Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What went wrong?
914World.com > The 914 Forums > 914World Garage
Pages: 1, 2
Dave_Darling
Distributor. Check that distributor. Do not f**k with the carbs, do not pass go, do not collect $200. Make sure that the distributor is in the right place. Rotate the engine until both valves on #1 are slack, then check where the distributor rotor is pointing. If it's not pointing at the distributor cap terminal that is connected to the #1 cylinder, it's wrong and the car will have one heck of a time starting.

Verify this first. Then make sure that the plug wires follow the firing order as you go around the distributor: 1-4-3-2. If you get the wires wrong, the car either won't start or will run like s**t.

Static timing is basically done by turning the engine by hand until it is at TDC for #1, and turning the distributor so the points are just opening (or could be just closing; I forget which triggers the spark!). Forget 7 degrees or whatever, setting it to TDC will make it close enough for the car to start.

Verify the spark, make sure your distributor is in the right place, then set the static timing so you're somewhere close. The car should be able to run at that point, unless the fuel or the compression is messed up somehow.

--DD
Superhawk996
Sorry - not trying to over simplify

However tuning is an iterative process. Airflow affects idle mix, mix affects idle speed, idle speed affects timing (due to centrifugal, mechanical advance on 009), and synch between the two carbs goes right back to affecting airflow.

All the above are interrelated to Venturi and jetting.

It’s anything but simple. But it needs to be worked through in a methodical way with each incremental adjustment becoming smaller.

Since you never got to a stable idle below 1200 rpm per your original post I can only conclude that something was not adjusted properly.

Your most recent post of having popping and backfiring could at a bare minimum be tied to it getting lean as you transition off idle.
Superhawk996
QUOTE(Dave_Darling @ Mar 20 2023, 10:58 PM) *

Distributor. Check that distributor. Do not f**k with the carbs, do not pass go, do not collect $200. Make sure that the distributor is in the right place. Rotate the engine until both valves on #1 are slack, then check where the distributor rotor is pointing. If it's not pointing at the distributor cap terminal that is connected to the #1 cylinder, it's wrong and the car will have one heck of a time starting.

Verify this first. Then make sure that the plug wires follow the firing order as you go around the distributor: 1-4-3-2. If you get the wires wrong, the car either won't start or will run like s**t.

Static timing is basically done by turning the engine by hand until it is at TDC for #1, and turning the distributor so the points are just opening (or could be just closing; I forget which triggers the spark!). Forget 7 degrees or whatever, setting it to TDC will make it close enough for the car to start.

Verify the spark, make sure your distributor is in the right place, then set the static timing so you're somewhere close. The car should be able to run at that point, unless the fuel or the compression is messed up somehow.

--DD


agree.gif I sort of assumed you have done this when you said you have it running And had verified timing.

Note: the moment when the points OPEN is when the spark is triggered.
brant
Taking the carbs off will effect the linkage

Having unbalanced carb linkage can causing significant popping and back fire

It’s a systemic that requires each step to be correct
Type 47
QUOTE(Dave_Darling @ Mar 20 2023, 07:58 PM) *

Distributor. Check that distributor. Do not f**k with the carbs, do not pass go, do not collect $200. Make sure that the distributor is in the right place. Rotate the engine until both valves on #1 are slack, then check where the distributor rotor is pointing. If it's not pointing at the distributor cap terminal that is connected to the #1 cylinder, it's wrong and the car will have one heck of a time starting.

Verify this first. Then make sure that the plug wires follow the firing order as you go around the distributor: 1-4-3-2. If you get the wires wrong, the car either won't start or will run like s**t.

Static timing is basically done by turning the engine by hand until it is at TDC for #1, and turning the distributor so the points are just opening (or could be just closing; I forget which triggers the spark!). Forget 7 degrees or whatever, setting it to TDC will make it close enough for the car to start.

Verify the spark, make sure your distributor is in the right place, then set the static timing so you're somewhere close. The car should be able to run at that point, unless the fuel or the compression is messed up somehow.

