QUOTE(Mark Henry @ Nov 20 2010, 10:37 AM)
I guess watching my dad's '67 go up in flames in the middle of a Sears parking lot, on new years eve, with 4 fire trucks and police and a large crowd gathering was just a figment of my childhood imagination.
The "old wife's tale" comes from the late sixties when VW tried to place the gas heater above the tranny. Many rusted out, spewed gas and went up in flames. VW abandoned placing them there shortly after that do to liability issues and put them back in the trunk.
It was fun watch everyone hit the deck when the tires blew.
I will defer to your experience with your dad's car going up in flames; you were there, I wasn't.
However, in my experience with VWs, 99% of all fires are due to fuel
hoses cracking and spewing raw fuel which causes a fire, NOT a malfunction w/in the Eberspacher heater itself. There's a big difference. Like all fuel hoses, if not maintained and changed regularly, you will have a fire. The other 1% came from fuel hose nipples coming loose. I've never seen an Eberspacher heater as the cause. Not saying it has never happened, I just think the heaters get the bad rap for the real cause which is faulty fuel lines.
What I was getting at was what McMark more eloquently stated; when well maintained, they are safe. I can't say that about the aftermarket Stewart Warner heaters though. They do not have the safety features of the Eberspachers and did start a few fires. Personally speaking, I would
never use or install a SW heater.
What cars, other than the 411/412, did VW put the heaters above the trans?? In the U.S. they never did, ONLY the 411/412 and buses with the BA6 had them under the cargo floor. . . All the BA4s and BA6s that I have pulled from under the cars have been in pristine condition (once the dust was removed).