Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Sound deadening/ride quality
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
jmargush
I built my car as an autoxer years ago and never installed carpet or sound deadener after the restoration.

Now as I age and have an opportunity to take a longer trip in the car I am looking for a little more "comfort" in the car.

Question is how much will carpet and/or sound deadening improve the road noise?

The back pad has been removed and there is sound deadener and felt covering the firewall currently.

Curious as to what you all might have experienced or recommend.


I am also thinking about dialing back the suspension setup for the long trip.
Cairo94507
I believe the sound deadener makes a dramatic difference in our cars. My floor, firewall and doors are all done. Anything you can do to keep heat and sound out is a good thing. beerchug.gif
Superhawk996
Duplicate
Superhawk996
I have been involved in data analysis and modeling to correlate ride quality with 3rd party quality metrics like Consumer Reports, JD Power, OEM customer satisfaction surveys.

Sound is a highly correlated variable even though it has no direct effect on ride quality. That is to say that most people if they perceive that bumps are “loud” they are also perceive the bump to be more severe than it really is as measured by seat track accelerometers.

So - a quieter car is perceived to ride better than an equivalent car that is noisy.

Addition of constrained layer damping like Dynamat will get you a huge improvement over what you have (nothing). This treatment will reduce the structurally transmitted noise low frequency noise <100 Hz.

Addition of carpet and a back pad over Dynamat will reduce the higher frequency airborne noise above 100 Hz.

You really want both types of noise reduction treatments since they each affect different noise frequency ranges.

Don’t forget the felt liner on the targa top - that big fiberglass panel is a noise reflector.

Dialing back your suspension from an AX setup would also be a significant improvement for long trips.
mlindner
jmargush, I did the same thing last year, interior tar mat, then 1/2 foam and then thin layer of perlon carpet. I do not have anything on the engine compartment wall. It nocked noise down by more then half. I do have Ben's sport muffler so that end is pretty loud. MarkClick to view attachment
emerygt350
What do you suggest for the roof? Mine has nothing at the moment, didn't really consider the added sound deadening it would provide. Mine is pretty quiet but I could always use more..
Superhawk996
QUOTE(emerygt350 @ Sep 26 2022, 10:43 AM) *

What do you suggest for the roof? Mine has nothing at the moment, didn't really consider the added sound deadening it would provide. Mine is pretty quiet but I could always use more..

Something like this. I don’t recall my OE headliner having edge binding but this should be close. On my 2nd car it is missing and yet to be replaced but I’ll use this or just cut some Perlon.

https://www.pelicanparts.com/More_Info/APBZ...eBoCu4MQAvD_BwE
jmargush
Thanks guys great info!
Retroracer
QUOTE(emerygt350 @ Sep 26 2022, 07:43 AM) *

What do you suggest for the roof? Mine has nothing at the moment, didn't really consider the added sound deadening it would provide. Mine is pretty quiet but I could always use more..

My car (faux GT) has almost zero sound insulation, but I did rework my roof panel a while back to try and reduce heat transfer inside. I used a product called Dynaliner:

https://www.dynamat.com/products/dynaliner/

on the bare fiberglass, then purchased a precut headliner piece from 914Rubber:

https://914rubber.com/oem914563321113-1-700-charcoal-1-2975

to finish it out. Can't really comment on whether the heat insulation reduced the sound as the rest of the car is so loud at speed anyway; but the thermal reduction worked a treat ;-)

- Tony
jmargush
Another question is there an opinion on whether loop carpet is more effective than perlon at reducing sound?
mlindner
Loop all the way. Perlon is very thin and light.
emerygt350
Any opinion on just applying a sound deadening mat to the targa without carpet? Was thinking maybe a sheet of this stuff and calling it a day.

https://www.amazon.com/Siless-Sound-Deadeni.../dp/B07CG2YPRJ/

but that price I could just get carpet (if it were in stock).
Superhawk996
@emerygt350

I’d avoid that product. It is just butyl as a mass damper. A constrained layer product like Dynamat is going to be more effective than just butyl.