--DD

checked the valves, there slack, rotor pointing @#1. checked the wires and replugged them to make sure good contact.

car runs but pops, sputters, and backfires.
Type 47
QUOTE(brant @ Mar 21 2023, 05:48 AM) *

Taking the carbs off will effect the linkage

Having unbalanced carb linkage can causing significant popping and back fire

It’s a systemic that requires each step to be correct


we did tighten up the linkage. It may be time to get a better one though.
Type 47
QUOTE(Superhawk996 @ Mar 20 2023, 08:02 PM) *

Sorry - not trying to over simplify

However tuning is an iterative process. Airflow affects idle mix, mix affects idle speed, idle speed affects timing (due to centrifugal, mechanical advance on 009), and synch between the two carbs goes right back to affecting airflow.

All the above are interrelated to Venturi and jetting.

It’s anything but simple. But it needs to be worked through in a methodical way with each incremental adjustment becoming smaller.

Since you never got to a stable idle below 1200 rpm per your original post I can only conclude that something was not adjusted properly.

Your most recent post of having popping and backfiring could at a bare minimum be tied to it getting lean as you transition off idle.


We did have it idling OK before I replaced the plug wires. I should have mentioned that. I was idling OK but still a slight bit of vibration/shake. When I replaced the wires it ran smoother but idle had move up from about 900 to 1200.
nditiz1
If the car pops stutters backfires at IDLE here are the things to check:

Idle circuit is dirty - are the carbs clean? Have they been cleaned?
Mixture screws are set too lean - richen them up to see if the popping goes away.
Get the Syncrometer on the throats and see if all 4 are in sync. You don't need linkage at this step.

Timing could be off, but I believe you ran it up to 3500 and set the timing to 27/ the mark on the pulley. If you did, then the timing is correct, no need to touch the timing anymore.

Getting a smooth idle of around 1000-1100 is the key right now. You can worry about smoothness up to 3500 in a later step.

EDIT - Adjust idle speed with the carb idle speed adjusters which will in turn adjust the vac pull so double check they are back in sync. When you want to make the car smooth throughout the RPM band you will need to use the syncrometer to check the vac pull at a few different intervals up to ~3000 rpm. Hold the rpm steady at 1500, check both sides, 2000 check both sides, 2500 check both sides. Each interval should have the same pull which means the linkage is in sync.

EDIT2 - some engines like to idle at a higher RPM then 950. 1200 is a little on the high side I would shoot for between 1000-1100. The best budget linkage is the CSP center pull. You can see it on Zach's latest 2.3 PMB engine.
brant
QUOTE(Type 47 @ Mar 21 2023, 09:16 AM) *

QUOTE(brant @ Mar 21 2023, 05:48 AM) *

Taking the carbs off will effect the linkage

Having unbalanced carb linkage can causing significant popping and back fire

It’s a systemic that requires each step to be correct


we did tighten up the linkage. It may be time to get a better one though.



even a worn out linkage can be balanced... it just won't hold it well over time
balancing the linkage ensures both banks open the butterflies at exactly the same time
and does not create a lean condition (popping) on one bank...

after a good baseline balance is found
then fine tuning can be done with the carb balance screws
technicalninja
QUOTE(Type 47 @ Mar 20 2023, 09:23 PM) *

QUOTE(ChrisFoley @ Mar 20 2023, 04:35 PM) *

with a timing light while the engine is running.

We did get it running, kind of. So we used a timing light. But i'm not sure how to use it. I was able to hold rpm at 3,500 while it was scoped and the mark was there.


I'm not sure if the 914s have a full advance timing mark but most cars don't.

If a standard style mark (usually idle with vac lines removed from dist) is being used and he saw that mark at 3,500 rpm he may still be way off on his timing.
3,500 will usually have almost all of the mechanical advance in and some of the vac adv/retard in.

I am not a 914 timing guru yet but I'd expect that the "timing" would be way the hell out at 3500 rpm if I could see the timing marks in the indicator. I'd expect 25 degrees + of advance at that speed.

Ignition function and timing FIRST. Then setting up fuel, balance airflow, set throttle linkage second.

