Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Black Friday/close out muffler sale
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
Pages: 1, 2, 3
mb911
QUOTE(Amphicar770 @ Dec 29 2020, 09:24 PM) *

QUOTE(PanelBilly @ Dec 12 2020, 10:15 PM) *


Sounds great. Mine should arrive soon.

From a loudness perspective, how would you compare it to your original muffler? Louder, quieter, about the same?


Quieter then the video posted
Amphicar770
For those who installed on their 2.0. Did you use / purchase the GT bracket?

I guess I did not read closely enough. When I placed my order I did not realize the bracket was an additional purchase. Just checking how others installed.

Thx

mepstein
QUOTE(Amphicar770 @ Jan 4 2021, 12:51 PM) *

For those who installed on their 2.0. Did you use / purchase the GT bracket?

I guess I did not read closely enough. When I placed my order I did not realize the bracket was an additional purchase. Just checking how others installed.

Thx


I would use the bracket. Ben sells them at or below cost and they support the muffler properly, just like a 911 muffler is mounted.
DucRS
QUOTE(Amphicar770 @ Jan 4 2021, 12:51 PM) *

For those who installed on their 2.0. Did you use / purchase the GT bracket?

I guess I did not read closely enough. When I placed my order I did not realize the bracket was an additional purchase. Just checking how others installed.

Thx


Yes, it’s a must have. Ben’s bracket was a perfect fit. It comes painted/powdercoated ready for install.
mb911
Yeah sorry if it was confusing to anyone.. these mufflers with hardware and gt style bracket are almost a wash for me.. it just helped get inventory off the books.. it also bombarded me with orders and has helped me to streamline things moving forward.. I have found some cheaper prices on hardware and gaskets that helps me keep doing this but I am not making gt3 money not even 914 money biggrin.gif
mepstein
QUOTE(mb911 @ Jan 4 2021, 02:12 PM) *

Yeah sorry if it was confusing to anyone.. these mufflers with hardware and gt style bracket are almost a wash for me.. it just helped get inventory off the books.. it also bombarded me with orders and has helped me to streamline things moving forward.. I have found some cheaper prices on hardware and gaskets that helps me keep doing this but I am not making gt3 money not even 914 money biggrin.gif

Not ready to start buying 962’s yet?
mb911
QUOTE(mepstein @ Jan 4 2021, 11:14 AM) *

QUOTE(mb911 @ Jan 4 2021, 02:12 PM) *

Yeah sorry if it was confusing to anyone.. these mufflers with hardware and gt style bracket are almost a wash for me.. it just helped get inventory off the books.. it also bombarded me with orders and has helped me to streamline things moving forward.. I have found some cheaper prices on hardware and gaskets that helps me keep doing this but I am not making gt3 money not even 914 money biggrin.gif

Not ready to start buying 962’s yet?



Nope.. kids are each driving 3k beaters and my new boat to me was a 1999 this summer..
anderssj
Mine arrived about two hours ago. Ben, REALLY nice work! Will probably polish it before I install it just because it deserves the extra attention.

Speaking of installing, does anyone have a picture of the GT mount on the transmission? I know I'll probably figure it out, but I can't wait to get to it.

mepstein
Once you remove the stock muffler hanger, put the gt hanger on the two trans studs. It really only fits one way. Then bolt the muffler to the heat exchangers and strap the muffler to the gt hanger.
VaccaRabite
QUOTE(anderssj @ Jan 4 2021, 07:33 PM) *

Mine arrived about two hours ago. Ben, REALLY nice work! Will probably polish it before I install it just because it deserves the extra attention.

Speaking of installing, does anyone have a picture of the GT mount on the transmission? I know I'll probably figure it out, but I can't wait to get to it.

Once you start the install its fairly obvious on how it has to go.
I'll take a picture of mine when I'm out of scouts tonight.

Zach
anderssj
Thanks, I appreciate it! pray.gif
VaccaRabite
Click to view attachment
Here you go.

Zach
TX914
Received my Quiet Muffler from @mb911 . Looks great! Looking forward to install. Thanks Ben! Click to view attachment
PanelBilly
Mine's due to arrive today too. I’m planning on making a video of the old and new muffler for comparison so others can hear the difference.
bbrock
QUOTE(PanelBilly @ Jan 5 2021, 12:26 PM) *

Mine's due to arrive today too. I’m planning on making a video of the old and new muffler for comparison so others can hear the difference.


