The result was excellent. Same stitches, the vinyl grain is very similar, and similar thickness.
Now, it was simple for my grandma to make, and she offered to make a few more, if I wanted to sell them. Would anyone here be interested? Im not sure exactly how much they are worth, but I was thinking $30ish +shipping....
Here are some pics, I havent had a chance to staple it on:
BEFORE AND AFTER:

