Huh... I didn't know there was a difference on 1.7s. Thanks for the heads up Mark!
Matt, sounds like you just need to give it a little more umph.
Like Dave and others have said, make sure the grooves are really clean first (I used a few cans of brake cleaner to get rid of all the sludge and grit) and oil them as well. Then make sure you twist and push hard as they go in. You'll feel them "snap" into place.