QUOTE(Ratrod87 @ Sep 11 2019, 10:06 PM)

I literally did nothing but take the linkage apart and put it back together and it works. Will it happen again? I'm puzzled, something somewhere has to be wore out or something.
These cars are 40-50 years old. You can safely bet that the bushings are worn. Replace with new.
It may have been as simple as the linkages not having been aligned properly and the R&R got things into the right position. If the cone set screws are not aligned and dropped into their respective pockets on the linkage, it will not shift right.
This is a blind operation and it's easy to be off a spline or two and assume the cone screw is in the the right place when it's not.
914 shifting is notoriously vague to start with as compared to a modern trans with a direct shifter (i.e. in/on the trans directly) like a Miata.
Order all new bushings, do at your convenience now that you have it shifting.