Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Al Reed restoration -- what size shoes to wear?
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
Jett
With the help of this form and others, we have been slowly restoring our Delphi Green 73 914 2.0/4 Appearence package and are finally approaching the completion. In preparation of the build completion we asked Al Reed to restore our wheels and they arrived this morning. We think the wheels are amazing smile.gif

That said, I was going to install a set of P7s 165 70 15.

Thoughts and advice would be appreciated.

Please note that we will share the entire build once complete, thanks again for all the help!
JRust
Go wider! At least 195/60/15's. 205's should fit as well but 195's will fit for sure no problem.
johannes
I like the 185/65. Very large choice in this size
Cal
Those wheels turned out very nice indeed.....now you just have to add the fox manufacture decal/print to the back side smile.gif



Dave_Darling
What are you going to use the car for?

If concours, get 165/80-15 tires. Vredestein makes ones with a vintage-looking tread pattern, and Coker I think re-pops Michelen XWXes.

If racing/track days/autoX, go with the largest tires allowed by the rules and/or the fenders. Usually 205/50-15.

For just cruising around, find a tire you like the looks of and go with it.

--DD
rhodyguy
195 55 or 60. with fresh paint why gamble on a rub issue? beautiful wheels.
Tom_T
Al's shop does such great work! drooley.gif

Jett - what type of a resto are you doing? .... what is your goal?
.... Concours or Driver? .... Originality? .... Resto Mod?

Those 165/70R15 will give you a pretty big odometer error of 16% IIRC, so you'll add up "shadow" or "ghost mileage" post resto pretty quickly, & pay the ultimate value penalty for it later on down the road, as did other members on here. So you'll want to use one of the tire error calculators online to compare with the stock 165/80R15 size for error, to try to minimize it.

For example, Todd914 on here did a pristine CW refurb of a nice low mile original survivor red/black 73 2L & put the factory recco'd substitue 195/65R15s on with half your Pirelli's error at about 8%, & paid the penalty of a couple of $10Ks when he sold it after a short hold

Your wheels look to be dead on original correct - down to anodizing them & with the dulled down background.

So if you're looking for period correct - the 73-76 2.0's came with H speed rated tires in 165HR15 (i.e.: 165/80HR15 in today's /80 profile size), & you should stick with the 165HR15 (or at least a 165SR15 or TR, which weren't around back then) size tires.

Check at Lucas Tires in Long Beach CA & their UK counterpart Longstone Tyres for what they have (US can get anything on the UK site as well). You'll find that their tire prices are better than Coker in most cases, & Al could've had theirs mounted on his wheels for you, had you made the choice before he shipped them (for futre ref & for others reading here).

http://www.lucasclassictires.com

http://www.longstonetyres.co.uk

There are also Universal & Coker to price check as well -

https://www.universaltire.com

https://www.cokertire.com

Some of the question is also what you want to drop $$s for a set of 5 tires, cuz they range from $70-100 each for basic B-brand 165/80SR15s, up to $400-500 for 185 XWX Michelins. Also, a member here has 2 unused/never mounted XWXs in the Parts FS classifieds for a reasonable price (for those), to get part way there.

Vredestein has a decent HR one at the lower end, & sometimes Bridgestone will have an SR or TR or HR rated 165/80R15, & there are some off-brand or B-brand 165/80R15's out there too, but I wouldn't recco any of them.

FYI - T speed rating is adequate for our 2Ls /4s but wasn't out back then, & HR was overkill beyond the rated 119 mph spec top speed of a 73-74 2L (I've had my stock 73 2L up to 126 though), so the HR goes with more cushion, whereas the SR is too low for a 2L, but was spec'd for the 1.7L & 1.8L with lower top speeds - but are usable in real world sub-100 mph use..

The next step up would be the period correct mfgrs. & both Pirelli Cinturato & Michelin have 165/80R15 in S, H, & V speed ratings: Michiliin in XZX SR, XAS HR (the XAS needs tubes), as well as the period option XWX 185/70VR15 (nominal <0.1% error IIRC).