I guess I’m wrong - looked again and it says it does have the aluminum constraint layer like Dynamat.
bbrock
I'd do a search on other recent threads on sound deadening. As @Superhawk996 said earlier, different materials reduce different frequencies of sound. The firewall also has the engine noise to contend with which is why sound deadening in that area was designed as a sandwich of different materials to reduce sound levels.
rfinegan
Coming back from Octeeener fest, MY 75 914 did not have the fire wall blanket, on on return I purchased and installed a Synthetic blanket from Rix914 at the show..EZ install and made a noticeable difference in the reduction of engine noise in the cabin. Wish I had done this upgrade earlier . Rick is a great guy to work with too
jim_hoyland
QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 27 2022, 08:41 AM) *

Coming back from Octeeener fest, MY 75 914 did not have the fire wall blanket, on on return I purchased and installed a Synthetic blanket from Rix914 at the show..EZ install and made a noticeable difference in the reduction of engine noise in the cabin. Wish I had done this upgrade earlier . Rick is a great guy to work with too

Does that mount inside the cabin ? Are they available on-line ?
@rfinegan
bbrock
QUOTE(jim_hoyland @ Sep 28 2022, 07:10 AM) *

QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 27 2022, 08:41 AM) *

Coming back from Octeeener fest, MY 75 914 did not have the fire wall blanket, on on return I purchased and installed a Synthetic blanket from Rix914 at the show..EZ install and made a noticeable difference in the reduction of engine noise in the cabin. Wish I had done this upgrade earlier . Rick is a great guy to work with too

Does that mount inside the cabin ? Are they available on-line ?
@rfinegan


It replaces the heavy tar/fiber mat inside the engine bay and is available online.

It's the same mat I went with and I really like it. I measured 1 dB sound reduction inside the cab compared with a less expensive sound/heat reduction mat. Unfortunately, I got too excited about installing the new mat and forgot to measure sound with no mat at all. It is significant though.
rfinegan
https://www.rix914parts.com/store/p29/914_F...uction_Mat.html

attaches with factor metal tabs and 3/ 4 push in fasteners from the engine compartment
FL000
Food for thought but don’t forget to focus on any window gaps as they contribute significantly to road noise and overall comfort.

Case in point I spent some time recently readjusting my door windows and seals. Couldn’t believe how much more relaxed I was driving the 1500 odd miles to Utah and back. My car is loud as hell so not implying it is quiet by todays standards, but my wife and I were never so relaxed after 5 hours in the car.

Van914
Years ago Stoodards used padding on the top above the roll bar to reduce sound.
rfinegan
It was ez to install. I did mine right cat the car show. 10-15 mins. May be faster to remove the engine grill/lid but either way it is not difficult to install with the engine in and all accessories place. Its a little snug by the ECU mount on my 75, but slides right in place none the less.
930cabman
Road noise, how do tires factor into the mix?
rjames
QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 28 2022, 01:00 PM) *

https://www.rix914parts.com/store/p29/914_F...uction_Mat.html

attaches with factor metal tabs and 3/ 4 push in fasteners from the engine compartment


Are those push fasteners available for purchase anywhere? Can't seen to find them.
rfinegan
QUOTE(rjames @ Sep 29 2022, 10:30 AM) *

QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 28 2022, 01:00 PM) *

https://www.rix914parts.com/store/p29/914_F...uction_Mat.html

attaches with factor metal tabs and 3/ 4 push in fasteners from the engine compartment


Are those push fasteners available for purchase anywhere? Can't seen to find them.


included with purchase from Rix914

rjames
QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 29 2022, 08:15 AM) *

QUOTE(rjames @ Sep 29 2022, 10:30 AM) *

QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 28 2022, 01:00 PM) *

https://www.rix914parts.com/store/p29/914_F...uction_Mat.html

attaches with factor metal tabs and 3/ 4 push in fasteners from the engine compartment


Are those push fasteners available for purchase anywhere? Can't seen to find them.


included with purchase from Rix914


Have the pad, just need the plugs. @Mikey914 Do you make these?
bbrock
QUOTE(rjames @ Sep 29 2022, 11:11 AM) *

QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 29 2022, 08:15 AM) *

QUOTE(rjames @ Sep 29 2022, 10:30 AM) *

QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 28 2022, 01:00 PM) *

https://www.rix914parts.com/store/p29/914_F...uction_Mat.html

attaches with factor metal tabs and 3/ 4 push in fasteners from the engine compartment


Are those push fasteners available for purchase anywhere? Can't seen to find them.


included with purchase from Rix914


Have the pad, just need the plugs. @Mikey914 Do you make these?


