Dan join the club, tires are the most difficult choice because there is no way of getting a true test or review. In golf they have the iron byron which is a robotic golf club swinging device in which balls and clubs can be tested to the same degree.
With tires we have to go by drivers feel and opinion, until they have a slot car type test track in which all the turns and braking are governed by the same turning force and angle at the same time, has same braking force and speed is controlled by a computer program we are only guessing.
I really like the Yokohama ES100's and I believe the Hankook RS2 212's are a hell of a tire at any price.
I am shopping for tires right now and I just eliminated the Bridgestone S03's from my list I cant believe you get a significant bang for the buck, and am finding it hard not to purchase another set of ES100's for 373.00 bucks delivered.
These are the tires ive been looking at:
ES100's
Toyo T1-R's
Hankook RS2 212's
I was taking to a tuner today who works at the high performance tire shop in town, his car is featured in this months Euro tuner magazine. He is running the Toyo T1-R's and tells me he likes them better than the S03's and the Yoko Avs's that he has had on his car. Car and driver rated the Toyo's poor placing them no better than 8th in comparison to the other tires tested, the Hankooks were like 3rd.
So how can you really form any idea on what is good. YOU CANT DAMN IT unless you can try them all out on your own car.
The good news is all these tires are good, and better than anything that you've ever rolled on so you will probably love anything you end up with.
I cant find any fault with the ES100's having driven them on the street. And it's really not fair to compare the performance of track or Dot R tires to summer performance street tires even though thats what we dream of.
I hope I dont drive crazy enough to test the limits of my street tires on road and am sure that what ever you or I choose we will still be happy with our choice.