I personally think impacts are easier on hardware than breaker bars. I’ve snapped off a lot of bolt heads to draw that conclusion. It can also help to tighten a bolt a millimeter before you loosen.
I’ve parted out a lot of rusty cars and yes, the seat belt bolts are always tight but I’ve never snapped them.
The internet agrees with me;
It seems that an impact gun does much better job handling an over-torqued nut. The continues force that a breaker bar imposes can easily destroy bolts or studs. Whereas, an impact gun can open nuts with no damage.Nov 1, 2015
https://mechanics.stackexchange.com › ...
Does using an impact wrench instead of a breaker bar prevent In most cases, using an impact gun will be less likely to cause the fastener to fail. Here is my reasoning: Impact guns provide high torque for very short periods of time. This jarring action or "impact" is going to be more likely to free the fastener.Jul 23, 2015
https://mechanics.stackexchange.com › ...
Which is least likely to cause twisting off of rusted bolts? Impact gun or ...