Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: are aluminum radiators generally repairable?
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
jimkelly
I have a renegade radiator in my v8 car and it is leaking. I bought the radiator from renegade probably around 2005, not much miles on it, but lots of years.

any suggestions on who I can buy a replacement radiator from? and cost? model number would be great.
GeorgeRud
If a local radiator shop can't help you, I imagine Renegade has them available. I've heard that galvanic action can cause breakdown of the aluminum, but all of mine are aircooled so not an issue! biggrin.gif

Good luck!
veekry9
http://www.griffinrad.com/company.php?tid=33

A custom rad for a custom install,front,side,rear.
colingreene
Depends on where the leak is coming from
Saldana Radiator in Indiana has always been my go to radiator people.
mb911
QUOTE(jimkelly @ Nov 27 2015, 11:31 AM) *

I have a renegade radiator in my v8 car and it is leaking. I bought the radiator from renegade probably around 2005, not much miles on it, but lots of years.

any suggestions on who I can buy a replacement radiator from? and cost? model number would be great.



Typically a good all aluminum radiator can be fixed I have done many of the years. They must be TIG welded and pressure tested.. Good luck
jimkelly
I just emailed griffin. dtf.

QUOTE(veekry9 @ Nov 27 2015, 01:17 PM) *

http://www.griffinrad.com/company.php?tid=33

A custom rad for a custom install,front,side,rear.

sb914
So my car had a renegade radiator that had less than a thousand miles on it when it started to leak.i pulled it out, took it to a rad shop and he could not fix it.he tried to fix but just couldn't hold pressure. So I ordered a new one from renegade. and less than a year went buy and it also leaked.the rad is floated in with all the proper schrods.it has the rubber on the sides and the bottom and the little supports on bottom per renegade install directions.I also have ground straps. So I called Scott the owner and ask him WTF.gif first he ask me if I could move rad up and down and side by side and to make sure it's not ridged as the car will flex with that much power.told him yes it floats.so then he went on and on about aluminum not being as pure as it used to be WTF.gif and I mean on and on.to make a very long story short he told me to use bars leaks rad stop leak. I was surprised that this was his fix being a hign end shop.Anyway I went ahead and used them as I didn't want to spend another 500 on another rad.it hasn't leaked since,but I'm sure it will.next time I'm going to go with someone else.
Andyrew
Where is the leak coming from? Mine started leaking at the fill neck...

I would think that any reputable radiator shop would make quick work of the leak.
jimkelly
bars.. huh..
jimkelly
looking at radiator from front, but I have a grill blocking obscuring the view, the leak seems to be along a horizontal tube at the far drivers side of the radiator. pic of center of radiator, so no value related to our discussion sad.gif

QUOTE(Andyrew @ Nov 27 2015, 02:56 PM) *

Where is the leak coming from? Mine started leaking at the fill neck...

I would think that any reputable radiator shop would make quick work of the leak.
Andyrew
QUOTE(jimkelly @ Nov 27 2015, 02:02 PM) *

looking at radiator from front, but I have a grill blocking obscuring the view, the leak seems to be along a horizontal tube at the far drivers side of the radiator. pic of center of radiator, so no value related to our discussion sad.gif

QUOTE(Andyrew @ Nov 27 2015, 02:56 PM) *

Where is the leak coming from? Mine started leaking at the fill neck...

I would think that any reputable radiator shop would make quick work of the leak.



I wouldnt throw stopleak out as a quick solution. However I would give your local radiator shops a call and tell them you have an aluminum radiator leaking from the core and see what they charge to fix it. It might be one pinhole leak that they can fix really easily.
jimkelly
yeah.. I may have one reasonably close.. I will call them tomorrow..
matthepcat
I had a similar experience. Maybe try a copper core radiator. In theory that material should have more "flex".
Chris914n6
Back in my day Renegade radiators were made by Ron Davis. Maybe they will warranty their work as they have a rep to keep.

http://www.rondavisradiators.com/
jimkelly
removed shroud cover. seems leak is clearly far more on the passenger side, up high. and radiator is 30.5" x 14.5".

