Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Comression ratio advice
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
team914
Hi,
I am planning to build a 6 cylinder street motor for my 914/6 factory replica. My original 84mm barrels were worn, so I elected to machine the barrels to 84.5mm and have bought a set of 84.5mm Wossner pistons. With a 70.4mm crank, the compression ratio is stated at 10.11:1 with the pistons out of the box. I intend on using Weber carbs, E cams and an E distributor/123 Distributor. My machine shop engineer has recommended reducing the compression ratio from the 10.11:1 to a more suitable figure. The petrol quality in Ireland is poor, typically 95 octane, and we now have a compulsory addition of 10% Ethanol added (E10)!
Any advice greatly appreciated
mepstein
You want to measure the actual compression ratio and not just count on what’s stated in the tech sheet. Especially if you are making changers, you want a known baseline, not just theoretical.


welcome.png
gereed75
The general wisdom says 9.5:1 is the max you can do on pump gas with a single plug.

Not familiar with the Wosners but it is fairly easy to remove material from the top of the pistons to adjust compression. Measure the volumes, do the calculations and then adjust.
Retroracer
Sounds like a nice build! I'm +1 on the "conventional wisdom" of <10:1 on single plug/high street petrol - the Dempsey book suggests as much - but I've never tried to build & run a high compression -6 motor daily, so what do I know?

HOWEVER: there are a few Porsche specialists on your time zone which might be worth a phone call for recommendations / guidance: Design 911 in Essex, and Tuthill Porsche in Oxfordshire.

Both have run older 911s in competition/ historic rallies all over the UK, so can't hurt to ask.

- Tony

PS. post pics of the build pls? smile.gif
nditiz1
QUOTE(mepstein @ Apr 22 2023, 03:15 PM) *

You want to measure the actual compression ratio and not just count on what’s stated in the tech sheet. Especially if you are making changers, you want a known baseline, not just theoretical.


welcome.png


Agree with this. With my 3.2, you would think 9.5:1 with JE pistons being 9.5:1 ,but when measured CR is actually 9.4:1.
rgalla9146
Summit racing has an easy to use compression ratio formula on their site.
You'll have to measure deck height and provide other info that is probably
included with your pistons.
Wossner is a high quality brand. Good choice.
9.5 is a reasonable target. You'll have to use the best pump gas available
CR can be adjusted incrementally by raising the barrels with thicker than stock base
gaskets. This method is also reversable.
You've got a beautiful plan.
Good luck
Rory clover.gif
Krieger
You do need to cc your heads.
rgalla9146
QUOTE(Krieger @ Apr 23 2023, 10:57 AM) *

You do need to cc your heads.


OOPS. Yes, that too
ogdougy
I would also add that some piston manufactures will provide on their website or, if you ask, what values they use to calculate their advertised compression ratio.

It helps give a rough idea with minimal work. For example, I ordered a set of pistons from Arias for my 4age. Advertised with 12:1 comp ratio. But their calculations used a combustion chamber size larger than any 4age head had. So i knew i was getting more compression than advertised which is what i wanted.
Krieger
QUOTE(ogdougy @ Apr 23 2023, 09:49 AM) *

I would also add that some piston manufactures will provide on their website or, if you ask, what values they use to calculate their advertised compression ratio.

It helps give a rough idea with minimal work. For example, I ordered a set of pistons from Arias for my 4age. Advertised with 12:1 comp ratio. But their calculations used a combustion chamber size larger than any 4age head had. So i knew i was getting more compression than advertised which is what i wanted.


It's called a spec sheet. I would expect Wossner to supply one with your pistons. Dome volume is one of the specs you need. This is a complex engine to build correctly.
r_towle
For a Daily Driver, I would suggest 9.5:1 to ensure cooler running on worse fuel.
We don’t drive them daily
We don’t race the (really)

So build it to last do 15 years from now it still runs great.
I have 240k on my 84 3.2 powered 911. Easy to run

I am building a 3.2 to similar specs because 200 hp in a 914 is more than I need.
targa72e
As others have said you need to CC the heads, figure out deck height and cc piston dome volume. Once you know all these you can calculate actual compression ratio. Since you are changing pistons and can specify more valve clearance I would look at more modern cam shaft design like Mod Solex or Mod S.

john
gereed75
The "9.5 compression" JE's i got were more like 11 after I measured and calculated it all out. I suspect that my combustion chambers were significantly smaller than JE figured

Using the density of the piston alloy I calculated how much weight had to come off the domes to get the correct volume reduction. All six came out perfectly the same height to within a few thousandths thus the same volume.

Worked pretty slick. I would also recommend the mod solex grind - sacrifice basically no bottom end and get about the same top end punch as an S but at a 500 lower RPM
porschetub
QUOTE(gereed75 @ Apr 23 2023, 11:44 AM) *

The general wisdom says 9.5:1 is the max you can do on pump gas with a single plug.

Not familiar with the Wosners but it is fairly easy to remove material from the top of the pistons to adjust compression. Measure the volumes, do the calculations and then adjust.

agree.gif considering the fuel he is running this has to be taken into account,his motor will still be fairly mild so no point in introducing more heat into an iron bore engine ,these motors are known to be rather under stressed and last well so no point in risking that for a few horsepower.
The cams will make the best single increase, and even better with an upgrade to better flowing 2.2 heads as Mr Dempsey suggests will be a good move,the larger valve sizes will benefit the better than stock cams which were very tame stock.
Cam choice will be important ,appears to be the Solex cams or 'E" cams but don't know so hopefully someone will chime in here.
End of the day this will be a rather strong short stroke and should make good power with well matched combo.
Cheers.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.