Another option there is on a tire very much like the OE "Dog-bone tread" Dunlop SP57 165HR15's which were most often spec'd on our 2Ls, 194-6's & 911s of that day (the 185 XWX above being the optional upgrade), is the modern retro tire by Blockley here:

http://www.lucasclassictires.com/165VR15-B...Radial-504p.htm

While those choices above will look most original & period correct on your resto, you won't be dinged at any of the local Region nor Zone PCA Concours for having non-original size &/or make tires (originality isn't judged here in our Zone 8, & AFAIK not in your Zone either), & may only run into it at a non-PCA Concours where they'd look for old school Michi or Pirelli etc., & maybe at the national PCA Parade Concours. that's my truth in advertizing bit on tires, but I do like the old school size & make look on a well restored or perserved survivor 914.

If you're looking for a driving tire & don't care about odometer error, then others on here are probably up to date on the current choices, but I would still suggest using the tire calculator to get the least speedo/odo error tires with the performance specs/profile for which you're looking.

Also beware that some of the wider tires will give you rub marks on the inner front wheelwells, &/or at the outer F &/or R fender lips, which would cause damage to your frest paint - so choose wisely & test them out on the lift with full lock turns L & R, & at the R fenders.

There is a Tires & Wheels nailed topic at the O&H Forum with a lot of info on tires too FYI.

Good Luck! beerchug.gif
Tom
///////

Larmo63
I'd go 205/60 15.

This size looks perfect on the car, unless you are going for factory originality.
Jett
Thanks Everyone for the insight.

To retain originality and reduce the speedometer error, we decided to go with the stock "upgrade" Michelin XWX 185/70VR15 from Coker (free shipping).

Cheers

PS Thanks Tom for the data. IIRC the original unused Michelin spare was an odd size... 165/78/15? I'll have to find the old thing smile.gif
Tom_T
QUOTE(Jett @ Aug 28 2016, 09:45 AM) *

Thanks Everyone for the insight.

To retain originality and reduce the speedometer error, we decided to go with the stock "upgrade" Michelin XWX 185/70VR15 from Coker (free shipping).

Cheers

PS Thanks Tom for the data. IIRC the original unused Michelin spare was an odd size... 165/78/15? I'll have to find the old thing smile.gif


No Jett, it would've been all 5 - including the spare - of the same original 165HR15 (165/80HR15 or 165/80R15 H in today's coding) - & what came from the factory would've only had 165HR15 on the sidewall for your 2L (or all 5 185 XWXs if that option box ticked off).

If your current spare is a /78, then it was a replacement tire since new, cuz they didn't list the section profile size number then, but it was "assumed" to be 80-82%, & some followed on with /78 IIRC I think Michi came out with those in the early 80's, but were not an HR IIRC, cuz the 165HR15s all went away then, & my last road set were Kleber 165SR15 which still were around in 1980).

Look up tire size info. at the Tire Rack info section to see what they all were & how the /80 "estimate" came about, as well as current speed, load, wear, etc. ratings - which the new repros also need to have now too AFAIK.

PS - FYI - Coker is not making their own XWX repop, but buying them from the same Michelin Classic plant making them & the XZX & XAS for the other sellers. I don't know if they're claiming that, but I think the truth is that they may have requested Michi to keep making them in return for a certain order number .... then they can try to say "we did it" - but in fact there are many classic tire outlets in the USA & Europe/UK & worldwide who are buying the production runs.

So you can either add a 5th 185 XWX to your order (call them 1st thing Monday) since all 5 including spare would've matched, since you're essentially trying to recreate the factory XWX option.

Or you could just pick one of the other 165/80R15 in S or H speed rating as a spare - as if the OO had upgraded to the 185 XWX option on 4 wheels from a car originally equipped with the 165s (back then you could do an in-dealership option or upgrade/change, similar to today, & was perhaps more common then - such as all those M471 914-6GT kits sold byy Porche+Audi dealers back then).

Either way, it's probably best to add it to your Coker order for free shipping on all 5 tires as a group, even if a mixed-set (4+1).

IIRC the PCA Parade is up your way next year! first.gif

Cheers! beerchug.gif
Tom
///////
Larmo63
thisthreadisworthlesswithoutpics.gif

We want to see the car with the new tires!!!!!!!!
Jett
Thanks Tom, we bought 5 of the XWX tires...

Added a shot of the car...with the shop tires on it smile.gif
napasteve
Wow, your car looks great Jett.
rhodyguy
Very...those wheels will fetch some dough if you decide to let them go.
JRust
QUOTE(rhodyguy @ Aug 29 2016, 08:46 AM) *

Very...those wheels will fetch some dough if you decide to let them go.