I received mine yesterday also and spent a good twenty minutes scrutinizing the perfection of every weld. I really can't recall buying anything welded to this standard. Truly amazing. It will be some time before I get to hear mine so look forward to your vids.

BTW, I did just a little digging and found there are cell phone apps to measure sound decibels that are surprisingly accurate. As I've muffler shopped, I've longed for a database of measured sound levels using standardized measuring procedures. Might be something the community could do with our phones? confused24.gif
PanelBilly
I have one called db meter pro that works well. I’ll use it when I make the video
TX914
QUOTE(mepstein @ Jan 4 2021, 06:50 PM) *

Once you remove the stock muffler hanger, put the gt hanger on the two trans studs. It really only fits one way. Then bolt the muffler to the heat exchangers and strap the muffler to the gt hanger.

Oh so you don’t use the stock hangar any more... guess I assumed the GT bracket would be in addition to. I suppose then one should support the heat exchangers until bolted to the muffler...
mepstein
No stock hanger.
I’m not the final answer on this but I don’t think there’s any harm in letting the he’s hang as long as you don’t lean in them. If they have all four nuts tightened down, they are pretty secure.

mepstein
QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 02:37 PM) *

QUOTE(PanelBilly @ Jan 5 2021, 12:26 PM) *

Mine's due to arrive today too. I’m planning on making a video of the old and new muffler for comparison so others can hear the difference.


I received mine yesterday also and spent a good twenty minutes scrutinizing the perfection of every weld. I really can't recall buying anything welded to this standard. Truly amazing. It will be some time before I get to hear mine so look forward to your vids.

BTW, I did just a little digging and found there are cell phone apps to measure sound decibels that are surprisingly accurate. As I've muffler shopped, I've longed for a database of measured sound levels using standardized measuring procedures. Might be something the community could do with our phones? confused24.gif

Ben has very high standards for welding.
My dad knows nothing about welding but loves great craftsmanship. He said it was beautiful.
bbrock
QUOTE(TX914 @ Jan 5 2021, 01:26 PM) *

QUOTE(mepstein @ Jan 4 2021, 06:50 PM) *

Once you remove the stock muffler hanger, put the gt hanger on the two trans studs. It really only fits one way. Then bolt the muffler to the heat exchangers and strap the muffler to the gt hanger.

Oh so you don’t use the stock hangar any more... guess I assumed the GT bracket would be in addition to. I suppose then one should support the heat exchangers until bolted to the muffler...


I'm planning to use the stock hanger. There's no reason it won't work. The HEs are still going to be in the same place they've always been and the muffler has to bolt to them.
Just to clarify, I"m using the stock hanger INSTEAD of the GT hanger.
mepstein
QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 05:57 PM) *

QUOTE(TX914 @ Jan 5 2021, 01:26 PM) *

QUOTE(mepstein @ Jan 4 2021, 06:50 PM) *

Once you remove the stock muffler hanger, put the gt hanger on the two trans studs. It really only fits one way. Then bolt the muffler to the heat exchangers and strap the muffler to the gt hanger.

Oh so you don’t use the stock hangar any more... guess I assumed the GT bracket would be in addition to. I suppose then one should support the heat exchangers until bolted to the muffler...


I'm planning to use the stock hanger. There's no reason it won't work. The HEs are still going to be in the same place they've always been and the muffler has to bolt to them.
Just to clarify, I"m using the stock hanger INSTEAD of the GT hanger.


I wouldn't but it's Ben's design so he knows more than me. @MB911
mb911
QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 02:57 PM) *

QUOTE(TX914 @ Jan 5 2021, 01:26 PM) *

QUOTE(mepstein @ Jan 4 2021, 06:50 PM) *

Once you remove the stock muffler hanger, put the gt hanger on the two trans studs. It really only fits one way. Then bolt the muffler to the heat exchangers and strap the muffler to the gt hanger.

Oh so you don’t use the stock hangar any more... guess I assumed the GT bracket would be in addition to. I suppose then one should support the heat exchangers until bolted to the muffler...


