Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Crazy idea for the Type IV engine shroud...
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
horizontally-opposed
So I've seen a lot of people do interesting things with the stock Type IV shroud to make it look more interesting. Body color, silver, red, orange, you name it. But none of these has really appealed to me. I've thought about ideas like CF (too modern for the car for my tastes) and wrinkle black (the way I would probably go). But then I saw the shroud in this thread:

http://www.914world.com/bbs2/index.php?showtopic=81971

I like this color, as it reminds me of the old Bosch distributor caps. But then THAT got me to thinking about another material I associate with this color, and that's the ultra-trick and way cool naked fiberglass Porsche used to use on 906/911R motors as well as throughout the 908s and 917s. Morspeed has duplicated it, albeit at far higher levels of quality and MUCH higher gloss, for its restorations.

Question is, could it be done for reasonable money? Could the stock shroud be used to make a mold? I frankly can't think of a cooler looking, period-correct hotrod 914-4 engine bay than this setup with a pair of carbs so long as the finish can be nailed. I think I'd like it even better than the Fat Perf. setup and the DTM, though I know it wouldn't outperform the latter.

pete
McMark
I think it's a great idea Pete. Got any good pictures of 'naked' fiberglass for members who aren't familiar?
McMark
This look, right?
pin31
Carbon Fiber would look cool.....
horizontally-opposed
QUOTE(McMark @ Mar 18 2008, 04:52 PM) *

This look, right?



THAT'S the look...

I think the key would be getting the over-the-top obvious weave and high gloss that Morspeed favors. Or not? Wonder if someone could photoshop a couple of 914-4 engine bay shots to give us a rough idea of what this might look like.

pete
Jake Raby
It's simple...
We can easily do this by just using a clear gelcoat rather than a colored gelcoat. I have made DTMs like this for demonstration purposes and it does look very cool.

I have a mold for 2.0 cylinder tins and could pretty easily finish our blower housing molds for the hybrid vanagon/914 shroud kit if I knew people would buy them.(superior cooling air discharge volume and pressure compared to stock)

Its just a matter of volume, there are many things we could offer but the market just won't support it. These things are very cool, but it takes a certain breed of enthusiast to appreciate them- others just think its ugly.
1970 Neun vierzehn
QUOTE(horizontally-opposed @ Mar 18 2008, 03:35 PM) *

So I've seen a lot of people do interesting things with the stock Type IV shroud to make it look more interesting. But then THAT got me to thinking about another material I associate with this color, and that's the ultra-trick and way cool naked fiberglass Porsche used to use on 906/911R motors as well as throughout the 908s and 917s.

.................... Fat Perf. setup ........

pete


This cooling fan set-up with the "natural" F/G look.....
Dave_Darling
"Natural"? Since when is red gel-coat "natural"?

Sure, it matches the car, that's cool. But Pete is talking about the translucent yellowish un-painted fiberglass, like in the picture of the 914-6 engine tin that McMark posted.

And after seeing the cover of Pano (sorry, Pete) a couple of months ago, with the sixteen-cylinder 917 engine, I won't disagree that it would be a really cool thing!!

--DD
1970 Neun vierzehn
Noooooooo,
It didn't come out right, I meant that the red fan shroud should be natural f/g. blush.gif
749142
ever thought about chrome?
my father had a 72, he chromed the engine tin and that was bitchin.
PeeGreen 914
Hey Mark... can I have that fiberglass 6 engine shrouding? biggrin.gif
Jake Raby
QUOTE(1970 Neun vierzehn @ Mar 18 2008, 08:48 PM) *

Noooooooo,
It didn't come out right, I meant that the red fan shroud should be natural f/g. blush.gif


And it should also have internal diverters to direct the air where it needs to be so there isn't a 150F temperature differential across the 4 cylinders, but it doesn't.
rick 918-S
QUOTE(McMark @ Mar 18 2008, 03:52 PM) *

This look, right?


drooley.gif That peaks the needle on the cool meter! agree.gif
horizontally-opposed
QUOTE(Jake Raby @ Mar 18 2008, 06:41 PM) *

It's simple...
We can easily do this by just using a clear gelcoat rather than a colored gelcoat. I have made DTMs like this for demonstration purposes and it does look very cool.

I have a mold for 2.0 cylinder tins and could pretty easily finish our blower housing molds for the hybrid vanagon/914 shroud kit if I knew people would buy them.(superior cooling air discharge volume and pressure compared to stock)

Its just a matter of volume, there are many things we could offer but the market just won't support it. These things are very cool, but it takes a certain breed of enthusiast to appreciate them- others just think its ugly.



I don't think the numbers would be there over time to keep this available, but then maybe I am wrong. That said, the more things you can do to make expensive Type IVs attractive to those with the funds, the better. I think it's pretty clear you've done enough to make the motors VERY attractive on the subjects that count (uh, let me see here: power, torque, efficiency...) but no one minds a good-looking engine bay.