The VW offset american wheels? Don't know why those would pull money. I've tossed them on more than one occasion.
siverson
I know I'm in the minority, but I really like 165 tires on stock -4 cars. 100# springs and a front sway bar (stock or bigger) and they still handle *REALLY* well. And I like the skinny tire look for stock cars.

-Steve
rhodyguy
Not everyone drives a 914 Jamie. I didn't mean to imply they're worth a fortune, but given the $ invested in the new wheels and tires, every bit will help.
pete000
QUOTE(johannes @ Aug 27 2016, 10:22 AM) *

I like the 185/65. Very large choice in this size



Al Does great work, they look perfect !

I run 185/60's

Tom_T
QUOTE(siverson @ Aug 29 2016, 09:35 AM) *

I know I'm in the minority, but I really like 165 tires on stock -4 cars. 100# springs and a front sway bar (stock or bigger) and they still handle *REALLY* well. And I like the skinny tire look for stock cars.

-Steve


agree.gif Steve,

My 73 2L always handled very well fully stock for springs/torsion bars, Boge shocks, 165 tires, stock rubber bushings, & stock F & R anti-sway bars - & even better when I upgraded to the Koni Red shocks & struts in its 80-83 rolling resto (after the OE Boges wore out). Porsche did a great job of balancing great handling on the 2L, with not killing your kidneys DDing on rough roads with too stiff of a suspension IMHO, as well as giving 30-35+ mph Hwy on the 165s. driving.gif

PS - that was with 165HR15 (/80) Semperit M401 & M501 dogbone treads like the OE Dunlop SP57s, & they performed 99% as well as the SP57s but would last 40k miles vs. 10-15k on the Dunlops according to the MT & R&T period Tire Tests. They were excellent handling tires, without breaking the bank on a DD with new tires every 9-18 months! smilie_pokal.gif

Unfortunately by 1980 they weren't making or importing them here, so I had to go with Kleber 165SR15s (another French Tire Co. & only made SR), in that 80-83 resto/refurb - so I gained suspension capability with the Konis, but lost some handling with the Kelbers. dry.gif

beerchug.gif
Tom
///////
Tom_T
QUOTE(JRust @ Aug 29 2016, 09:30 AM) *

QUOTE(rhodyguy @ Aug 29 2016, 08:46 AM) *

Very...those wheels will fetch some dough if you decide to let them go.

The VW offset american wheels? Don't know why those would pull money. I've tossed them on more than one occasion.


They actually may be the 914 ET40 offset flavor too Jaimie, since VTO did make the 40 offset back in the day IIRC.

And if cleaned up for sale, just about any period wheel will pull $50-100 per with the 914 & VW folks out there who like a particular wheel. TheSamba.com & here & CL, evil-bay etc. are the best places to list them FS.

That style wheel was never one that flaoted my boat, but there are folks out there who like them.

Frankly, I wasn't a big fan of the Fuchs 2L wheels back when I got my 73 2L in 1975, so I wasn't disappointed that it had the 5 spoke original Rivieras on it, but am going back to the Fuchs 2L with a set of 5 done by Al Reed for SoCalAndy's former 72 2056 build, but I'll have them anodized back to stock look (Andy liked them polished).

beerchug.gif
Tom
///////
Cal
QUOTE(Tom_T @ Aug 27 2016, 05:00 PM) *

Al's shop does such great work! drooley.gif

Jett - what type of a resto are you doing? .... what is your goal?
.... Concours or Driver? .... Originality? .... Resto Mod?

Those 165/70R15 will give you a pretty big odometer error of 16% IIRC, so you'll add up "shadow" or "ghost mileage" post resto pretty quickly, & pay the ultimate value penalty for it later on down the road, as did other members on here. So you'll want to use one of the tire error calculators online to compare with the stock 165/80R15 size for error, to try to minimize it.

For example, Todd914 on here did a pristine CW refurb of a nice low mile original survivor red/black 73 2L & put the factory recco'd substitue 195/65R15s on with half your Pirelli's error at about 8%, & paid the penalty of a couple of $10Ks when he sold it after a short hold

Your wheels look to be dead on original correct - down to anodizing them & with the dulled down background.

So if you're looking for period correct - the 73-76 2.0's came with H speed rated tires in 165HR15 (i.e.: 165/80HR15 in today's /80 profile size), & you should stick with the 165HR15 (or at least a 165SR15 or TR, which weren't around back then) size tires.