I'm planning to use the stock hanger. There's no reason it won't work. The HEs are still going to be in the same place they've always been and the muffler has to bolt to them.
Just to clarify, I"m using the stock hanger INSTEAD of the GT hanger.



The reason I suggest against that is because the muffler body is not supported in anyway and thus making it a lever and with the body of the muffler only .040 thick will likely work harden the welds and Crack at some point. I completely disagree with the engineering decision porsche made with stock system. The 911 setup is so much better.
bbrock
QUOTE(mepstein @ Jan 5 2021, 04:04 PM) *

QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 05:57 PM) *

QUOTE(TX914 @ Jan 5 2021, 01:26 PM) *

QUOTE(mepstein @ Jan 4 2021, 06:50 PM) *

Once you remove the stock muffler hanger, put the gt hanger on the two trans studs. It really only fits one way. Then bolt the muffler to the heat exchangers and strap the muffler to the gt hanger.

Oh so you don’t use the stock hangar any more... guess I assumed the GT bracket would be in addition to. I suppose then one should support the heat exchangers until bolted to the muffler...


I'm planning to use the stock hanger. There's no reason it won't work. The HEs are still going to be in the same place they've always been and the muffler has to bolt to them.
Just to clarify, I"m using the stock hanger INSTEAD of the GT hanger.


I wouldn't but it's Ben's design so he knows more than me. @MB911


I look forward to his reply but I can't imagine what harm it would do. It's lighter than the stock muffler, right? confused24.gif
mb911
A quick story as to how I got in this business. Rewind 20 years I was building a 914-6 conversion. I had a stock muffler that appeared in good shape. I took the car out for its first drive and within the 1st 15 minutes the muffler was draging behind the car.. I then built a stainless muffler (the very 1st m&k exhaust) it worked well and was much lighter but after a few years it had started to work harden. Eventually I made something similar to what you see..

I do think most will never have an issue. Its just a case and point
bbrock
Thanks Ben. Is there any reason to think your mufflers are more susceptible to work hardening than say, a stock muffler?
mb911
QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 04:12 PM) *

Thanks Ben. Is there any reason to think your mufflers are more susceptible to work hardening than say, a stock muffler?



Only because it's stainless and then remember its thinner then a stock muffler. I have not seen any failures but don't want to either.

Moving forward the bracket will just be part of the muffler kit as a whole and not an option.
bbrock
QUOTE(mb911 @ Jan 5 2021, 05:21 PM) *

QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 04:12 PM) *

Thanks Ben. Is there any reason to think your mufflers are more susceptible to work hardening than say, a stock muffler?



Only because it's stainless and then remember its thinner then a stock muffler. I have not seen any failures but don't want to either.

Moving forward the bracket will just be part of the muffler kit as a whole and not an option.


Gotcha. No question your hangers are a better design but I do have that originality disease. As you know, choosing a muffler was a tough decision for me, and it is a testament to the quality of yours that I was swayed from going original. beerchug.gif
mb911
QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 04:26 PM) *

QUOTE(mb911 @ Jan 5 2021, 05:21 PM) *

QUOTE(bbrock @ Jan 5 2021, 04:12 PM) *

Thanks Ben. Is there any reason to think your mufflers are more susceptible to work hardening than say, a stock muffler?



Only because it's stainless and then remember its thinner then a stock muffler. I have not seen any failures but don't want to either.

Moving forward the bracket will just be part of the muffler kit as a whole and not an option.


Gotcha. No question your hangers are a better design but I do have that originality disease. As you know, choosing a muffler was a tough decision for me, and it is a testament to the quality of yours that I was swayed from going original. beerchug.gif


Oh I know exactly what your saying.. I knew that was going to be a difficult decision for you. Likely never an issue but I am to careful I guess. My dads disease of being a safety inspector on every aspect of life was passed down to me. biggrin.gif
narino
Is it still possible to buy in?
mb911
QUOTE(narino @ Jan 6 2021, 08:32 AM) *

Is it still possible to buy in?



I still have a few left.. I am actually thinking of tooling up to do a run of these.. I am going to adjust retail on these and continue to sell at a huge value.

