QUOTE(Unobtanium-inc @ May 24 2018, 09:58 AM)
...He confided in me that with the newer ones you have to push them to the limit to make it feel like a 911...
I think that describes the main difference to me, at least from a street car perspective. My girlfriend's 2009 Carrera S with the PDK transmission is a fantastic car, it does pretty much everything perfectly, but it only feels like a 911 when you get on it.
It is so powerful that the rest of the time—maybe 80% of the time—around town you cannot push into the fun zone, and it becomes like just another modern luxury car (and it feels a bit heavy.)
With a 914, especially with a four, you can—and almost have to—push it to 100% all the time and not get into too much trouble. Thats why it is so much fun—all the time.
There are times though, like when all of a sudden I am in bumper to bumper traffic and its 97 degrees, that the 997 is clearly the best option because it can slip out of performance mode into luxury car in an instant. But 80% luxury time/20% performance time is not the best ratio for me. It starts to make the car feel boring.
My 993 is a good balance for me. It is more like 80% performance time/20% luxury.
The 997—and Im sure the 996s—are great cars and I think about buying one or a Boxster, or a Cayman now and then—usually when I am in traffic and its hot and I am trying to talk on the phone. Maybe I will in the future, but for now, they have to leak a little, squeak a little, and if I turn on the heat I want to smell a little oil.
-Andrew