Starter one and done, Starters not lasting Options

[JKincaid]

Hey everyone-

I have been experiencing issues with the Bosch rebuilt starters. I have gone through three in the last 5 times I have taken the car out and it's beginning to get pretty old having to pull the starter and replace it almost every time I take the car out. I know that the high torque starters are probably a better/more reliable option. I guess my real question is could it be something that is wrong with the electrical system causing these problems or is it just a case of poor quality of the rebuilt starters? Thanks in advance for any feedback.

[Beebo Kanelle]

is your battery fully charged?

I have had problems when the voltage drops, creating a larger amperage draw.

check to see if there any bad connections which might have a higher than normal resistance.

See what you voltage is when the stater is engaged ( I know, easier said than done)

good luck

[IronHillRestorations]

A bad battery cable could cause low voltage.

[mepstein]

I get all our alternators rebuilt at the local battery store. Starters too. Runs $75-100 and takes about 2 days. Only one came back with an issue out of at least 30 so far.

[GeorgeRud]

Have you installed a starter relay to provide full voltage to the solenoid? A lot of Bosch starter problems are actually caused by low voltage rather than a starter malfunction.

[Rand]

could it be something that is wrong with the electrical system causing these problems

Clearly. Three failures in the last five runs? Starters don't fail at that high of a rate.

What are your exact symptoms and how did you troubleshoot to determine the starter needed replacing? Don't assume if it stops cranking, that throwing another starter at it is the right solution. There are many more likely causes than the starter, such as cracked ignition switch, dirty battery connections, dirty ground strap connections, etc...

[mgphoto]

These older cars have issues with the electric connectors.
The starter has a very large copper wire that can get corrosion collecting on the ends.
Find all the connections and clean them off, good wire brush.

sometimes you need to remove the crimped connection clean the wire and replace the connector, make sure you get all the corrosion betweens the strands of the heavy cable.
I like to acid dip the cable, neturalize and than solder the heavy cable strands as one unit, than replace connector.

Sound like your voltage is being taken up by corrosion gaps.

[DM_2000]

Our guy needs to be more specific as to what the symptoms are and what specific part of the starter is failing.