QUOTE(rjames @ Feb 12 2009, 03:19 PM)
QUOTE
BTW, don't get near that rust with Por-15......Rust Mort or Ospho with a coat or 2 of etching primer will see you thru ....till next time.
A lot of folks are down on Por-15, but if used correctly and as directed, I think it works great. I think a lot of people make the mistake of not treating the rust before applying it. Por-15 is not a rust converter, it's a sealer/primer. The product the company makes for rust converting is MetalReady which is a converter/metal etching solution.
Just my $.02, now back to the original thread already in progress.
I agree. I think people expect it to work magic. I think a common problem is lack of cleaning of oil, etc. The other is that they treat metal that is rusted through and they coat just one surface, so it rusts from the inside out. I have no doubt that "professionals" can screw it up as well.
I also am a big fan of media blasting vs. rust conversion only for two reasons. (1), why convert rust to something else (and probably not get it all) when you can remove it. (2), it creates a "surface profile" that gives whatever you choose (POR or something else) something to adhere to properly.
Also, I think the something like Ospho works much better after a very light media blasting. Try this yourself if you have some Ospho or Metal Ready. Take some new sheet metal. Cut it into three sections. Clean all three (remove oil, etc.). Leave one as is, clean one with a flapper disk on a grinder or use a knotted wire wheel on it, lightly media blast the last one. Then spray all three with Ospho/Metal Ready. You will see that the first two don’t get etched much at all. In fact I think the second one that was sanded, ends up with a polished surface that doesn’t get etched much at all. The last one is etched much more than the other two. Which one do you think will work best with a sealer/primer like POR or some other product?
My 2 cents as well. Sorry for the hijack.