Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Rear valance and engine heat
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
MoveQik
I recently bought a fiberglass rear valance. It is the larger /6 style. Shortly after I bought it, it was brought to my attention that this has been rumored to trap warm air around the engine. In theory this seems logical....any truth to this in reality? More heat is the last thisg that I need here in AZ.
brant
yes..

Air_Cooled_Nut
No.
Ferg
Maybe chairfall.gif

john rogers
Yes and No. Yes if you do not have one of the large stock type mufflers that would sit in front of it such as a race car with stingers and No if you have the muffler.
MoveQik
QUOTE(Ferg @ Nov 9 2006, 09:18 AM) *

Maybe chairfall.gif

slap.gif

Fantastic....you guys are great. I assume that Brant is serious but I'm not sure about the "no" answer.

In all seriousness, I currently have an aftermarket 911 muffler(see my avatar) on it that has been rumored to be on the large side. How about if I "slotted" the valance and glassed in some mesh behind the slots? confused24.gif You think that would get the air out?
So.Cal.914
QUOTE(MW 914 @ Nov 9 2006, 08:42 AM) *

QUOTE(Ferg @ Nov 9 2006, 09:18 AM) *

Maybe chairfall.gif

slap.gif

Fantastic....you guys are great. I assume that Brant is serious but I'm not sure about the "no" answer.

In all seriousness, I currently have an aftermarket 911 muffler(see my avatar) on it that has been rumored to be on the large side. How about if I "slotted" the valance and glassed in some mesh behind the slots? confused24.gif You think that would get the air out?


I am sure it would help alot but with that big muffler in the way it probably

deflects alot of air.
Aaron Cox
you probably wont notice any adverse effects...

TROJANMAN
mike,
just buy a bigger radiator
oh....and all of that extra heat is probably what's making your brakes squeek
MoveQik
QUOTE(TROJANMAN @ Nov 9 2006, 10:39 AM) *

mike,
just buy a bigger radiator
oh....and all of that extra heat is probably what's making your brakes squeek laugh.gif

Note to self - Ignore all users from Colorado.
john rogers
In thinking about it more, it must NOT trap the heat as it certinly does not trap oil when you blow and engine wide open at speed. When mine went at about 120 or so all the oil went into the 356 right behind me!
LvSteveH
On your car, the muffler provides enough ram-jet effect to easily negate any issues with the rear valance (Have ya seen the size of his exhaust tips??)

Your best bet is to try it out and see. It will be interesting to see how it works with your oil cooler location. It only takes 5 minutes to take it back off if you need to.
MoveQik
QUOTE(LvSteveH @ Nov 9 2006, 10:44 AM) *

Your best bet is to try it out and see. It will be interesting to see how it works with your oil cooler location. It only takes 5 minutes to take it back off if you need to.

Thing is...I can sell it now if I want to. After I cut it for my exhaust it won't be worth much to any one else.
brant
Mike,

sorry for the differences of opinions.
someone here must have the old link.

once upon a time there was an old thread or link of a 914 guy who did ton's of actual temperature measurements.

was it brad anderson?.... can't remember
but in the old testing that was done, there was an actual test that showed removing the rear valance dropped engine bay or was it oil temperatures.

this was tested on a -4cylinder... but should yield similar results on a -6

my experience is only racing, but I've ALWAYS been told and understood that for a track car you should drop the rear valance no matter which muffler you used. even if you have a large sausage style muffler, you can reduce the insulation to it by dropping the valance.

I don't think we are talking about a big difference.
I think that for a street car the aesthetics might outweigh the benefit.
but it is my belief that it will help lower temperatures some.

so as mentioned above, try running it both ways (off/on) and see if it helps you

brant
Howard
QUOTE(Aaron Cox @ Nov 9 2006, 09:31 AM) *

you probably wont notice any adverse effects...


agree.gif And that heat is 'all the way back' so unlikely to affect performance or passenger comfort. Having said that, I just cut a nice piece of insulation for my trunk. Got pretty warm (but not enough to melt the kids' crayons) back there on trek to RRC.
jsteele22
QUOTE(Howard @ Nov 9 2006, 10:57 AM) *

QUOTE(Aaron Cox @ Nov 9 2006, 09:31 AM) *

you probably wont notice any adverse effects...


agree.gif And that heat is 'all the way back' so unlikely to affect performance or passenger comfort. Having said that, I just cut a nice piece of insulation for my trunk. Got pretty warm (but not enough to melt the kids' crayons) back there on trek to RRC.