The linkage has to be adjusted, just being "tight" is not being adjusted.
Replacing linkage before understanding how the linkage is to be adjusted will only further the OPs frustration with this process IMO.

On my 914 we didn't even get feeler gauges out to check points. A dwell meter was used from the start. I had to find my dwell meter as I hadn't used it in 20 years.
It took longer to find that critter than it took to set the points...

Just checked my "tune up" specs tag on my 75 L-jet 1.8. It says timing is to be 7.5 degrees advance at 850 +/- 50 rpm with vacuum hoses to distributor removed...
So the Germans are using a "normal" timing procedure and if he's seeing the marks at 3500rpm he is 25+ degrees RETARDED!
It is completely IMPOSSIBLE to adjust carburators at these timing settings.

The distributor should be twisted toward advance 20+ degrees.

Get it running with a slightly lose distributor clamp and try to twist it either way.
One direction it will get worse and the other it will clean up.

I can set what I call "base" timing with a timing light hooked up to the coil wire and the fuel system disabled. I'd want to see the timing mark in the window without the car running. The coil wire will flash 4 times for 2 revolutions and two of those flashes will be on the marks. two will not but your brain will overlook them and all you will see will be the marks themselves.

Your timing is still WAY out. That has to be addressed first before the carbs are messed with.

If my son had completely removed a pair of ITB carbs before we diagnosed what was wrong with the car I'd kill him.

If he left the intakes wide open, I'd bring him back to life and kill him again...

I don't use rags for closing off open intakes. Had too many sucked into engines when they were turned over by accident, I use the aluminum tape (has the paper covering the sticky side). This stuff doesn't break, and it peels back off nicely when you need to remove it. Nothing gets into intakes.
technicalninja
QUOTE(nditiz1 @ Mar 21 2023, 10:29 AM) *



Timing could be off, but I believe you ran it up to 3500 and set the timing to 27/ the mark on the pulley. If you did, then the timing is correct, no need to touch the timing

And here is where my 914 lack of knowledge might be hurting me...

If it really has a timing mark of 27 degrees, then that is a mechanical advance fully in mark and it SHOULD be set at high RPM.

If this is the case my previous post is hogwash...

I was not aware of a high speed mark and I apologize if this is the case...
nditiz1
Yes please retract your post biggrin.gif

Just so we are clear, there are at least 2 ways to set the full advance timing with a timing light at 3500rpm. As the OP did it with the gun having no digital advance OR set to 0 you should see the mark of 27 degrees on the wheel or one you have placed on the wheel (follow the guide on how to create).

The second way is to set your gun to 27 and line it up to the 0 mark on the pulley, both ways will get you the full advance.

He is working with a 009 which has no vac cannister on it. It is crude but works. Be sure to plug any open vac ports on the carbs that could introduce additional unwanted air. The SVDA is one of the best cheap distros you can have with your dual carb setup.
technicalninja
Yep, I'm sorry I may have added to the confusion.

I'll never retract something I post in error. I'll allow my lack of knowledge to be in full view of all.

I will apologize and re-post if I'm wrong, however.

You should notice that I was damn close to what the timing should be at that RPM.

I posted 25+degrees at 3500 rpm. I was 2 degrees off!
I just pulled that number out of my knowledge base in my memory.

Red mark is 27 and 0 mark is TDC.

How did Porsche expect technicians to be able to set timing to 7.5 advance at 850 rpm as my timing sticker states?

I wasn't aware of any timing lights that could do advance back then...

I started doing this stuff professionally (all this means is being paid) in 1982.
ClayPerrine
Just so you know, the 009 is a terrible distributor for a VW Type IV engine. The advance curve is completely wrong for it. IIRC, I don't think you can actually get 27 degrees at 3500 RPM with an 009 without having the base timing really off.


There are 4 things needed to make an internal combustion engine run, and they can be remembered with the acronym "FAST"

Fuel
Air
Spark
Timing


Fuel - you have that and you can adjust the carbs after it is running
Air - the engine is making compression
Spark - you verified that already
Timing - Start with that.