@narino pm me
bahnzai
Maybe over kill, but I used both the standard hanger and Ben’s GT bracket.
I figured the standard bracket supports the headers/heat exchangers, and the GT bracket supports the muffler...
BillJ
that's really not a bad idea - best of both worlds i guess.
TX914
QUOTE(bahnzai @ Jan 6 2021, 11:05 AM) *

Maybe over kill, but I used both the standard hanger and Ben’s GT bracket.
I figured the standard bracket supports the headers/heat exchangers, and the GT bracket supports the muffler...

I want to use the stock hangar in conjunction with the GT bracket as well for extra support. Do the flanges line up okay with the stock hangar still on? Going without the stock hangar feels like not wearing a seatbelt. shades.gif lol-2.gif
mepstein
QUOTE(TX914 @ Jan 6 2021, 12:18 PM) *

QUOTE(bahnzai @ Jan 6 2021, 11:05 AM) *

Maybe over kill, but I used both the standard hanger and Ben’s GT bracket.
I figured the standard bracket supports the headers/heat exchangers, and the GT bracket supports the muffler...

I want to use the stock hangar in conjunction with the GT bracket as well for extra support. Do the flanges line up okay with the stock hangar still on? Going without the stock hangar feels like not wearing a seatbelt. shades.gif lol-2.gif

The flanges should line up fine since Ben's muffler uses a stock size flange. You might have to put longer studs into the trans mount.
BeatNavy
I hate the stock bracket and can't wait to ditch mine once I get Ben's muffler. The stock bracket, or at least mine that may be tweaked, always seems to make hooking up the HE's to the head properly that much more difficult.
bbrock
Well I feel like a dumbass. I was cleaning up packing material and empty boxes in the shop tonight and kicked a box that was unopened. Opened it up to find a shiny GT muffler hanger, gaskets, and hardware inside. I got so excited about the muffler that I overlooked the other little box. screwy.gif I guess I'll do the double hanger thing too.
VaccaRabite
I don't understand the push to do a double bracket. It is not at all necessary, and the stock bracket is a PITA anyway.

Zach
Cairo94507
I agree. I dumped the stock bracket on my Six and went with the GT bracket and it works perfectly. confused24.gif beerchug.gif
bbrock
You guys just don't understand how F'd up my brain is w00t1.gif
BillJ
we are getting there....
TX914
For myself, I initially thought that the longer exchangers (compared to 911) combined with the rotational force of the engine might be hard on the exchangers and muffler welds w/o the added stability of the original hangar. But I suppose the whole mass (engine/trans/exchangers/muffler) rotate the same amount on acceleration/decel. If the muffler is mounted with only a GT style bracket on the GT and rally cars it must not be a concern.
bbrock
QUOTE(TX914 @ Jan 7 2021, 03:39 PM) *

For myself, I initially thought that the longer exchangers (compared to 911) combined with the rotational force of the engine might be hard on the exchangers and muffler welds w/o the added stability of the original hangar. But I suppose the whole mass (engine/trans/exchangers/muffler) rotate the same amount on acceleration/decel. If the muffler is mounted with only a GT style bracket on the GT and rally cars it must not be a concern.


In reality, I think the exchangers are really supported by the muffler even with the original hanger. The muffler and HEs are bolted together as a solid unit so I don't think which hanger you use changes the forces on the HEs much. Like Ben said, with the original hanger, the weight of the muffler is cantilevered behind the hanger support point which will put strain on the inlets.
Amphicar770
Hi All,

Received my muffler. As other reported, it is a work of art.

Unfortunately, mine was manhandled by the gorillas at UPS. There is a 2.5 inch dent in upper left, near the weld line.

Ben has offered to let me return it as well as some suggestions to remove the dent. On the one hand I know I am being a bit obsessive as it *probably* will not effect sound or performance and may not even be visible once on the car. Anyway, wondering what others think in terms of repair options, returning, living with it whatever.

Ben suggested blocking the inlets and forcing done compressed air via the tailpipe. I did try this to no avail. Have not come up with a great way to seal / fill the tailpipe so not sure if the actual psi. 2.5 us not a standard plumbing size. Given gauge if metal, not sure if air without heat is enough to pop it.

Ben also offered to send me a paintless dent repair kit he has. Again, not sure if that will work as they are generally made for thinner gauge body panels and / or the hot glue might not stic to the stainless. I did try with just a heated glue stick but it popped right off.