Check at Lucas Tires in Long Beach CA & their UK counterpart Longstone Tyres for what they have (US can get anything on the UK site as well). You'll find that their tire prices are better than Coker in most cases, & Al could've had theirs mounted on his wheels for you, had you made the choice before he shipped them (for futre ref & for others reading here).

http://www.lucasclassictires.com

http://www.longstonetyres.co.uk

There are also Universal & Coker to price check as well -

https://www.universaltire.com

https://www.cokertire.com

Some of the question is also what you want to drop $$s for a set of 5 tires, cuz they range from $70-100 each for basic B-brand 165/80SR15s, up to $400-500 for 185 XWX Michelins. Also, a member here has 2 unused/never mounted XWXs in the Parts FS classifieds for a reasonable price (for those), to get part way there.

Vredestein has a decent HR one at the lower end, & sometimes Bridgestone will have an SR or TR or HR rated 165/80R15, & there are some off-brand or B-brand 165/80R15's out there too, but I wouldn't recco any of them.

FYI - T speed rating is adequate for our 2Ls /4s but wasn't out back then, & HR was overkill beyond the rated 119 mph spec top speed of a 73-74 2L (I've had my stock 73 2L up to 126 though), so the HR goes with more cushion, whereas the SR is too low for a 2L, but was spec'd for the 1.7L & 1.8L with lower top speeds - but are usable in real world sub-100 mph use..

The next step up would be the period correct mfgrs. & both Pirelli Cinturato & Michelin have 165/80R15 in S, H, & V speed ratings: Michiliin in XZX SR, XAS HR (the XAS needs tubes), as well as the period option XWX 185/70VR15 (nominal <0.1% error IIRC).

Another option there is on a tire very much like the OE "Dog-bone tread" Dunlop SP57 165HR15's which were most often spec'd on our 2Ls, 194-6's & 911s of that day (the 185 XWX above being the optional upgrade), is the modern retro tire by Blockley here:

http://www.lucasclassictires.com/165VR15-B...Radial-504p.htm

While those choices above will look most original & period correct on your resto, you won't be dinged at any of the local Region nor Zone PCA Concours for having non-original size &/or make tires (originality isn't judged here in our Zone 8, & AFAIK not in your Zone either), & may only run into it at a non-PCA Concours where they'd look for old school Michi or Pirelli etc., & maybe at the national PCA Parade Concours. that's my truth in advertizing bit on tires, but I do like the old school size & make look on a well restored or perserved survivor 914.

If you're looking for a driving tire & don't care about odometer error, then others on here are probably up to date on the current choices, but I would still suggest using the tire calculator to get the least speedo/odo error tires with the performance specs/profile for which you're looking.

Also beware that some of the wider tires will give you rub marks on the inner front wheelwells, &/or at the outer F &/or R fender lips, which would cause damage to your frest paint - so choose wisely & test them out on the lift with full lock turns L & R, & at the R fenders.

There is a Tires & Wheels nailed topic at the O&H Forum with a lot of info on tires too FYI.

Good Luck! beerchug.gif
Tom
///////


Tom, were the Michelin 185 XWX tires originally offered as a factory option back in the day for a 914/4?
Tom_T
QUOTE(Cal @ Aug 29 2016, 02:48 PM) *

Tom, were the Michelin 185 XWX tires originally offered as a factory option back in the day for a 914/4?


Yes Cal, see the 1st of the 2 listed M471 options at Jeff Bowlsby's site at the link below:

http://bowlsby.net/914/Classic/OpEq.htm

I don't know offhand if nor what the specific factory option code was to order the XWX 185/75VR15 Michelins on the 15x5.5J 914/4 Alloy wheels (Fuchs 2L, Pedrini & Mahle 4-lug "Baby Gasburner" wheels), but I knew a couple of guys who got them ordered on their new 914s back in the day (a 73 2L & 74 2L on Fuchs 2L wheels).

I knew one other guy who had the dealer upgrade to them at $0 cost on a 76 2L, after I decided not to get that particular detuned GC powered 914 2L, since when I referred him, I said the dealer was desperate to move it & he got a good bargain price + XWXs & radio (DM inflation was killing all Porsche sales back then in late 73 to 76 & beyond, so they threw in stuff).