How I do it.
Take out the #1 spark plug. Put in the hose from a compression tester. Using a remote starter button, crank the engine over while keeping your thumb over the end of the compression tester hose. When it blows your thumb off the hose, you are on the compression stroke.

Now turn the engine until the 0 mark is in the timing marks in the fan housing. Make the rotor in the distributor point to the left front of the car. Reinstall the cap and put the wires on. The two plug wires on the right side of the motor connect to the two distributor towers on the right side. The two plug wires on the left side of the motor are crossed, i.e. the front spark plug connects to the rear distributor tower, and the rear spark plug connects to the front distributor tower.

Turn the motor until you have about 8 degrees advance on the timing marks. Then hook a test light to the points wire and hook the other end to the positive battery post. Turn the distributor back and forth until the light just goes out. That sets the static timing.

Hook the points lead back up to the coil and the car should start. You will need to make sure the carbs are properly synced at idle. Once you do that, you can then take the engine to 3500 RPM and check the timing is a 27 degrees.


I hope this helps.


Superhawk996
QUOTE(technicalninja @ Mar 21 2023, 11:39 AM) *

How did Porsche expect technicians to be able to set timing to 7.5 advance at 850 rpm as my timing sticker states?


1.8L engine has a 7.5 degree timing mark on the impeller.

At this point with so many parts having been swapped mix and match on 914s you’re liable to find a 7.5 degree mark on others including those that may have been added at a rebuild.

As a rough approximation 7 degrees is about 3/4 of the distance between impeller blades.

Click to view attachment
nditiz1
009 should have no problem getting to the base. Its curve closely resembles the 034 SVDA. Reason why the SVDA is better is because it eliminates the "flat spot" on acceleration and makes it so you dont need to run super rich to over come it.
technicalninja
QUOTE(Superhawk996 @ Mar 21 2023, 12:16 PM) *

QUOTE(technicalninja @ Mar 21 2023, 11:39 AM) *

How did Porsche expect technicians to be able to set timing to 7.5 advance at 850 rpm as my timing sticker states?


1.8L engine has a 7.5 degree timing mark on the impeller.

At this point with so many parts having been swapped mix and match on 914s you’re liable to find a 7.5 degree mark on others including those that may have been added at a rebuild.

As a rough approximation 7 degrees is about 3/4 of the distance between impeller blades.

Click to view attachment


Thanks again SH...
My 75 1.8 blower is still in the car. I have a 73 2.0l core I got from Mark Heard completely apart and it does not have the 7.5 indicator etched on it.
I did post that I was not a 914 timing Guru yet...
Guess what, I was RIGHT!
And now I'm a little bit smarter because of this thread.
cgnj
Hi,
You never said what fixed your no start problem. Something did. Care to share?

Carb setup - I have limited Webber experience. I prefer Dellortto. In either case I never open more than one air bypass screw per side.
I generally follow this procedure aircooled.net Carb sync


Type 47
QUOTE(cgnj @ Mar 21 2023, 11:29 AM) *

Hi,
You never said what fixed your no start problem. Something did. Care to share?

Carb setup - I have limited Webber experience. I prefer Dellortto. In either case I never open more than one air bypass screw per side.
I generally follow this procedure aircooled.net Carb sync

Carlos,

while we did get the engine fired it's far from fixed. I will be reading your carb instructions next, thanks for posting the link.
Type 47
QUOTE(Superhawk996 @ Mar 21 2023, 09:16 AM) *

QUOTE(technicalninja @ Mar 21 2023, 11:39 AM) *

How did Porsche expect technicians to be able to set timing to 7.5 advance at 850 rpm as my timing sticker states?


1.8L engine has a 7.5 degree timing mark on the impeller.

At this point with so many parts having been swapped mix and match on 914s you’re liable to find a 7.5 degree mark on others including those that may have been added at a rebuild.

As a rough approximation 7 degrees is about 3/4 of the distance between impeller blades.

Click to view attachment


thanks for posting this.

Is there any difference between the 1.8 and 2.0?

the pic below is the actual impeller from this engine. It had some broken fins so we swapped it with another one from a spare 2.0. Nothing but the 27 line, no 0, no 7.5 mark.