You can pick them up at your local NAPA. Can't remember the part number, but they are easy to find.
Mikey914
Pretty sure I have them, I'll check and let you know tomorrow.
Mark
FlacaProductions
https://914rubber.com/plastic-engine-paddin...astener-for-914
ITEM # 914-559-377-10
Plastic Engine Padding Fastener for 914
bbrock
Found the NAPA part too: https://www.napaonline.com/en/p/BK_6653116?impressionRank=1
Literati914
Neither of my '72 cars have holding tabs or any holes for the plastic clips.. is that correct and what's the solution - I was thinking rare earth magnets, but... confused24.gif


.
Root_Werks
QUOTE(rfinegan @ Sep 28 2022, 01:00 PM) *

https://www.rix914parts.com/store/p29/914_F...uction_Mat.html

attaches with factor metal tabs and 3/ 4 push in fasteners from the engine compartment



Just ordered this for my 914-6 conversion. I like how light it is, hopefully it helps to cut down on the noise.
tpines
QUOTE(mlindner @ Sep 26 2022, 06:29 AM) *

jmargush, I did the same thing last year, interior tar mat, then 1/2 foam and then thin layer of perlon carpet. I do not have anything on the engine compartment wall. It nocked noise down by more then half. I do have Ben's sport muffler so that end is pretty loud. MarkClick to view attachment

Hi Mark,
Love your interior! Looks awesome. Just a little concerned not having head rests for safety. Take care!

Clark
Cairo94507
@Root_Werks I would love to hear your opinion after the install. Pics of the install would be nice too. beerchug.gif
Root_Werks
QUOTE(Cairo94507 @ Oct 20 2022, 06:39 AM) *

@Root_Werks I would love to hear your opinion after the install. Pics of the install would be nice too. beerchug.gif


@Cairo94507

Will do. I've only had one 914-6 with the engine bay pad installed. It's a tight fit around the edges of the fan. Very curious how this will fit and stay in place.
Cairo94507
Terrific- fingers crossed it all goes to plan. beerchug.gif
Root_Werks
Arrived today, very nice quality. Came with 3 push pins.
Root_Werks
Installation was easy, holes all in the correct spot. Hopefully drive tomorrow and listen for reduced noise.

Cairo94507
Looks clean. beerchug.gif
Root_Werks
Drove today, it certainly makes a difference and worth the money. I wish I had a before/after DB meter reading for folks. My ear says the cabin is quieter.
Cairo94507
Something else to think about. The problem is 6's never came with the sound deadening pad on the engine side of the firewall and they look so nice without it. I am going to have my back-pad off soon to replace the rear glass, I will look and see if anything more can be done on the interior side to provide a bit more sound deadening.
beerchug.gif
Root_Werks
QUOTE(Cairo94507 @ Oct 25 2022, 03:35 PM) *

Something else to think about. The problem is 6's never came with the sound deadening pad on the engine side of the firewall and they look so nice without it. I am going to have my backed off soon to replace the rear glass, I will look and see if anything more can be done on the interior side to provide a bit more sound deadening.
beerchug.gif


My 914-6 started as a 914-4 so the inner pad was still there.

Some place here I read real 914-6's had the longs covered in similar/same tar as floor boards? I could see that, there is a bit of noise transferred through those.

My 914-6 is a driver, everything is hooked up and works like heat, fresh air etc. Wager I'm getting noise through the heater tubes.

Either way, that engine bay pad helped! beerchug.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.