also note that this celica radiator on ebay for $170 is almost exactly the same size.
matthepcat
Believe me it's not worth repairing. It will leak again in months. Just buy cheap new and replace every few years. I had a custom built Fluidyne unit that used a high performance Pantera core. Was more robust than the RH unit, but that as well had a tiny leak after a year of mountain drives.
Andyrew
Thats the radiator I have and Mike Bellis has. He's ran it and hasnt had any issues, I have just fabricated my mounting and seems like its a good quality dual core radiator.
Andyrew
Yup. You can see that I mounted mine really close to the front for extra trunk room since I am doing some other things with my trunk.
jimkelly
just ordered to splices from jags that run, a 1 to 1.5 and a 1.25 to 1.5, to I can mate up radiator to my existing hoses.

http://jagsthatrun.com/Pages/Parts_Cooling...seSplicers.html
Cairo94507
That just does not make sense. Aluminum radiators have been the performance solution for decades and I have never heard of them springing leaks routinely. What is going on to cause these units to fail? I do not like the bars leak fix either.
rmdinmd
I have never known bars leak to work for any period of time. Years ago if it was just one tube the Radiator shops would close off the leaking tube.
Cracker
Jim - I attached a little message on your thread earlier in the alignment post - don't know if you saw it. Anyhow, why don't you consider a steel radiator? I highly doubt weight is important with your application and they are used in OEM ALL the time. I'm using a steel unit and I have a problem OVER cooling. Just another option (that is stronger) and less leak prone. All the best.

Tony
jimkelly
I did miss that post. someone mentioned copper core. for $140, i think i'll give aluminum one more try. but will keep steel in mind. thanks beerchug.gif

QUOTE(Cracker @ Nov 28 2015, 07:51 AM) *

Jim - I attached a little message on your thread earlier in the alignment post - don't know if you saw it. Anyhow, why don't you consider a steel radiator? I highly doubt weight is important with your application and they are used in OEM ALL the time. I'm using a steel unit and I have a problem OVER cooling. Just another option (that is stronger) and less leak prone. All the best.

Tony

crash914
be sure to use the correct coolant for aluminum.

You might have to use the "Extended life" coolant. Just read the label carefully....usually the color is different. I like BMW coolant, its blue.
jimkelly
few more pics of the shrouding.
dlkawashima
QUOTE(Chris914n6 @ Nov 27 2015, 03:22 PM) *

Back in my day Renegade radiators were made by Ron Davis. Maybe they will warranty their work as they have a rep to keep.

My Renegade radiator also failed. Contacted Ron Davis and they said they will not warranty or even touch a radiator installed with the Renegade Hybrids kit. They said the mounting method is a flawed design that does a poor job of isolating the radiator from the stresses introduced by the relatively flexible nose of the 914.

Renegade now gets their radiators from CBR Performance. I *think* they're custom made for Renegade, but the model that's closest in size is the CBR1003, about 31”X14”X3”. They're not cheap.

The 2000-2005 Celica radiator is approximately the same size and quite a bit cheaper. You can find them all day long on ebay for less than $50 (with plastic water tank). You can even find all aluminum ones for under $100, including shipping.
jimkelly
I bought this one today. thanks.
ThePaintedMan
Chads74 has a Renegrade radiator too, and he's had it repaired at least twice. Renegade will NOT warranty them, despite the fact that the radiators are $800+. That's stromberg.gif in my opinion - knowing that and how many people are having problems with them tells me they don't value people's business. Right up there with AA.
Chris H.
Dang that Celica radiator is really becoming the standard! I've been using it for a couple of years myself. BIGKAT pointed it out (shocker). Fits great. Cools well.
Mike Bellis
QUOTE(Chris H. @ Nov 28 2015, 03:40 PM) *

Dang that Celica radiator is really becoming the standard! I've been using it for a couple of years myself. BIGKAT pointed it out (shocker). Fits great. Cools well.

agree.gif

Works great!
jimkelly
ray (aka: A&P Mech) provided me these additional pics of his celica radiator install. many thanks to ray for sharing these with us smile.gif

and here is his link to the grommets he used. I think the tabs at the top of the radiator have a different OD then the bottom tabs. I will confirm. I plan to make vibration cushions of similar dimension with smooth-on product.
A&P Mech
Jim, you are correct. The top and bottom isolation mount posts are different sizes. The post for the lower mount is larger than the top. All the pictures of the radiator that I found show the radiator sitting up side down from the way the that the Toyota OEM lower vibration mounts would dictate. I mounted mine based on that.
76-914
Jim, once your radiator is installed and topped off with fluids take your VOM and place your + lead in the liquid and the - lead to ground. Your checking for stray voltage which will amplify the electrolysis. Do the check with the key on and off. Let us know what you find. beerchug.gif
jimkelly
i'm thinking you are serious? just never heard anyone mention this before but then again, most of us to not have a radiator in our cars. you are wondering is stray voltage could be exacerbating a corrosion issue in my coolant system. interesting popcorn[1].gif

