QUOTE
I didn't contact Jake Raby, because he only supplied them through his web site.
Mr. Bliznik,
Why were these issues not formally brought to my attention? Part of being a good customer means communication with the Vendor should any issues need to be taken care of and as a Vendor I expect this to be done prior to any postings being made. Nothing infuriates me more than people who "have an issue" with a component, but do not feel that issue is worth any communication with the Vendor, but they'll have no problem posting it to the world, often times in a manner that isn't exactly 100% accurate.
QUOTE
I am happy with everything Jake furnished.
No, you aren't.
Anytime any of our parts go to another builder they are scrutenized and the same when those builders have their components get into our hands, which is true with your builders work as well as we have experienced and repaired it in the past. I found gripes with it as well, but my customer didn't make it a point to post to the world.
QUOTE
Maybe Jake needs to get after Len about his quality since it came through Jakes business.
Jake would, if he heard ANY complaints! Len Hoffman has been creating all my cylinder heads for years and until this post was stunbled upon I had never received a complaint about his work, and thats not an exaggeration. IF I had not have found this in my cruising of the forums I STILL WOULD NOT HAVE KNOWN ABOUT THE ISSUES BECAUSE YOU DIDN"T BRING THEM TO MY ATTENTION!!!!!
QUOTE
I am sure I'll hear about it.
Yep, because it must be addressed. The only way around a problem is straight throught he damn middle.
I would have thought that you have known me and my stand on topics like this long enough to know how much this post would infuriate me. I would also have expected more from you, like a phone call or an email addressing the gripes so I could take care of them. More than likely I would have goten the heads back from you, made any changes necessary, with no questions asked and it would have been a done deal. Instead you had to shoot yourself in the foot with this post. Not smart.
At any rate, the heads you purchased do exact the 2.0/914 head in the chamber and port areas.
I'll now address your issues individually.
QUOTE
** Missing vent holes in each head for hooking up the emissions to my stock D-Jet (see Photo)
Only the early 2.0/914 heads had vents drilled into them and we would have addressed those and added them at no charge if you would have requested them. I would have also done this if you would have tactfully asked me to do so after you received the heads, and it would have been done at no extra charge..
QUOTE
** The Cyl head temp sensor is in the wrong place. It's near the cold intake area & should be where Porsche put it near the exhaust hot area (per 2.0 Liter Type-IV location). Porsche put it where it should be because this is the high heat area that effects the signals to the D-Jet MPS & etc. This incorrect location is also a problem matching up the engine tin hole. (see photo).
This sensor location has proven for us to be more effective as it keeps the engine on cold start for a few more seconds as it takes a bit longer to heat soak the sensor. It also tends to take longer to cool off, since it is not in the fin area and that means in your climate the engine would be more forgiving for short runs in colder weather since it would nopt go on cold start as early.
I consider this an upgrade, but we could have tapped either hole for you, or even both and I would have done so if you would have contacted me. Not everything Porsche did was the best, we have learnned that.
QUOTE
** Seating of valves could have been better. At the 45 degree angle of the valve seating it's below center & should be seated at the outer diameter. OK, but not what I feel you get for the money spent.
That was done purposely, and I am not willing to divulge why. In 100,000 miles you would be Thanking us for that procedure.
QUOTE
** Valve springs are not 2.0 liter springs, but type-I The type-1 springs fit very tight over the I.D. boss and chaff on the inside spring. If left like this you will notice silver metal fillings when you change oil. The springs will rub & wear down with this tight clearance over time. The machining was done for 2.0 liter springs & clearances. Ok, to use Type-1 springs, but with a proper fit.
Once again, done on purpose. We NEVER use stock valve springs! The material you speak of was purposely left in place to reduce the weakness of the valve guide boss. Some people remove too much material from this area resulting in springs that walk and wear into the heads and on top of that they also tend to weaken the guide boss.
QUOTE
** The heads are bus heads that anyone can purchase from a Spain foundry that makes lots of VW & Misc repo heads. I understand a lot of welding and CNC machining is done to bring up to 2.0 Liter standards, but with the missing holes, etc mentioned above they are not a true replica.
It is evident that your idea of a "True Replica" is different than ours. My primary concern was to provide a component that would bolt on to equal the performance of the stock 2.0 heads that have not ever been available. If you wanted a couple of things drilled and tapped we would have paid the shipping and done that without any questions being asked.
QUOTE
The question did I get what I ordered?? Answer: Yes, but for the money I paid they should be perfect.
And everyone's opinion of whats "perfect" varys. If your gripes were about port imbalances, chamber volume imbalances and other critical aspects I would be much more concerned about the critique of these parts.
That said, send me the heads that Mr. Petrucci is creating for you and I'll send back a critique of those as well. There is no book to follow to do this work and there are no rules. When a component is top dollar and held in high ragard people TRY to find issues with it that don't "Satisfy" them.
QUOTE
This criticism is not about Jake. It's for Len to review his 2.0 Type-1V replica heads he sells through Jake
But it involves me and the business I have busted my ass to build on quality components. Contact me offline- it's your obligation. **I** take responsibility for EVERYTHING that occurs here, good or bad, no matter if an Employee or a sub-contractor made the mistake. I don't believe in passing the buck to other people because I sign the checks and put MY name on what leaves these doors.
So basically you took our components to another builder and YOU were satisfied.. That is until this other person who just so happens to be in the same business critiqued them and found some "issues"...
You then didn't find these issues worthy of any communication with ME, but you did find it worthy of a post here. Tell me whats fair about that????
I'll bet you 20 bucks that Mr. Petrucci learned more from looking at those heads than he told you about and I'd say those things will show up in the heads he prooduces in the future.. Thats the way the ball bounces in this world and everyone is ALWAYS trying to take the big guy down...
Now, lets deal with this the way it should have been from the beginning and I'll try to pull the knife from between my shoulder blades and deal with you.
And, an apology would be really nice.