QUOTE(Superhawk996 @ May 25 2020, 07:12 PM)
Since Porsche bearings are sold individually, I'll likely order 2 half shells and see if there is any promise there without having to go whole hog on a hunch.
OK so #1 main bearing half shells came in and I thought I'd post the results.
This single OEM Porsche main bearing #1 is $75 per ½ shell. $150 for the bearing pair. Not a set – just Porsche OEM bearing #1.
I paid $165 for a whole SET of #1 - #7 bearings from Glyco – the OEM manufacturer.
I’ve been reading stories on interwebz and the bird forum that Porsche 911 bearings are better and have tighter tolerances. In the nature of a skeptic I wasn’t sure I could believe Web info so I ordered just this one bearing for comparison
Yup – it’s true.
Click to view attachmentGlyco aftermarket bearing set
Click to view attachmentPorsche bearing ordered from Pelican - delivered in Porsche bag, Porsche p/n on bag and on bearing.
Click to view attachmentAlthough the OEM Porsche bearing bears the Glyco makers mark, it has a Porsche part number and different markings. Even the maker mark is slightly different. I'm not suspecting counterfit parts but see it as evidence that these Glyco aftermarket bearings are indeed different.
Click to view attachmentClearly made in a different plant and/or via different sorting / handling / marking process.
More importantly these bearings would give me a tighter fit by around 0.0009” or nearly 0.001”. That is huge. I’d like to target 0.0025”-.003” max but was measuring 0.004”+ on the Glyco bearings with both plastigauge (well really .003” gauge that didn’t appear to crush fully) and the math between bore gauge of the bearing and the crank as mastered off the micrometer used on the crank.
Yes - I only measured 1 point on this comparison but it aligns with the postings on the bird forums about differences as posted by those that invested more time measuring two or three points per bearing.
Very frustrating.
Looks like I may end up having to pony up $850 dollars for the OEM Porsche Bearings. The other option is upgrade pump to 76' 4 rib pump or maybe a 930 pump but that is just counting on pump volume to mask larger clearances that would be present by using the aftermarket bearings.
Other option is grind crank undersize and be sure they grind to the high spec and then polish down as needed. Not ideal either.
Time to think about this a bit more.