QUOTE(76-914 @ Nov 29 2015, 09:56 AM) *

Jim, once your radiator is installed and topped off with fluids take your VOM and place your + lead in the liquid and the - lead to ground. Your checking for stray voltage which will amplify the electrolysis. Do the check with the key on and off. Let us know what you find. beerchug.gif

76-914
Absotootely. The reason I wanted to see the voltage with key on/off is to isolate and ground any devices dumping voltage into the coolant. The transmission even does it to some extent. You, and I repeat, you cannot have too many grounds. In severe instances you can use an anode fitting to control it. Your Al radiator and CI block are worlds apart on the Galvanic chart. This will get you up to date............ http://www.engineersedge.com/galvanic_capatability.htm
dakotaewing
QUOTE(jimkelly @ Nov 29 2015, 08:14 AM) *

ray (aka: A&P Mech) provided me these additional pics of his celica radiator install. many thanks to ray for sharing these with us smile.gif

and here is his link to the grommets he used. I think the tabs at the top of the radiator have a different OD then the bottom tabs. I will confirm. I plan to make vibration cushions of similar dimension with smooth-on product.



Jim or Ray, can you provide the link for the grommets please?

Also, Ray do you have any more detail images of your mounting frame,
especially where the mount bolts into the body at the base,
and the mounts at the top connecting to the radiator?

Thanks so much for what you have already provided !

Thanks! Thom
A&P Mech
QUOTE(dakotaewing @ Nov 29 2015, 07:10 PM) *

QUOTE(jimkelly @ Nov 29 2015, 08:14 AM) *

ray (aka: A&P Mech) provided me these additional pics of his celica radiator install. many thanks to ray for sharing these with us smile.gif

and here is his link to the grommets he used. I think the tabs at the top of the radiator have a different OD then the bottom tabs. I will confirm. I plan to make vibration cushions of similar dimension with smooth-on product.



Jim or Ray, can you provide the link for the grommets please?

Also, Ray do you have any more detail images of your mounting frame,
especially where the mount bolts into the body at the base,
and the mounts at the top connecting to the radiator?

Thanks so much for what you have already provided !

Thanks! Thom


The link for the lower vibration mounts is:
http://www.amazon.com/Genuine-Toyota-16535...adiator+Support

Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment

There are a few more pictures in my build thread.
dakotaewing
Thanks Ray! What were you using for the uppers?
I looked at the images for your thread, but didn't see a reference.
Looks like a aluminum mount with the rubber bushing ?
Thanks again for the additional images !
A&P Mech
You are correct. I made aluminum mount and found a thick walled rubber gommet at the local hardware store that fit the radiator.
chads74
This is some great info. Like George said I have had nothing but issues with my RH radiator. It first started leaking after only a couple hundred miles and when I called to ask RH about it they just said good luck. Well I have been looking for a replacement ever since. Maybe George can have it all reinstalled by the time I get home... What do ya think George??? jk I wouldn't want to miss any of the fun.
jimkelly
seems ray welded tabs at the far ends of the lower mount as to stay away from the sheet metal work zone but i assume the lower mount can be attached to car anywhere along that bottom section of frame. those tabs must be a semi bitch to get bolts thru?
A&P Mech
QUOTE(jimkelly @ Nov 30 2015, 06:21 AM) *

seems ray welded tabs at the far ends of the lower mount as to stay away from the sheet metal work zone but i assume the lower mount can be attached to car anywhere along that bottom section of frame. those tabs must be a semi bitch to get bolts thru?


I placed the tabs in that location to avoid drilling through the floor. The thought was to keep the attachment hardware inside and out of the elements. It was probably over thinking it a bit but It really worked out great. The bolts are pretty easy to get in and out and the mount is very solid when bolted in. It almost feels like it is welded in place.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.