Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What size is the fitting for the oil pressure sender
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
Pages: 1, 2
gothspeed
+1 ....... as you mentioned, there is a .0022" delta in thread pitch between the NPT and the 10mm x 1.0 ..... 'per thread' ...... so unless someone is only planning on 3 threads of engagement, it does not take long to stack .0022" over several turns before it becomes a problem.

In my experience, it only took about 2 finger tension turns, for me to realize there was something wrong. The factory may have specified a tapered thread in this application but it certainly was not an NPT thread. These old cases already have enough problems to deal with, without us purposely creating more of them. popcorn[1].gif
stugray
sgetsiv - thank you for confirming my suspicion.

Again "WHY would german engineers make an entire engine with Metric threads and then in only one place put in SAE threads?"

Ask this question: "What is the thread of the CHT?"

And dont go playing the "engineer" card to much, it tends to piss off the natives. (I have EE with 20 years in Aerospace).

Good job on the investigative work. I agree wholeheartedly with your conclusion.

Stu
nathansnathan
I found the link I was thinking of, not a word, but a standard is what it was, from the Deutsches Institut für Normung e. V..

DIN 158-1
mating tapered external threads to parallel internal screw threads.

http://engineers.ihs.com/document/abstract/ZSMXJBAAAAAAAAAA

QUOTE
DIN DIN 158-1: Metric taper external and mating parallel internal screw threads - Dimensions, tolerances and inspection
Publication Date: Jun 1, 1997
SDO: DIN: Deutsches Institut für Normung e. V.
DOD Adopted ANSI Approved Approved
Scope and field of application

This standard specifies profiles, dimensions and methods of verification for general purpose metric taper external threads intended to be mated with parallel internal threads with a basic profile as specified in ISO/DIS 68-1

Taper external threads as specified in this standard are intended for self-sealing joints, such as those employed on pipe plugs, compression couplings and lubricating nipples. They can be used in all cases where a parallel threaded joint with washer is unsatisfactory for technical or economic reasons.

For fluids such as oils, other liquids and gases, no thread sealants are required for joints where the nominal size is small. For joints of greater nominal size, it is recommended that sealants be applied, since the leaktightness of such joints decreases as the diameter increases.

A short design taper external thread has been specified along with the standard design both to be mated with general purpose IS0 metric parallel internal threads of tolerance class 4H for the pitch diameter and 5H for the minor diameter (as in ISO/DIS 965-1).

Aussengewinde
metrisches Gewinde
Cap'n Krusty
The stock oil pressure switch is definitely a M10mm x 1.0 thread pitch, not tapered. The engine case is tapped near the distributor for an M10mm x 1.0, not a 1/8" NPT. And yes, it takes a narrow wall deep 24mm socket to remove the stock sensor from the case.
Hope someone finds this useful...
[/quote]

In this case, you are ABSOLUTELY wrong. The sender is tapered, and it's READILY VISIBLE to the naked eye. Senders that are not tapered come with a captive sealing washer. Furthermore, I have been installing switches and accessories with 1/8 NPT fittings into both aluminum and mag Porsche cases for more than 40 years (and that's only the time I've spent as a professional wrench, in addition to the other 15 years or so before I became employed as a mechanic) and have yet to run across a case of thread damage caused by such installation. BTW, if you have the factory tool, you don't need that deep well socket, either.

The Cap'n
stugray
Cap'n,

Would you please explain how I can thread a 10mm X 1.0 threaded adapter WITH NO BINDING into: The oil pressure sensor port, the CHT port, and the brakes absolutely perfectly?

When I try to thread in a NPT it binds after only three threads.

The adapter (10mmX1.0 to NPT) worked perfectly and does not leak.

I think the only debate here is IF the 10mmX1.0 on the sender units are tapered or not.
I could believe the taper to help with electrical contact.

I think that we have determined that the NPT threaded sensor works fine, but was not the original design ( based on sgetsiv's measurements)

Just because someone has been doing it wrong for 40 years and it works does not make it correct, just good enough.