So what kind of numbers and at what price would you need to make a small-ish run of them worth your while? I'm thinking group buy. Questions are:

-Should all the pieces be done or just the on-engine shroud?

-Does your hybrid Vanagon setup keep the cool ridges etc. of the stock tins? Not sure this matters...

pete
Jake Raby
Some of the ridges are there, but a few have to be removed to make the units from glass inside molds.

The only killer is the "llok" can't be achieved with components that need to be super strong as the glass gets too thick to allow the transparency. Thats what would make the blower housing difficult to make because it has to accomodate an alternator bracket and needs rigidity.

The cylinder tins would be fairly easy to do since they need little strength or rigidity.

My X4CS DTM Carrera cooling system should do enough in the looks department to take things to the next level and its being made for effectiveness more than a "look" as I have little to no desire to make blingy items that don't increase the longevity/reliability/efficiency or power of an engine while looking good.
Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
I don't think we'll have any "attractiveness" issues after I reveal this baby in mid 2009

I don't
horizontally-opposed
QUOTE(Jake Raby @ Mar 19 2008, 09:56 AM) *

Some of the ridges are there, but a few have to be removed to make the units from glass inside molds.

The only killer is the "llok" can't be achieved with components that need to be super strong as the glass gets too thick to allow the transparency. Thats what would make the blower housing difficult to make because it has to accomodate an alternator bracket and needs rigidity.



I think the only way this idea makes sense is for those who don't need/don't want/can't afford the DTM setup.

So, as a replacement for the stock tin on the engine (which many building your motors retain) could it be done? I get the sense you mean the structural issues are only issues with your upgraded cooling systems. And the setup you hint at here, as well as the Fat IV setup (too bad it seems to need an internal redesign), don't need any aesthetic help. Just some gloss black paint, or whatever color people want.

I am also not interested in items that look blingy, either. Period. But, as someone wise once said, once the man is made, clothing greatly improves his appearance. The 914's Type IV has never been, uh, particularly nice looking, even with carbs. Just trying to think of ways to address that... I also like the idea of the appearance of the engine bay reflecting the idea that 100-150 pounds have been saved over installing a 911 engine... and nothing says "lightweight" like 911R cues.

The opposite of bling, in my book.

Looking at that four-cam motor prompted me to wonder if you of all people have played around with twin-plugging the Type IV. I remember an article way back when about RPM in Florida doing it, and that the writer said the "smoothness" of the twin-plug Type IV was very noticeable. Given that you're doing your own heads, and the availability of V8 distributors out there (as opposed to the no easy/cheap way to fire a twin-plug flat 6). Or have you arrived at the conclusion that it's not necessary?

pete
jd74914
That 4-cam has very interesting throttle linkage. I have never seen any linkage with a bent leg like that.
Jake Raby
Pete, twin plugging is standard on all my engines larger than 102mm bore size and has been for a couple of years.

This is my Wife's recently completed German Look 79 Vert. It sports a 2.8L twin plug TIV and is pictured here two weekends ago laying down 195 RWHP and 206 lb/ft of torque with max HP@ 5,400 RPM and max torque at 3,500 at the Southeast Dyno Day
IPB Image

IPB Image


here is the IDA Weber equipped twin plug beast. It idles at 800 RPM smooth as silk and has the throttle response of a crotch rocket. It runs 10.5:1 CR on 89 octane pump gas and this weekend it got 33.3 MPG on it's first long distance cruise.
IPB Image

here is the youtube video of the dyno pull.. At the end you'll hear someone say "no way, that has to be a mistake".. The engine sounds so stock no one would ever believe it makes 250 FWHP.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPJI6nhwy10

Here is the dyno graph from my dyno that was done prior to the event, the difference was the muffler that we had to run for dyno day pulled 20 HP from the engine, but Chris and I are working on the redesign now. Lok at the power and look at the revs, thats the amazing part. What N/A 911 engine can do that!!
Click to view attachment

We can do twin plugs with carbs and this modified Nissan dizzy, or with EFI and twin plug direct ignition.

This is one of the things I wanted to talk to you about!

purple
uh, Jake,

Can I put A DTM setup on my crappy hydro-cam engine please?

KTHXBAI
Jake Raby
yeah, but do you really need it?
purple
QUOTE(Jake Raby @ Mar 19 2008, 02:11 PM) *

yeah, but do you really need it?


Funny you should ask....Now that I've followed your advice, bought tons of parts from your store, and had lots of patience and perserverance...no.

The engine's temp tops out at 350 when I'm pushing it hard (CHT at the spark plug) I was the guy with a weber progressive, hydro bus engine, dual motorcycle exhaust and 009 distributor with only 1 piece of lower engine tin installed from the p.o. remember me?

I've gotten from your store:
Mallory unilite(friggen amazing)
mallory promaster ecoil & ballast resistor(friggen amazing)
weber 40IDF's (friggen amazing AND perfectly jetted)
other stuff:
eurorace header.

That engine runs friggen excellent now! what makes the biggest difference? Valve adjustment. un-real how much better it runs now. the p.o. had loose rockers all over that car, my poor baby.

