Well if it's on the Intrawebz . . .
Not sure how to put this but if the person that posted that was ever deposed as an engineer in a court of law relating to an fatal accident, it wouldn't end well.
Post appears to be primarily concerened about track bar binding with articulation. Sure in low speed off-road scenarios I get it. On road use will not result in anywhere near the amount of articulation that would begin to bind on a properly maintained suspension.
Other factors at play:
Failure modes: Engineers are held to account for what happens if a leaf spring breaks. Are you really comfortable depending on the anti-roll bar to locate the axle as the whole body drops to one side? Don't think leaf springs break? . . . they sure have on occasion. Solid engineering takes failure modes into account.
Emergency handling: Not a Jeep strong point by any measure but as an chassis engineer that has certified vehicles to be safe to various regulations, I'll say that I would be surprised if it would pass muster without track bars.
Other belt and suspenders: Since about 2008 Electronic Stability Control has been standard on Jeeps. Primarily to prevent rollovers which are so common with these high Cg vehices. A TJ doesn't have this belt and suspenders to keep a vehicle from getting to far out of control. I personally wouldn't want to be near a sideways TJ with lots of lateral force on the axles without a track bar.
Competitive landscape. Even as the post suggest, others at lest put some sort of travel limiter in there if not an actual track bar.
I thought I'd post a funny snippet.
"Jeep added them to the YJ because Nader's boys were attacking jeeps because of roll over issues, so I should add, if you plan on driving your jeep on the street at 40 MPH and then turning your steering wheel left and right as fast as you can (this is how Nader showed jeeps roll over), keep your track bar, or
better yet buy a Porsche" (empahsis mine
)
The problem is this maneuver that is described is a very simple emergency lane change at 40 mph. I guess if you don't mind rollover risk . . . and value maximum off-road articulation which is only needed for rock crawling . . . then remove the track bar. Can't disagree there.
https://www.wranglerforum.com/threads/to-tr...ack-bar.361065/Decide what you will, but, as someone that has done chassis engieering - there were no "extra" parts put in there.
You mention that you will put them back in if something gets squirrely. I'll only say that if it gets really squirrely in an emergency handling scenario, you may not get a 2nd chance to put them back in. There is a reason emergency handling developement is done with outriggers on vehices . . . to prevent the vehicle from going up on two wheels. I'll pretty much guarantee that your son won't have the right instincts to put it back down if it goes up on two.
Sorry to be so passionate about this. Jeeps are dangerous enough. No need to make them more dangerous for a novice driver by taking out the track bars.