Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Tube fitting, making a transmission mount ends in frustration
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
914forme
I have been working on mocking up pieces for my Conversion. I tack weld stuff up, and then bribe my buddy who is a pro welder to come over and do the good stuff. He's a sucker for Brisket, I can smoke a mean Brisket beerchug.gif

But this is where I ran into issues. I can cope tube to tube joints all day long. Find the angle run it through my machine make it a little long and grind / file it for a perfect fit. Easy enough.

Well the transmission mount, I am going with 2 plates one up top, one below. They mount into a poly mount at the top much like the stock transmission mounts. multiple angles are involved. After several weekends of playing with the idea, I got me one of these. Click to view attachment

It did make to process closer but still not accurate enough for me to say I am done.

So what are the tricks?

I could build it out of flat pieces and make a box. 16a sheet metal would work. I just like tube.

I could take a piece of rod or wire and cut it to fit, then tack in place and figure out my angles and then transfer that to tube. Just looking for a good trick to get this done, and learn something new.

Here is what I came up with so far, my welding buddy will reject it as the gaps are to big, and I agree. headbang.gif

Click to view attachment
bulitt
That pipe master thingy looks nice but I usually just tape a piece of heavy paper around a PVC tube and transfer the angle with a school compass. Once the length and both ends are trimmed just slide the paper onto the metal tube and transfer the cuts with a marker.
andys
QUOTE(bulitt @ Feb 9 2015, 09:12 AM) *

That pipe master thingy looks nice but I usually just tape a piece of heavy paper around a PVC tube and transfer the angle with a school compass. Once the length and both ends are trimmed just slide the paper onto the metal tube and transfer the cuts with a marker.


Bob,

Could you further explain this method; I'm having trouble grasping the concept.

Thanks,

Andys
Mueller
http://www.blocklayer.com/Pipe-Notching.aspx


^Give that a try...
914forme
Okay Im and idiot, what I need is lying right there on the bench. Since its tacked, I can just measure the proper angles. headbang.gif headbang.gif headbang.gif headbang.gif

Am I wrong in this idea.

I would still love how to mock this up easier, always willing to learn a new trick.

Mike, nice, I normally do them with a chop saw and a lot of filing. That could get it closer, maybe.

I have a chart I keep in the shop I grabbed of Pirate for this.

"Here is one from Marc Googer on www.Offroadfabnet.com :

The chop saw method, if understood, is a science. With known tube size and joint angle, tube can be notched with great accuracy. The notch is achieved by cutting two opposing angles on one end of a piece of tube, to form a point. The cross-section of this cut will be an elliptical cut due to the shape of the tube. Changes in both of the two angled cuts must be made for the intersection angle and the size of the two tubes being joined. The only real limitation is the max angle of the chop saw.

You start with what I call the base angle. This is the angle of both cuts if the joint was 90*. For an example, I am fitting Two tubes together that are both 1.75", at an 90* joint. The base angle, or the angle of both cuts is 28*. These two cuts must meet at a point, and the point must also be centered on the tube.

Remember your base angle will change with the tube being cut and the tube that you are fitting to.

Here are a few examples of base angles...

2.0" to 2.0" tube, base angle of 30*

1.75" to 1.75" tube, base angle of 28*

1.5" to 1.5" tube, base angle of 26*

1.25" to 1.25" tube, base angle of 22.5*

1" to 1" tube, Base angle of 20*

Now to fit different size tubes together

1.75" to 2" tube, base angle of 25*

1.75" to 1.25" tube, base angle of 45*

1.25" to 1.75 tube, base angle of 20*

1" to 2" tube, base angle of 12*

What if instead of a "T" joint, I want the notched tube at a 15* angle with my first 1.75" tube???? You must start with your base angle, which was 28* for 1.75"(remember above), and subtract 15* from one cut, and add 15* to the other cut to form a perfect notch. So now I must make a 13* cut and an 43* cut with the point centered on the tube. Perfect coped joint, with no grinding.

Written by Marc Googer
[Edited slightly for clarity by TNToy]"

Its simple enough and gets you close. He claims no grinding, his chop saw must be more accurate than mine.
Jeff Hail
QUOTE(914forme @ Feb 9 2015, 11:49 AM) *

Okay Im and idiot, what I need is lying right there on the bench. Since its tacked, I can just measure the proper angles. headbang.gif headbang.gif headbang.gif headbang.gif

Am I wrong in this idea.

I would still love how to mock this up easier, always willing to learn a new trick.

Mike, nice, I normally do them with a chop saw and a lot of filing. That could get it closer, maybe.

I have a chart I keep in the shop I grabbed of Pirate for this.

"Here is one from Marc Googer on www.Offroadfabnet.com :

The chop saw method, if understood, is a science. With known tube size and joint angle, tube can be notched with great accuracy. The notch is achieved by cutting two opposing angles on one end of a piece of tube, to form a point. The cross-section of this cut will be an elliptical cut due to the shape of the tube. Changes in both of the two angled cuts must be made for the intersection angle and the size of the two tubes being joined. The only real limitation is the max angle of the chop saw.

You start with what I call the base angle. This is the angle of both cuts if the joint was 90*. For an example, I am fitting Two tubes together that are both 1.75", at an 90* joint. The base angle, or the angle of both cuts is 28*. These two cuts must meet at a point, and the point must also be centered on the tube.

Remember your base angle will change with the tube being cut and the tube that you are fitting to.

Here are a few examples of base angles...

2.0" to 2.0" tube, base angle of 30*

1.75" to 1.75" tube, base angle of 28*

1.5" to 1.5" tube, base angle of 26*

1.25" to 1.25" tube, base angle of 22.5*

1" to 1" tube, Base angle of 20*

Now to fit different size tubes together

1.75" to 2" tube, base angle of 25*

1.75" to 1.25" tube, base angle of 45*

1.25" to 1.75 tube, base angle of 20*

1" to 2" tube, base angle of 12*

What if instead of a "T" joint, I want the notched tube at a 15* angle with my first 1.75" tube???? You must start with your base angle, which was 28* for 1.75"(remember above), and subtract 15* from one cut, and add 15* to the other cut to form a perfect notch. So now I must make a 13* cut and an 43* cut with the point centered on the tube. Perfect coped joint, with no grinding.

Written by Marc Googer
[Edited slightly for clarity by TNToy]"

Its simple enough and gets you close. He claims no grinding, his chop saw must be more accurate than mine.


I use the longer side of the cut tube as my reference and always leave a little length for proper fitting. Always easier to take a little more off as needed than have to add metal (humor for the scrap bin).

I have a fairly large brain and the tube diameters are not much of an issue because base angles can be set to anything you want them to be whether on purpose or miscalculation (humor for the scrap bin).

On each end of the cut tube will always have two angles. Angles will vary.

The notches (sometimes called fishmouthing) are where things go sideways. Too shallow, not shallow enough or the incorrect profile to the joint to be mated to. End up with gaps and poor fitting joints. Tube to tube fitting can be made easier with whats called a "Snap Collar". Masking tape can do the same thing.

A good failsafe if the angle is less than 45d leave your tube 1/4 the diameter of the tube. If its more than 45d cut the tube at the intersection of the centerline. Centerline finder of improvised v block are great tools.

The joint in your picture above should not be difficult to fit up tightly even with simple drafting tools. Its a tube butted up to a plate. Work in right angles and watch the rotation of the tube using a centerline reference to the intersection. That's why the joints have air.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.