Just a thought.
LED's are a Light Emitting Diode. Diodes only conduct in one direction. LED's only conduct with proper polarity applied.
Take one of the DOA ones and reverse polarity and see if it works. China quality control being what it is, they may have the terminal connections within the LED reversed.
Long shot but what do you have to loose? Now if it works you still have a problem because I'd never suggest reversing polarity on the vehicle.
More of a science experiment.