The impeller we put on it was from GA006291 a late 73' 2.0 I believe. It has the 0 and the 27 mark. I will have to look closely at it, now I know where to look for the black line.

I hear what your saying about "at this point" I do believe this engine is original to this car; both have low production #'s 00696 for the car and GC000243 for the engine.

Then again it had a degree plate on the front of the engine like a bus would have.

Click to view attachment
technicalninja
Just looked at the link provided for syncing carbs.
Very good into. I have both tools and far. far prefer the snail gauge.

One thing that link didn't provide was what I do now FIRST.

I'll set the throttle stops on the carbs (commonly I was doing 3 two bl side drafts) to have the same openings when you look through the carb when off the car.

I'd back the throttle stops out until the blades actually seated and then chose one carb to be my standard. I'd open the throttle stop approx 1/2 turn from blade closed and then set the others in much the same way.
I'd then hold the carbs and look through the bores with a light source behind the carb,
I'd adjust # 2-3 to have the same width crescent of light coming that will be visible from the light source. On an IDF which has a adjustment between the two bores I'd set this adjustment next.
I'd bolt them on and hook up linkage and adjust the linkage to make all three carbs open at the same time.

Really important to set any mechanical throttle for WFO right from the start. Have someone bury the accelerator hard into the floorboard and verify the carbs can just hit wide open without any undue stress happening in the linkage.
All throttle cables should be adjusted for wide open first!
Most designs will then have the extra play at the beginning of the throttle stroke and you will not be able to damage. bend, or knock your adjustments out by flooring it.

After you have this together make sure the throttles all open at the same time VIA the accelerator pedal. Adjust individual linkages accordingly.

I found adjusting this crap, by eyeball, when the car is not running got 90% of the sync job done and the use of the snail tool was for minor finish up adjusting only.

The above mentioned procedure decreased the time involved for me by 75%.
Sometimes just eyeballing it was dead nut on.
It turned what can be a frustrating job into gravy...
Type 47
QUOTE(nditiz1 @ Mar 21 2023, 07:29 AM) *


Idle circuit is dirty - are the carbs clean? Have they been cleaned?
Mixture screws are set too lean - richen them up to see if the popping goes away.



The carbs where taken apart and cleaned enough to install what was in a rebuild kit. They were not completely taken every single piece apart.

by richen them I'm assuming you mean backing the screws out
Type 47
QUOTE(ClayPerrine @ Mar 21 2023, 08:48 AM) *

Just so you know, the 009 is a terrible distributor for a VW Type IV engine. The advance curve is completely wrong for it. IIRC, I don't think you can actually get 27 degrees at 3500 RPM with an 009 without having the base timing really off.


There are 4 things needed to make an internal combustion engine run, and they can be remembered with the acronym "FAST"

Fuel
Air
Spark
Timing


Fuel - you have that and you can adjust the carbs after it is running
Air - the engine is making compression
Spark - you verified that already
Timing - Start with that.

How I do it.
Take out the #1 spark plug. Put in the hose from a compression tester. Using a remote starter button, crank the engine over while keeping your thumb over the end of the compression tester hose. When it blows your thumb off the hose, you are on the compression stroke.

Now turn the engine until the 0 mark is in the timing marks in the fan housing. Make the rotor in the distributor point to the left front of the car. Reinstall the cap and put the wires on. The two plug wires on the right side of the motor connect to the two distributor towers on the right side. The two plug wires on the left side of the motor are crossed, i.e. the front spark plug connects to the rear distributor tower, and the rear spark plug connects to the front distributor tower.

Turn the motor until you have about 8 degrees advance on the timing marks. Then hook a test light to the points wire and hook the other end to the positive battery post. Turn the distributor back and forth until the light just goes out. That sets the static timing.

Hook the points lead back up to the coil and the car should start. You will need to make sure the carbs are properly synced at idle. Once you do that, you can then take the engine to 3500 RPM and check the timing is a 27 degrees.


I hope this helps.


