QUOTE(zoomCat @ Jan 29 2023, 02:40 PM)
Stoddard is selling Porsche branded windscreens, with a modern brand. I’m restoring a six, but I’m not sure if it’s really much of an improvement over the XYG aftermarket that’s a third the price.
Intersting find!!!
The Pilkington glass is made in St Helens, England, XYG is made in Hong Kong, China.
That would explain the price difference. Quality - well that would require direct comparisons.
What I do find interesting is the Porsche branding. From what
@wonkipop said, it only appears on Porsche certified parts. I don't think you can put that on without their blessing. To get approval for use of that mark, I would think that Porsche certified the glass to meet specifications for bend, form and size. I am certain Porsche still has the blueprints on file for that part. If Pilkington just cloned that mark not knowing what it was, well, thats a different story.
I think I mentioned earlier in the thread how companies make replacement glass that they were never OEM tooled for.
They go out and buy a piece of glass from someone. Ideally it is made by the OEM, but that is not always the case. From that piece of glass they make a mold to represent the shape and size and build the tooling from that. If that sample glass is out on size or bend, then so will anything they make. Glass can flex so we did make compensations for any twists or non symmetries that we found - if it looked like it was out a bit. Like I said a photocopy of a photocopy of a photo copy. There are few if any OEM w/s kicking around to make an accurate copy of these days for the 914.
When we were making replacement glass, accuracy was not that critical as it was made to a sample of god know what quality. Bob at the local auto glass could fiddle with it to make fit. OEM was more demanding since they would not tolerate stuff like that on the production line. Thats why they have tolerances to meet. Bob doesn't have those tolerances.
If that is a legit licensed use of the Porsche parts logo, it should be made to OEM data from Porsche - if I correctly understood the use of that logo. XYG will only have made theirs on the basis of a piece of glass they found.
I have a replacement w/s in the box from the Porsche dealer... I will need to check if I have that logo on mine...