front main seal - should I or shouldn't I, "might as well" or "leave well enough alone"? Options

[iankarr]

Hi Guys,

Been really trying to tighten up the miscellaneous leaks on my 2056. What I thought was a leak from a bad front main seal looks like it is actually caused by a partially disintegrated oil pump gasket. See pic below.

I don't see evidence of an active leak from the main seal, but there is some sticky oil residue around it.

My general approach to old cars is not to fix something that aint broke, or risk messing something else up in the process. But since the motor is out and I have all the stuff to replace the seal (and the oil pump gasket), do you think it's a good idea to replace the front? Or leave well enough alone? FYI, the motor was last gone through about 10 years ago.

Thanks!

[Chris914n6]

My general rule of thumb is 10 years or 100k or be ok with the impending minor leak. 125-150k is when I usually see undersides covered in sludge. In the NE it may take longer than 10 years for the rubber to dry out and leak.