sorry for the late response...spent the weekend disassembling the car at the chassis shop!
Can't wait... they start cutting this week.
Anyway, my thoughts are this...
The 930 is notchy no matter what, just the nature of the beast. Not to be confused with vague of course... they are definitely not vague, but still a bitch to shift fast 2-3 or 3-2.
The bigger differences between mine and the Renegade (from what I can tell in pix and I felt a couple years ago) are these:
1. I bring the R-1-3 "H" selecting cable in completely perpendicular to the shaft in the trans. When shifting 1-2 or 3-4, the cable end still has to move side to side, but there is no "push or pull" on the cable that you would have from coming in at an angle (looking at MikeP's post, it appears that cable comes in at a bit of an angle from the bracket).
Any angularity will begin adding push or pull (depending on whether going from 1-2 or 2-1). The more of this push/pull effect you have, the vaguer (is that a word
- I conjugate my own from time to time) the shifting will be.
2. There is no adjustability for pattern, it is direct to the shaft. A little offset by using the studs and the "rod end reversal" like I did makes it nice to tune the pattern to what you like to "feel". No offset is just a super tight pattern on the "H", but the fore/aft stuff is 1:1 which I would think would be kind of a long throw. If they used a short shifting handle to make this tighter, the H would tighten up as well. Long throw with a tight H would feel vague to me too since it makes it hard to tell whether you selected 3rd in the H or if you are going for 1st. You gotta have some H pattern...
long description.. short review: I can adjust the H by moving the cable up and down the stud - closer to the shift rod is tighter, spaced away is a bigger H. Fore and aft, if I shorten the linkage between the cable and the swivel rod end, tighter fore/aft (and more effort is required). Right now I am definitely NOT 1:1, but much tighter fore/aft, but do have some offset to broaden the H up so I can tell where 3rd v. 1st is.
3. None of their inputs are in the exact direction of motion... the fore and aft selection is angled from the bracket - mine is truly parallel to the input shaft. Their's will induce some side to side motion in your fore/aft selection = vague feeling. Again, the H isn't perpendicular, so vague. Even the slightest pulls "on paper" are really quite noticeable in reality.
Classic engineering example I deal with every day here at work... "the side to side push/pull is only .030", so no big deal" to which I respond "multiplied by a 4" shift handle input = .120", basically 1/8". You wouldn't feel the .030" at the trans, but you definitely feel the 1/8" in your right hand ."
Drive-ability, you are in OC and my car is being worked on in Orange near the circle off Chapman. I have the engine and trans out of the car sitting behind it right now. I will be there next Saturday afternoon to remove the interior while they cut out the floorpan... let me know if you would like to swing by and see the stuff personally. Maybe it will help you out.