The 185/75VR15's XWX itres with dog-bone tread (& 14" counterparts for -6s with 14" Fuchs) perform very well & was THE choice of all the 914/4 & many -6 "Racer Boyz/Galz" back then, but dropped maybe 20-25% off the mpgs for street/hwy/DD use.

The Dunlop SP57 & Semperit M401/M501 165HR15 tires were like "Baby XWXs" & so performed well too, but with better DD mpg. The Blockley is a modern reproduction of those dogbone tread tires, since Dunlop & Semperit do not do theirs in repops, as you can see from the pix below.

XWX 185/70VR15 (/75 is NLA) -
Click to view attachment

Blockley 165/80HR15 (similar to Dunlop SP57/Semperit M401/M501) -
Click to view attachment

This is a Dunlop SP57 165HR15 (/80) -
Click to view attachment

This is my spare tire - the last of the Semperit M401 165HR15 (/80) -
Click to view attachment

Although each is slightly different treads, they do have a consistent tread design approach.

beerchug.gif
Tom
///////


JamesM
QUOTE(johannes @ Aug 27 2016, 09:22 AM) *

I like the 185/65. Very large choice in this size


agree.gif

I have had everything from 165s to 205s on fuchs and i wouldn't go wider than a 185 again, with the 185/65 being the most available (and cheap) without going to short. If you want to spend the money the 165/80 vintage tires would be a good way to go.

Im not exactly sure what advantage people think they are getting by stuffing the largest possible tire on a 5.5" wide rim??? In my experience best performance comes from optimizing tread width to rim width, but that may all depend on your definition of "performance".

155/165a are as close to optimized as you can get but 185s are better from an availability/selection standpoint.

If you want to run a wider tire get a wider rim, 205s should be run on a 7" wide rim, running them on a 5.5" rim gives inferior handling characteristics.
Jett
Please note that the wheels used in the shop are not mine smile.gif

Regarding the suspension. We went with NOS period front Billstiens that were "freshened" by Elephant, and the entire rear setup was built by Elephant... Trying to keep the look stock but with modern performance. The car also retains its front and rear stock sway bars.
Jett

QUOTE(napasteve @ Aug 29 2016, 08:42 AM) *

Wow, your car looks great Jett.


Thanks!

The folks helping restore her are all passionate car enthusiasts, which always results in a quality product smile.gif

Cheers
sixnotfour
why would they put a v rated tire on a factory 914-4,,,H&S yes..
xwxs where on Ferraris from the factory back then..
But yes was a popular tire upgrade..back in the day
Tom_T
QUOTE(sixnotfour @ Aug 30 2016, 02:07 AM) *

why would they put a v rated tire on a factory 914-4,,,H&S yes..
xwxs where on Ferraris from the factory back then..
But yes was a popular tire upgrade..back in the day
Tom how is your 914 coming along ??


I don't think they made the XWX in less than V rating, so folks who wanted them to race or do spirited street driving got them & overpaid IMHO to get them on /4s, since the Dunlop SP57s & Semperits were almost as good & plenty enough for a /4 IMHO.

My resto is coming along sloooooow - other than sourcing needed parts here & there. Just too much else going on now with my biz, house refurb/resto, family illnesses/deaths, other car stuff + hunting for a Cayenne S, etc., etc. sad.gif

beerchug.gif
Tom
///////
Jett
Mounted the new tires smile.gif
Tom_T
QUOTE(Jett @ Sep 6 2016, 06:50 PM) *

Mounted the new tires smile.gif

Nice! smilie_pokal.gif
beerchug.gif
Tom
///////
sixnotfour
agree.gif

I do know that, Jett's wheels came off of a one handed(birth defect) black mans 914 ..
Bob C. Is his name he passed away, they had been in his basement a long time..he bought his 914 new and was quite a presence back in the day PCA track and autcross PNWR..

the rest of the story
raynekat
Those look perfect.
Great size on a great looking wheel.
You'll enjoy those I'm sure.....
Jett
I still have those (4) rims but not yet restored smile.gif. The (5) rims in the picture came with the car.

Cheers

QUOTE(sixnotfour @ Sep 6 2016, 07:51 PM) *

agree.gif

I do know that, Jett's wheels came off of a one handed(birth defect) black mans 914 ..
Bob C. Is his name he passed away, they had been in his basement a long time..he bought his 914 new and was quite a presence back in the day PCA track and autcross PNWR..

the rest of the story

sixnotfour
..now you know the story on those at least.. beerchug.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.