(catsltd @ Jun 9 2016, 08:49 AM) *

QUOTE(BeatNavy @ Jun 9 2016, 12:22 PM) *

I'm not aware of copper nut issues - I've always been told to use those. I would definitely consider using the copper anti-seize paste as well.

In terms of the copper gasket (ring as you call it): a small dental pick carefully applied should be able to get that out of there. The approach I had the best success with in terms of putting the gasket on was to use that copper spray gasket and use that almost as a glue -- it keeps the gasket in place on the head as you put the HE in position. I've heard others say using superglue is fine as well, as the heat from the engine will simply burn it off. Putting it on the HE while you lift it up into place is way too hit and miss for me. I tried that before and found I had one HE that sealed well and another that did not.

Are you going to anneal the gasket? Have you considered filing down the HE's to make sure they're uniform?

I have a large file,and have already filed the heat exchanger( 1 of them) flat.

I just read about heating the copper gaskets,so I will do that as well,but did not do it on the drivers side,and it leaks so not impressed.

I am doing the clutch so I will pull both heat exchangers and replace copper o rings after I have anneal them.3 new studs,all new copper nuts(Thanks),and will file flat.
Dont want to do this again,as I am sure Ill break a stud.

Thanks for your help.
Grant

A lot of folks do not know that to soften copper or silver you heat to dull red and immediately quench in cool water. Opposite of steel. If you cool slowly you are following the process for hardening!

agree.gif
g911
So is there a torque spec for the stud going into the head? I had the same issue when I removed the exhaust.
rjames
QUOTE(g911 @ Oct 24 2021, 01:55 PM) *

So is there a torque spec for the stud going into the head? I had the same issue when I removed the exhaust.



18 lb/ft max. I'm not that brave and stop at 15. Haven't had a problem yet.
914werke
QUOTE(Mark Henry @ Jun 9 2016, 10:35 AM) *
If the studs are backing out, the threads are stripped even though you think they are not.
I like using the 8mm/9mm step stud if you can find them. This gives you the option of the 8mm/10mm stud in the future. I've also had luck with timeserts, but never use a helicoil on an exhaust stud.

Sorta agree.gif idea.gif But If you have to drill up to 10 mm, youve already lost. The bosses arent that robust & once drilled to that degree that stud wont hold too long. The 9/8 stud is a bit harder to locate but will provide a stronger head once repaired.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.