Yes, all of this helps. Thank you.
nditiz1
There are definitely different levels of cleaning. Even to go as far as dipping them in Chem dip. The rebuild kit will break the carb down enough to get most areas clean. You need to pay attention to the passages and shoot brake cleaner and compressed air through them.

Did you perform the float adjustment procedure. Very key to setting carbs up?

Ensure you have proper fuel pressure to the carbs (3psi)

Dialing in carbs is not difficult, but it can be time consuming. You also need to make sure the the engine is warm.

Since it will at least idle you already have a base. Pop off the linkage on side so it does not interfere with getting them to idle smoothly. Use the snail gauge to ensure the vac on both L and R are the same. Also ensure the the throats on the same carb are also in sync. The bypass screws should start all the way closed. These screws will be opened to increase the vac on that throat. In the perfect world all throats will be the same as the pull on each cylinder is perfectly matched, but I have yet to encounter this so minor adjustment is always needed.

Now that all 4 carbs are in sync you can use the Idle speed screw to bring the idle to around 1000. When you do this your sync will be off so readjust L and R.

Now you should be running ~1000 and the Land R are in sync. Start turning the mixture screws out from all the way in about 3 turns. Slowly screw it in until the engine starts to stumble. If the idle never drops you could have an issue (dirt) with that throat. The point at which the engine starts to stumble means it is going lean. I usually back the screw out a half turn or quarter depending on the jet size. This will get you close to best lean idle. If the engine is worn the same all 4 mixture screws should be within a quarter to half turn of each other. It is a good practice to perform this step a few times as it could increase you idle. This will make you move the speed screws out to lower idle which will change the mixture. It is a cycle to get everything into a harmonious balance.

If you have made it this far the engine should be pretty smooth. If not you could have any number of issues, dirty carbs, intake leak, exhaust leak.

The last step is to sync the carbs under throttle from linkage. You use the sync gauge again holding different RPM to ensure the L and R are the same. If one side is pulling more then adjust the linkage. You never need to touch mixture, idle speed, or bypass screws.

The last step involves driving, getting a feel, and using a AFR meter to possibly rejet.
Rand
QUOTE(Aerostatwv @ Mar 15 2023, 03:21 PM) *

Sounds like a bad condenser to me.

I'd be interested in your explanation of why and how a condenser would cause this.

I'm also curious to know what color the spark is?? (like yellow, or bright blue?)
Type 47
QUOTE(nditiz1 @ Mar 21 2023, 04:37 PM) *

There are definitely different levels of cleaning. Even to go as far as dipping them in Chem dip. The rebuild kit will break the carb down enough to get most areas clean. You need to pay attention to the passages and shoot brake cleaner and compressed air through them.

not chem dipped but carb cleaner and air (son thinks BC is to caustic)

Did you perform the float adjustment procedure. Very key to setting carbs up?

probably not, son's tech school taught nothing about carbs, we probably assumed carbs taken off properly running car was good for a baseline

Ensure you have proper fuel pressure to the carbs (3psi)
That's where the FPR is set



will follow your tuning advise. I'm hoping this experience is teaching someone some patience and understanding.

BTW, didn't work on the car today. Want to soak all this info in and move forward tomorrow.
ChrisFoley
That red line on your impeller is the 27 degree mark, which is what you want to see with the timing light at 3000-3500 rpm. Actually, a little past that mark, so you are at 28 deg. is even better.
bossboy302
TYPE 47: you never have explained how you got from "what happened-not running" to "Got it to run".

Even if it still runs poorly, you solved something.........what?
Type 47
QUOTE(bossboy302 @ Mar 22 2023, 09:40 AM) *

TYPE 47: you never have explained how you got from "what happened-not running" to "Got it to run".

Even if it still runs poorly, you solved something.........what?


we set the static timing and then cranked it until it fired. We have to keep a hand on the linkage to keep it running. it doesn't idle on it's own yet.

We ran out of time and haven't been able to work on it further.

will update on the progress. when we work on it next, maybe tomorrow or Friday.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2024 Invision Power Services, Inc.