QUOTE(matthepcat @ Jun 22 2020, 06:39 PM)
Now the question is, has the car appreciated $14k in 3 years? Or are we paying for the seat upgrade and refinished fuch's?
If other similar cars are selling and have sold for a similar asking price then yes, it has appreciated or it at least has shown to have the value that is being asked. If it sells for asking or close to it, then we are certain it has appreciated in value. Of course, in the last couple years, Porsche engines, trans, parts and labor have all increased so the justification of a higher asking price is warranted just from that metric.
Conversely, if you are seeing similar cars in the mid to upper $30’s, it’s probably priced to high.