QUOTE
The rear cover gasket isn't critical, it's just there, and there's only one thickness. The gaskets between the housing and the intermediate plate are CRITICAL. They fine tune the pinion depth and MUST be correct. If you didn't replace the old ones with the EXACT set, you're pretty well screwed, and will have to get someone with the correct tools to determine the correct pinion depth. There IS NO OTHER WAY. The Cap'n
QUOTE
I only somewhat agree.
True, the rear one is no big deal. If you just did the build then you should not have to worry about a leak when you reassemble. NO GOOP!
The gaskets that are between the intermediate plate and the tranz housing are critical. You do not count number of gaskets, you measure thickness of each gasket and replace with comparable size. The best place to measure the total gasket thicknesses is at a point where they are not compressed - where there is a void in the plate. This thickness will give you the best reading for the stock setting. Where I differ with John is in the "your pretty well screwed" sentiment. While the most correct way is to replace the gaskets with exact thickness replacements, it is totally possible to throw all of the gaskets, or some combo to split the error difference on from a seal kit and have it run fine. This sounds like heresy, but I have had people do it many times and NEVER had a problem with it (if I didnt see it I would not believe it either). There is a reason that the right way is the right way, it gives you the largest margin for a positive outcome, but the other ways still have a pretty sizable margin for a positive outcome.
Remove the cone, replace the pin, put it back together with no goop and see what happens. If it doesnt work, you can go from there.
Keep us posted.
That's all well and good, except there's no chance in hell that I'd be able to get a measurement of the thickness of the old gaskets since they've already been replaced. I know for a fact that there was two gaskets between the intermediate plate and the housing- it was obvious when I tore it apart. So that's what I put back on it from the kit I bought from Pelican. But I checked with the PO anyway, and he tells me he never had the tranny rebuilt. So assuming that the gaskets were original factory, what measurement should I have on pinion depth? If there's numbers or something I need to get off the tranny to find this out, no problem, just lemme know.
As for gooping/not gooping, it'll just be a matter of time on that. I've got a long way to go before the engine and tranny go back in the car. But I'll go ahead and try to tear it apart w/out damaging the new gasket I've installed- if I can do it successfully then I'll still have a gasket and won't have to worry about goop.