I think the thinking is that as air passes from the region under the engine, then past the tranny, it suddenly hits a wall at the rear of the car, a wall that drops just about straight down from the trunk floor level, down to the lower bumper level, and then a few more inches if you have a valence. So from the paint of view of air flow, its a major restriction. I've been working on my engine bay from the inside (just crawl under and sit on the gound) and I was thinking just the other day, that from that perspective the rear end of the car looks like a drag chute. Anyway, based on this I would be willing to bet that removing the valence gives some inprovement, but I have no clue how much.

WARNING : Some of the opinions expressed in this post originated in the state of Colorado. They may not be suitable for consumption by pesons living in other areasa. Please consult a qualified non-Colorado resident before taking this advice at face value. May contain nuts.
brant
exactly Jeff!

and in a snow state like colorado, you will find many of the old cars have valances bent outward where they have drug in deep snow.

the valance (in order to hide everything for aesthetics) is the lowest hanging item usually.

VegasRacer
Elvira has a deep rear valance and I have never had any problems with heat.

*(I also know not to keep my Crayons in the rear trunk)
McMark
happy11.gif
anthony
So what is the goal here? If you have a 3.2L six then I assume you have a front oil cooler and no cooling issues. Correct?

It sounds like you have plenty of power so trying to improve airflow under the car isn't going to help that much. Unless this is a race car I'd keep the valence because it looks so much better.
MoveQik
QUOTE(anthony @ Nov 9 2006, 12:42 PM) *

So what is the goal here? If you have a 3.2L six then I assume you have a front oil cooler and no cooling issues. Correct?

It sounds like you have plenty of power so trying to improve airflow under the car isn't going to help that much. Unless this is a race car I'd keep the valence because it looks so much better.

The goal is to not trap a bunch of hot/dead air around the motor since I have the oil cooler under the rear trunk. The cooler under the trunk was sort of an experiment. So far, no trouble but I've only run it in sub-100 degree temps. If need be I will relocate it to the front but I would prefer not to. So...my question was really at trying to determine if the valance would reduce airflow bacck there enough to hinder the oil cooler.
McMark
If you've already got it, run it. All we've got right now is 'old' information. Keep and eye on the temps and let us know what you find out. biggrin.gif
anthony
Pretty easy to run with and without and see if you notice a difference.
MoveQik
QUOTE(anthony @ Nov 9 2006, 02:19 PM) *

Pretty easy to run with and without and see if you notice a difference.

I agree. I was just looking for easy answers before I cut up a valance. wink.gif
East coaster
When in doubt......vent it out sawzall-smiley.gif

Click to view attachment
turboman808
Or just get rid of it.

IPB Image
Howard
Valances and engine tin are for sissies alfred.gif

brant
did this turn into a thread about valance-less cars?

hey howard, whats that drip pan for?
is that where the "incontin(g)ent" signature came from?
brant
and here is version #2....

I saved weight by building a different bracket:
MoveQik
QUOTE(brant @ Nov 9 2006, 08:57 PM) *


hey howard, whats that drip pan for?
is that where the "incontin(g)ent" signature came from?

Brant - perhaps you should ask Howard where he got that drip pan? biggrin.gif

Lemme guess....that is just from working on the car, right??
Howard
Drip pans are for sissies, too. There ain't one under Moby.. that's a skid plate poke.gif
brant
ahhh....

but do you see the oil line in the bucket.
I was changing the oil, which caused the mess.

brant
TROJANMAN
QUOTE(brant @ Nov 10 2006, 06:54 AM) *

ahhh....
but do you see the oil line in the bucket.
I was changing the oil, which caused the mess.
brant

don't overwhelm him brant
I am not sure he knows what it means to change the oil
to him, changing the oil means writing a check
MoveQik
QUOTE(TROJANMAN @ Nov 10 2006, 07:38 AM) *

QUOTE(brant @ Nov 10 2006, 06:54 AM) *

ahhh....
but do you see the oil line in the bucket.
I was changing the oil, which caused the mess.
brant

don't overwhelm him brant
I am not sure he knows what it means to change the oil
to him, changing the oil means writing a check

....and I can assure you that it wouldn't go to a shop with floors as dirty as Brant's. cool.gif
carr914
If you want a rear valance, go out and get some wine & cheese too

T.C.
VegasRacer
KMA.gif

Click to view attachment
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.