Thanks for your help jake, i just wanted some more friggen awesome parts from you because it would make my engine more...friggen awesome..er
Jake Raby
Nope, you don't need a DTM...

Glad our things are working for you, effectiveness is what we shoot for!
r_towle
QUOTE(Jake Raby @ Mar 19 2008, 01:52 PM) *

Pete, twin plugging is standard on all my engines larger than 102mm bore size and has been for a couple of years.

This is my Wife's recently completed German Look 79 Vert. It sports a 2.8L twin plug TIV and is pictured here two weekends ago laying down 195 RWHP and 206 lb/ft of torque with max HP@ 5,400 RPM and max torque at 3,500 at the Southeast Dyno Day
IPB Image

IPB Image


here is the IDA Weber equipped twin plug beast. It idles at 800 RPM smooth as silk and has the throttle response of a crotch rocket. It runs 10.5:1 CR on 89 octane pump gas and this weekend it got 33.3 MPG on it's first long distance cruise.
IPB Image

here is the youtube video of the dyno pull.. At the end you'll hear someone say "no way, that has to be a mistake".. The engine sounds so stock no one would ever believe it makes 250 FWHP.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPJI6nhwy10

Here is the dyno graph from my dyno that was done prior to the event, the difference was the muffler that we had to run for dyno day pulled 20 HP from the engine, but Chris and I are working on the redesign now. Lok at the power and look at the revs, thats the amazing part. What N/A 911 engine can do that!!
Click to view attachment

We can do twin plugs with carbs and this modified Nissan dizzy, or with EFI and twin plug direct ignition.

This is one of the things I wanted to talk to you about!


I thought you hated IDA carbs.....
What have you modified???

Rich
ericread
QUOTE(Jake Raby @ Mar 19 2008, 06:27 AM) *

QUOTE(1970 Neun vierzehn @ Mar 18 2008, 08:48 PM) *

Noooooooo,
It didn't come out right, I meant that the red fan shroud should be natural f/g. blush.gif


And it should also have internal diverters to direct the air where it needs to be so there isn't a 150F temperature differential across the 4 cylinders, but it doesn't.


What most people don't understand is that air flow is stupid. If you aim an airflow at a wall, you won't get a nice smooth airflow around the wall, you will get a high pressure point at the wall with a falloff of airflow on the fringes. These internal diverters are absolutely necessary to "shape" the airflow and direct it to where you want it to flow.
So.Cal.914
QUOTE(purple @ Mar 19 2008, 12:29 PM) *


The engine's temp tops out at 350 when I'm pushing it hard (CHT at the spark plug) I was the guy with a weber progressive, hydro bus engine, dual motorcycle exhaust and 009 distributor with only 1 piece of lower engine tin installed from the p.o. remember me?

I've gotten from your store:
Mallory unilite(friggen amazing)
mallory promaster ecoil & ballast resistor(friggen amazing)
weber 40IDF's (friggen amazing AND perfectly jetted)
other stuff:
eurorace header.



I remember you, glad to see all is coming together. Sorry about making fun of

your exhaust, but damn. biggrin.gif

Whats next for your car?
Jake Raby
This engine has intake ports that flow 225 CFM, these are the only port that has outflowed the capability of a Weber IDF to date, hence the use of an IDA.These ports have the volume to overcome the characteristics that make an IDA equipped TIV hard to tune.

This car was built (including the engine) in 3 weeks time by Blake and myself for a single day of competition at the SE Dyno Day. Due to that we did not have time to install and tune the EFI system that would generally be used with this arrangement.

IDAs in 95% of instances do not work well with the characteristics of the TIV heads, this is the odd 5% situation where they do work very effectively.

That said IDAs were my last and only resort to beat the Cali guys given the time I had to get the job done.

Click to view attachment

r_towle
IDA's are the best thing for a hard dyno pull, there is not transition circuit to worry about, just WOT that the IDA loves.....

So, are you telling us that your wifes motor gets awesome MPG also????
Cause if you can put numbers like that down, and get good MPG...now you are talking....
Rich
Jake Raby
Yes. The engine hardly has to work and the high CR is made totally safe with the twin plugs. CR= efficiency when met with an optimum cam and head arrangement.

This is a daily driveable engine and even with the IDAs it has great manners. With FI it would drive like a stock V8.

Over the weekend I got 33.3 MPG from the engine in the Bug. of course it is near impossible to drive the car hard without ending up in Jail, or blowing the tranny to bits. with the IDAs and their transition coupled to the gearing I was unable to run less than 75 MPH and most of the time I had to run just over 80 for the carbs to be happy..

With development i am sure this super efficient combo could easily attain 40 MPG and make even more power, because the engine doesn't even realize it is pushing the car.
Rav914
Well this topic got waaaay off target....

How about it. How does the DIY make his own amber-colored fan shroud pieces for the 914? Would I need to make a mold, or could I use the should as the mold? How do I get the amber color?

I've done some glass work but only on top of wood and clear was the desired result.

For reference:

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.