Well, I'd like to think mine are the best, but you be the judge.
Why I think this -
Mine are made from solid neoprene rubber- not sponge rubber like the OEM and knockoffs. It is a more expensive and better product of this application. The sponge holds the water in the track against the metal, this is why most cars have at least some rust there.
They also make the door shut with a nice solid feel. You will know why you have less road noise for this area once you try them.
I even know a CW that uses them.
http://shop.914rubber.com/914-Outer-Door-S...m?categoryId=-1