The guy I race with every other weekend that builds RSRs for a living laughed at the thought that there was a SAE thread anywhere on a Porsche engine when I mentioned it.
Cap'n Krusty
I suggest you read Post #48, above, and pay particular attention to the highlighted sentence in the illustration. Please note the illustration is a copy of a page in the factory workshop manual. Granted, there are errors here and there in the manual, one being the rear brake venting clearance, but this isn't one of those errors. The hole is tapered, the switch is tapered, and I believe my practical (and yes, anecdotal) experience is good in play here. While the 10mm taper and the 1/8 NPT taper are not EXACTLY the same, they're plenty close enough to fit, to seal, and don't cause damage to the parent metal. Brake line fittings (and 356/912 oil line fittings) are 10mm fine straight thread. In the case of European bubble flare brake fittings, the seal is made by the flare, not the threads. In the case of brake line banjo fittings, the seal is provided by copper washers. In the case of 356/912 oil lines, the ferrule does the sealing. If you use a 10mm fine thread fitting in the tapered hole for the oil pressure switch, you will need a sealing washer to affect an leak proof connection. The factory does not provide for such a seal in this case, even though it is common in other oil pressure switch applications in both Porsche and VW/Audi Group applications. I rest my case, as I'm tired of beating this poor horse. You can choose to do what is both practical and works, or screw around indefinitely posing engineer excuses why it can't/won't while I put miles on my car. Same goes for the seat belt anchor bolts. Remember, it's the job of the wrench/mechanic/tech to make what the engineers design actually work in real life!

The Cap'n
gothspeed
QUOTE(stugray @ Dec 9 2013, 12:15 PM) *

Cap'n,

Would you please explain how I can thread a 10mm X 1.0 threaded adapter WITH NO BINDING into: The oil pressure sensor port, the CHT port, and the brakes absolutely perfectly?

When I try to thread in a NPT it binds after only three threads.

The adapter (10mmX1.0 to NPT) worked perfectly and does not leak.

I think the only debate here is IF the 10mmX1.0 on the sender units are tapered or not.
I could believe the taper to help with electrical contact.

I think that we have determined that the NPT threaded sensor works fine, but was not the original design ( based on sgetsiv's measurements)

Just because someone has been doing it wrong for 40 years and it works does not make it correct, just good enough.

The guy I race with every other weekend that builds RSRs for a living laughed at the thought that there was a SAE thread anywhere on a Porsche engine when I mentioned it.
+1000 ....... doing something wrong for 40 years does not make it ok.

BTW every 1/8 NPT male thread fitting I have seen stuffed into a 10 mm x 1.0 tapered or not ..... was 'forced in' and numerous times upon removal I have noticed metal shavings from the 10mm side (aluminum or magnesium depending on what it was made of) ....... all this good information on this 'thread pitch difference', confirms the thread deformations and particulates/shavings I have seen in those interfaces, on many motors throughout the years.
stugray
QUOTE
I suggest you read Post #48, above, and pay particular attention to the highlighted sentence in the illustration.


I did.
pay particular attention to: "The oil pressure switch is sealed by means of the tapered threads"
In my opinion that means that the threads of the part being screwed IN is tapered. That makes perfect sense if the part has to make electrical contact upon installation.

Nowhere does it say that the threads on either side are SAE OR that the threads in the case are tapered.
If the threads in the case were tapered then I could not thread in a 10mmX1.0 fitting without it binding.

And Yes you have to use a crush washer if you install the 10mmX1.0 to 1/8"NPT adapter into the case.
0396
QUOTE(stugray @ May 6 2013, 10:02 PM) *

So I followed the above advice and got the 6" grease gun hose at autozone.
I still installed the 10mm to 1/8NPT adapter. It threads into the case perfectly and the hose threads into that like it should.
And I used some brass...
Anyway, I wanted to find a solid place to mount it where I could also thread on a mechanical gauge when I want to, and remove it easily.

Here is my solution: One hole drilled in fan shroud and some scrap aluminum I had laying around.

The mount that holds the brass tee is somewhat shock isolated with rubber.
I can easily unscrew the mech gauge and plug the port.

IPB Image

IPB Image

It doesnt interfere with the coil position either.
Thanks for the tips.

Stu



Very cool, where did you buy the gage , T, and sender? Harbor freight?

Thanks
stugray
Gauge, jegs or pegassus.
It is for an accusump oil resivoir.
Turns out it is actually meant to read the air pressure on the "dry side" of the accusump, but seems to work fine.
I will remove it before racing, but I wanted an independent gauge when I first primed the engine.

T & adapters - Ace hardware.

Adapter into the case Pegasus
sender - Pelican
gothspeed
Looks good!! smilie_pokal.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.