Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Space saver spare
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
Montreal914
In the quest of increasing the space in my front trunk to integrate an oil cooler, I came across this piece of information that I thought was worth sharing.

Mercedes has been using Vredestein Space Master 165-15 collapsible spares on their smaller models like the C230 and the SLK.

After looking at the pictures and comparing them to my 911 space saver on steel wheel, I think they are the exact same tires.

The difference is that it is mounted on a 4.5" alloy wheel, not 5.5" like the Porsche.

So, one though to gain trunk space would be to mount the space saver tire on a ~$100 4.5" Fachs from cip1. Lighter and narrower wheel, win win. The goal would still to have it laying flat for impact absorption, yet probably allowing a lower trunk floor and giving room for the front mounted cooler to vent out.

Now the challenge is finding a place that will want to remove the collapsible Space Master tire and mount it on the Fachs... dry.gif

Below is the MBZ space saver wheel/tire.

Click to view attachment
mepstein
I believe that the spare needs to be inflated to help with impact absorption.
mlindner
Removing a space saver tire is very very very..........hard.
DickSteinkamp
Using a Boxster spare might be a good compromise. Narrow wheel, but inflated and correct bolt pattern. It would lower the frunk floor but still give you the crash protection.

I used one in my V8 914 but moved it to the rear trunk.


Click to view attachment
Montreal914
Currently have both in hand, 911 5.5" steel rim with space saver and 986/996 skinny spare. I am studying my options as to ways fit a cooler in there yet minimize the body cutting. idea.gif

Good point Mark that inflated would definitely help more the absorption. dry.gif

McMark's U shape ducting with flat collapsible spare in between is probably the most elegant option as recently seen in PMB Coatchwerks' orange car, but clearly involving and cutting...

Trying to see what is the simplest way as my fabrication capabilities and my house garage operation are somewhat limited biggrin.gif.

Thank you for sharing your thought... beerchug.gif
Mark Henry
I have a 944 turbo collapsible spare, same as a steel spare but it's aluminum rim.
I haven't seen McMarks U shape ducting, but I was thinking along the same lines. Just remember the area of the exit(s) should be 2X the area of the inlet.
Montreal914
Right! And i believe some later 911 also have alloy 15x5.5 with collapsible but not sure. Looking at the 4.5" Fachs, the offset makes the wheel center protrude a fair amount outward going against my goal of thinning the wheel... dry.gif

So my current 3 options are:

1- 986/996 spare: 3.5",light, full diameter, inflated.
Below is a mockup with a Mesa style cooler with a fan on top. The trunk floor is lower that the stock one. smile.gif To achieve that, I would need to cut a ~9x9" opening in the floor though... sad.gif Inlet would be front plugs.

Click to view attachment

Click to view attachment


2- 911 or alloy collapsible: 5.5", heavier than 986/996, small diameter, requires compressor. dry.gif
Below is the mockup using a Mercedes Diesel oil cooler, the narrower one, which fits under the arched shelf. This doesn't require any body cutting, just remove front 5 plugs and 2 rear access ports.
As for area, 5 ports = 11.1 sq.in., and 2 outlet opening = 25.1 sq.in., so Ratio is good! smile.gif
The trunk floor is pretty much at the same position as the stock setup or even a little lower or without angle.

Click to view attachment


3- Fachs 4.5" with temporary donut (125/70-15): 4.5" anrrower than 5.5" (but center protruding), light, OD 22", inflated.
Unfortunately, I don't have the wheel setup to validate this option but I think either cooler configuration could be used but there probably wouldn't be any gain in trunk space vs. option2.

So, at the moment for more of a "bolt on" setup, I am leaning towards the collapsible option but I definetly need to either find an alloy collapsible spare, or find someone that can swap the tire, which as mentioned earlier, can be very difficult... headbang.gif

All of these options will require a custom trunk floor that would seal all around to create a plenum. Air path would be pretty turbulent compared to the beautiful work below but that would be my first step.

@Mark Henry :
This is McMark's setup! pray.gif

Click to view attachment

And this is the integration done in PMB's recent build pray.gif

Click to view attachment
PanelBilly
When I blew up my space saver it was all lopsided. Tried to find a replacement tire with NO LUCK. Cut the tire off and I plan to mount a traditional tire to the wheel.
ClayPerrine
QUOTE(PanelBilly @ Aug 8 2020, 05:49 PM) *

When I blew up my space saver it was all lopsided. Tried to find a replacement tire with NO LUCK. Cut the tire off and I plan to mount a traditional tire to the wheel.



Remember, those space-saver tires are over 30 years old. They won't be there when you need them, they are just too old to function.

Go get a Boxster spare. If you have Boxster calipers, the 15 inch space saver spare won't fit anyway.

Montreal914
Right!, they are old.
That is where the Mercedes C230 ones become appealing smile.gif but they need to be transferred... dry.gif
914Sixer
I am using 16" Boxster inflated.
Montreal914
QUOTE(914Sixer @ Aug 8 2020, 04:48 PM) *

I am using 16" Boxster inflated.


Do you have a front mounted oil cooler?

The 986/996 spare that I have is 17" (105/95-17) confused24.gif
JamesM
QUOTE(mepstein @ Aug 8 2020, 02:52 AM) *

I believe that the spare needs to be inflated to help with impact absorption.


and also the windshield washers!

lol-2.gif lol-2.gif lol-2.gif lol-2.gif
914Sixer
No oil cooler.
Mark Henry
On my bug and '67 bus I have 15" rims with T125/15 temporary spares, only thing is they barely stretch fit onto a 4-1/2" rim.
They do have fake 5-bolt Fuchs that are 4-1/2" made for the Bug crowd
Montreal914
QUOTE(Mark Henry @ Aug 9 2020, 03:11 AM) *

On my bug and '67 bus I have 15" rims with T125/15 temporary spares, only thing is they barely stretch fit onto a 4-1/2" rim.
They do have fake 5-bolt Fuchs that are 4-1/2" made for the Bug crowd


That is the setup I had on my Bug 30 years ago! smile.gif
The 4.5" fake Fuchs from cip1 is exactly what I had in mind with a 125/70-15 for my option 3. Specs for the 125/70-15 tire is for rims 4-4.5"
Picking up a free Honda donut spare today that will allow me to mock up.
My only disappointment in the bug 4.5" fake Fuchs is its offset which makes the center protrude out a lot, going against my goal of thinning down the spare, but this donut would have 22" diameter probably giving enough room for a front mounted cooler while being an inflated tire.
drem914
QUOTE(914Sixer @ Aug 8 2020, 04:48 PM) *

I am using 16" Boxster inflated.

So am I, but no front oil cooler. Direct replacement bolt in and still maintains crash assistance of the original spare. Besides I have 200 mile towing with AAA, if really necessary.
Click to view attachment
drem914
Click to view attachment

Beautiful setup

Montreal914
PMB Coachwerks: drooley.gif

http://www.914world.com/bbs2/index.php?sho...p;hl=Coachwerks
porschetub
Alloy spacesaver mounted in the rear of the car,have 944 air compressor but may just inflate it,I was told it came from a 964 but haven't checked the part number yet.
These wheels are pretty solid and fairly heavy but certainly lighter than the steel version,I had no choice but use the alloy one as it clears my 944T calipers.
Click to view attachment
burton73
I bought my space savers at different prices over the years. I have a couple of 15-inch ones and when I switched to 16 on my 6, I bought a Mercedes Benz spare in 16 and had the local guy remove it. I sent that one to Eric (PMB) to use for my six mounted on RSR finish on 16x6


Bob BClick to view attachment Click to view attachment
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.