Just drove the Cayman S week before last. It is flat-out obscenely good to drive, and much better looking in person than in pictures (where have you heard that before). The New Beetle foglights don't even bug me no more.
Only bummer about the Cayman is that you WANT the PCCBs, Sport Chrono, Adaptive Sport seats, and PASM. You don't want the 19s (except for pose value, if that's your gig). The bummer part is that puts the price up to $75K-80K. I'm sure the base car with no options is grand, too, but the options above really DO do good things for a serious driver.
I'll give any mainstream mag props for getting a 914 on the pages (in a positive way, anyway), but they shoulda compared it to the 916, not the GT. I'd rather have either than a Cayman S, but then I'd rather have a Cayman S than any late-model 911 with the sole exception of the GT3.
I think a garage with one old Porsche and one new one is the ideal setup, but then that's just me...
pete