Another option could be to use electric stud welder to tack a stud and pull the dent. However, do not want to turn one problem into a bigger problem.

Yes, we could do a UPS claim but, from my experience, UPS always blames the packaging. There was no visible damage to box. Likely it was dropped in an edge like lip of truck.

As noted, I could just live with it. Open to other ideas.

Thanks.

Mike









Click to view attachment

mepstein
I would file a claim
mb911
The can is. 040 so I think PDR would work
Cairo94507
@Amphicar770 - I have received 2 of Ben's mufflers - they were packed as if they were going to circumnavigate the globe. Sorry your muffler got treated roughly somewhere during the shipping/delivery trip.

I would file a claim with UPS. Sadly some of the handlers and delivery personnel are not as careful as they should be. If it were me, I would want no dent- the muffler is a piece of art.

What would it cost to ship it back to Ben and let him straighten that out? Of course that would be after the UPS does whatever they are going do. Or you could ship it and have Ben repair it then file the claim with pictures to show the box and the damage and claim for the shipping and whatever Ben would charge to fix the muffler and return it.

Sucks that it came dented like that. We have all received parts at some point that were damaged in shipping and it is frustrating-especially when it cost so much to ship nowadays.
Amphicar770
Yes, although I mentioned it earlier, Ben has been accomodating in trying to resolve so kudos to him. Obviously, easiest thing for both of us would be to pop it out if possible so we are looking at that first. But yes, may wind up having to file claim with UPS if all else fails. Unfortunately, the standard response from UPS is generally to blame damage on packaging.

Fortunately, teener pretty much remains in garage until spring so hopefully can resolve. Trying to think of better way to add air pressure at tailpipe..
BillC
QUOTE(Amphicar770 @ Jan 17 2021, 05:24 PM) *

Yes, although I mentioned it earlier, Ben has been accomodating in trying to resolve so kudos to him. Obviously, easiest thing for both of us would be to pop it out if possible so we are looking at that first. But yes, may wind up having to file claim with UPS if all else fails. Unfortunately, the standard response from UPS is generally to blame damage on packaging.

Fortunately, teener pretty much remains in garage until spring so hopefully can resolve. Trying to think of better way to add air pressure at tailpipe..

Given the thickness of the sheet metal in the muffler, air pressure alone won't work. You'll need to pressurize the muffler and then heat the crease with a torch. Shouldn't require so much heat that you weaken the metal, but it will be discolored. Maybe you can polish it afterward.
Amphicar770
QUOTE(BillC @ Jan 17 2021, 06:47 PM) *

QUOTE(Amphicar770 @ Jan 17 2021, 05:24 PM) *

Yes, although I mentioned it earlier, Ben has been accomodating in trying to resolve so kudos to him. Obviously, easiest thing for both of us would be to pop it out if possible so we are looking at that first. But yes, may wind up having to file claim with UPS if all else fails. Unfortunately, the standard response from UPS is generally to blame damage on packaging.

Fortunately, teener pretty much remains in garage until spring so hopefully can resolve. Trying to think of better way to add air pressure at tailpipe..

Given the thickness of the sheet metal in the muffler, air pressure alone won't work. You'll need to pressurize the muffler and then heat the crease with a torch. Shouldn't require so much heat that you weaken the metal, but it will be discolored. Maybe you can polish it afterward.


Thanks. Yes, mist of the videos I have seen use air plus heat. In this case, I do not want to try anything without Ben's guidance or approval lest I make it worse and then it becomes a situation of, "well I would have taken it back before you did whatever to it".


mb911
So we have so many things going on here.. 1st all these mufflers were sold at cost. It sucks when this happens because there is no way to make it work for everyone. UPS will likely require Mike give all the packing, the muffler and the box to them. Then it will take weeks for answer. They are 50/50 on what the outcome will be. Meanwhile I am sold out on the quiet mufflers and not sure when I could make more so if this were to get returned there wouldn't be a replacement available for a while.

This dent in no way effects the performance of the muffler but it sucks for the buyer as they expect the muffler as advertised and as the seller I want to provide the best experience as possible.. it's basically a terrible spot to be in..

The best way would to have Mike pop that out without any of the other alternatives..I would think the PDR kit would do it and if that won't bring it back enough then air pressure and heat..
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.